PDA

View Full Version : Why Eli Manning Shouldn't Have Anything Left to Prove



Shockdisnation03
03-12-2012, 02:57 PM
There's nothing left to discuss here, folks. Eli Manning is an elite quarterback.

There's no denying it, and there's nothing anyone can say to slight his recent Super Bowl win.

The New York Giants were once 80-1 odds to win this year's Super Bowl. I guess miracles do happen.

Let's break this down, though:

Eli Manning now has more Super Bowl rings than Drew Brees, Aaron Rodgers, Peyton Manning and Archie Manning.

There was even some talk of Cam Newton already being better than Eli Manning.

Ridiculous.

Tom Brady is a sure-fire Hall of Famer, right?

How many quarterbacks can say they beat Brady the last three times they played—two of those times in Super Bowls?

Manning not only has two Super Bowls now, he was also the MVP in both of them.

The best part is that he's 31 years old with a dominant defensive line and, at the very worst, two stud wide receivers going into next year.

Eli Manning has nothing left to prove on the elite front, but a couple more good seasons out of him wouldn't hurt his case for Canton.

SweetZombieJesus
03-12-2012, 03:04 PM
He's already in very elite company -- multiple SB winners.

Can he go up even further?

Can he get where Tom Brady can't -- in the company of Montana and Bradshaw? 4 rings?

For better or worse getting up there puts you in the "all time" conversation.

G-Man67
03-12-2012, 03:05 PM
well the nice thing with Eli is his approach never changes ... he doesn't play harder when the media says he has something to prove and he certainly won't take it easy now that the media wants to pre-induct him into the Hall of Fame</P>


he just loves playing football and competing and being around his teammates and having it on his shoulders down 4 with 1:30 left ... i really think he is able to tune it all out ... he's just in his backyard playing 5 on 5 and he knows it's much more fun when you win</P>

Shockdisnation03
03-12-2012, 03:07 PM
well the nice thing with Eli is his approach never changes ... he doesn't play harder when the media says he has something to prove and he certainly won't take it easy now that the media wants to pre-induct him into the Hall of Fame</P>


he just loves playing football and competing and being around his teammates and having it on his shoulders down 4 with 1:30 left ... i really think he is able to tune it all out ... he's just in his backyard playing 5 on 5 and he knows it's much more fun when you win</P>

I so agree on that comment

GameTime
03-12-2012, 03:17 PM
well the nice thing with Eli is his approach never changes ... he doesn't play harder when the media says he has something to prove and he certainly won't take it easy now that the media wants to pre-induct him into the Hall of Fame</P>


he just loves playing football and competing and being around his teammates and having it on his shoulders down 4 with 1:30 left ... i really think he is able to tune it all out ... he's just in his backyard playing 5 on 5 and he knows it's much more fun when you win</P>


</P>


well said....</P>


and to add to that in regard to the OP orig topic. </P>


Eli has a lot left to prove to himself. He has always been his own critic and he only cares about getting better every season so he can help the org, current team mates, and himself win games and championships. </P>


</P>

burier
03-12-2012, 03:18 PM
Eli has pleanty to prove.

He still has 3 QBs who are by consensus seen as better than he is. He can prove that he is the class of the NFL.

He can prove that he's the greatest clutch quarterback in the history of football.

He can prove that he's the greatest big moment quarterback in the history of football.

He can prove that he's the greatest quarterback in the modern era of football period.

There's still quite a few more chapters to be written in The Book

FBomb
03-12-2012, 03:37 PM
Like the Eli Gatorade ad says:

Q: What do you say to the doubters?
A: Nothing. You already told them twice.

nygsb42champs
03-12-2012, 04:17 PM
Nobody has said he does. He is elite. End of discussion.

NYG 5
03-12-2012, 04:24 PM
He's gotten to the top 5 regular season ranking, top 3 playoff ranking. He's on the cusp of quarterbacking a dynasty. If he gets past that, he gets into GOAT conversation, and people start hyping college prospects as the next Eli Manning.

The only problem I can see happening is a disastrous injury happening, and Reese not being able to reform the team with young replacements, and being encumbered with salary cap woes.

GameTime
03-12-2012, 09:00 PM
Eli has pleanty to prove. He still has 3 QBs who are by consensus seen as better than he is. He can prove that he is the class of the NFL. He can prove that he's the greatest clutch quarterback in the history of football. He can prove that he's the greatest big moment quarterback in the history of football. He can prove that he's the greatest quarterback in the modern era of football period. There's still quite a few more chapters to be written in The Book</P>


the point you may be missing is he really only would probably want to prove those things you mentioned to himself for the benfit of his team. Seems Eli couldn't care less what most others actually think.</P>

nygfanmaybe
03-13-2012, 05:03 AM
He has proven that he is the real deal...a long time ago. His tallest mountain to climb when it comes to proving things is right here on this MB.

Some people here are either really tough nuts to crack or trolls...take your pick.

TuckYou
03-13-2012, 08:27 AM
He has to prove he can do it again, and again, and again, without a defense, without WRs, without a RB, without a coach, without being lucky... ect. </P>


Thats what they will continue to say.</P>

jax5338
03-13-2012, 10:23 AM
Eli has pleanty to prove.

He still has 3 QBs who are by consensus seen as better than he is. He can prove that he is the class of the NFL.

He can prove that he's the greatest clutch quarterback in the history of football.

He can prove that he's the greatest big moment quarterback in the history of football.

He can prove that he's the greatest quarterback in the modern era of football period.

There's still quite a few more chapters to be written in The Book

this.

although he probably doesnt talk about it or seem to show it eli definitely wants to be THE BEST. you dont work as hard as he does in order to just gain a little notoriety. is it greedy im expecting at least one more superbowl during his tenure as giants QB because i know he is that hungry?

MikeIsaGiant
03-13-2012, 10:25 AM
He has nothing to prove to anyone else, but to us fans he does. More playoff games, more championships, more SBs!!

I don't want to be greedy, but Eli is one of the best, if NOT, the best QB we've had. Let's keep him at the benchmark of this organization by winning more SBs.

Manning's name will go down for ages

burier
03-13-2012, 10:26 AM
Eli has pleanty to prove. He still has 3 QBs who are by consensus seen as better than he is. He can prove that he is the class of the NFL. He can prove that he's the greatest clutch quarterback in the history of football. He can prove that he's the greatest big moment quarterback in the history of football. He can prove that he's the greatest quarterback in the modern era of football period. There's still quite a few more chapters to be written in The Book</P>


the point you may be missing is he really only would probably want to prove those things you mentioned to himself for the benfit of his team. Seems Eli couldn't care less what most others actually think.</P>

If we're not talking about what others think there's no thread.

The OP says theres "Nothing left to discuss" yet there is pleanty.

jjj45
03-13-2012, 11:01 AM
Eli hasn't had anything to prove for the last 4 years. At least to rational people.

Harooni
03-13-2012, 11:26 AM
Eli has won a lot of us over, certainly the best "clutch" qb i'v ever seen. there is no stat for it, but if we are down one score he can make it happen.