PDA

View Full Version : Should Eli Manning be considered a Top 20 quarterback of all time?



wallerstein
04-22-2012, 11:56 AM
Right now on Rankopedia.com in their "Best NFL Quaterback of All Time" Eli Manning does not even make the Top 25. <FONT color=#000000>After winning two Super Bowls, doesn't Eli deserve more consideration? </FONT>

GameTime
04-22-2012, 12:06 PM
not with hopefully another 6 years or so to go.......
save rankings like that towrds the end of his career...

FBomb
04-22-2012, 12:27 PM
uh-oh....another list that Eli is being 'dissed' on.......guess we should cut him. How can we ever win another SB without Eli getting props on an arbitrary list?

B&RWarrior
04-22-2012, 01:41 PM
I think all this talk of the "greatest of all time" for Eli is premature. I only have a problem with one name on that list- Donovan McNabb. No way is he better than Eli.

rebelfan1966
04-22-2012, 01:46 PM
Don't know how Donnie Mac made the list.... but I agree with everyone else.... Lets wait until he retires to talk about this list.

giantsfan420
04-22-2012, 02:02 PM
how the f is Vince Young on that list???lmfao

Ntegrase96
04-22-2012, 02:30 PM
I think if Eli is not on there, then Roethlissberger and McNabb shouldn't be either.

Kurt Warner probably shouldn't be on the list either. He's had some pretty good seasons and made it to the superbowl 3 times and with two different teams, but he's also been a back-up in between some of those appearances. When he was good he was great, and when he was bad he was average.

RoanokeFan
04-22-2012, 02:44 PM
Right now on Rankopedia.com in their "Best NFL Quaterback of All Time" Eli Manning does not even make the Top 25. <font color="#000000">After winning two Super Bowls, doesn't Eli deserve more consideration? </font>

This is a "whole body of work" issue and Eli's not there yet.

BigBlue1971
04-22-2012, 03:07 PM
Eli still has 6-8 years left as a starter. if he stays in this offense he will shatter team records and prolly knock down league records along the way!</P>


maybe when hes done your subject line will read ".............Top 5 of ...........?</P>

simms56
04-22-2012, 03:11 PM
After looking at a few of the lists on there I would say the average rater is 13, therefore I wouldn't put a whole lot of weight in it.

buddy33
04-22-2012, 03:15 PM
Who cares?

JMFP2
04-22-2012, 07:13 PM
I think you can't judge any player until they've retired and been out of the league for a few years.</P>


There isn't a QB in the NFL right now I'd take over Eli, but I wouldn't judge his "all-time" status at this point.</P>

Morehead State
04-22-2012, 07:27 PM
Right now on Rankopedia.com in their "Best NFL Quaterback of All Time" Eli Manning does not even make the Top 25. <FONT color=#000000>After winning two Super Bowls, doesn't Eli deserve more consideration? </FONT></P>


<FONT size=6>STOP!!!!!!</FONT></P>

RoanokeFan
04-22-2012, 07:30 PM
Right now on Rankopedia.com in their "Best NFL Quaterback of All Time" Eli Manning does not even make the Top 25. <font color="#000000">After winning two Super Bowls, doesn't Eli deserve more consideration? </font></p>


<font size="6">STOP!!!!!!</font></p>

<font size="6">IN THE NAME OF LOVE..... [6]</font>

Morehead State
04-22-2012, 08:35 PM
Right now on Rankopedia.com in their "Best NFL Quaterback of All Time" Eli Manning does not even make the Top 25. <FONT color=#000000>After winning two Super Bowls, doesn't Eli deserve more consideration? </FONT></P>


<FONT size=6>STOP!!!!!!</FONT></P>




<FONT size=6>IN THE NAME OF LOVE..... [6]</FONT>
</P>


<FONT size=6>BEFORE YOU BREAK MY HEART....</FONT></P>

Drez
04-22-2012, 09:08 PM
Right now on Rankopedia.com in their "Best NFL Quaterback of All Time" Eli Manning does not even make the Top 25. <font color="#000000">After winning two Super Bowls, doesn't Eli deserve more consideration? </font>

This is a "whole body of work" issue and Eli's not there yet.


Agreed. I love me some Eli, but except for very rare players, this isn't something you can judge until a player's career is over.

That being said, if Eli maintains the career arc he's had so far, it'll be safe to say that he will probably be regarded as a top 25 all time.

chasjay
04-22-2012, 09:24 PM
Right now on Rankopedia.com in their "Best NFL Quaterback of All Time" Eli Manning does not even make the Top 25. <font color="#000000">After winning two Super Bowls, doesn't Eli deserve more consideration? </font></p>


<font size="6">STOP!!!!!!</font></p>




<font size="6">IN THE NAME OF LOVE..... [6]</font>
</p>


<font size="6">BEFORE YOU BREAK MY HEART....</font></p>

Way to go guys, - that was Supreme!!

DragonSoul
04-23-2012, 03:55 AM
uh-oh....another list that Eli is being 'dissed' on.......guess we should cut him.* How can we ever win another SB without Eli getting props on an arbitrary list?here here

nygsb42champs
04-23-2012, 08:26 AM
Lets see how it plays out for another 6 or 7 years before we start putting him in that category.

SweetZombieJesus
04-23-2012, 09:35 AM
I'd rather not worry about this now, but there are 4 QBs with multiple SB MVPs.

Starr.
Montana.
Brady.
Eli.

NYG216
04-23-2012, 10:42 AM
This thread smells like spam.