PDA

View Full Version : All Giants team from last 25 years



BluTri10
04-23-2012, 07:25 PM
Since we just won another Super Bowl, I'd say it's a good time to sit back and think of the all Giants team from the last 25 years. Feel free to agree/disagree...Sorry to all you Lewis Tillman fans out there....


QB (2) - Eli Manning, Phil Simms
RB (3) - Tiki Barber, Brandon Jacobs, Rodney Hampton
FB (1) - Charles Way
WR (4) - Plaxico Burress, Hakeem Nicks, Amani Toomer, Victor Cruz
TE (3) - Mark Bavaro, Jeremy Shockey, Howard Cross
LT (2) - Brad Benson, David Diehl
LG (2) - Rich Seubert, Billy Ard
C (2) - Bart Oates, Shaun O'Hara
RG (2) - Chris Snee, Ron Stone
RT (2) - Karl Nelson, Kareem McKenzie

LE (2) - Michael Strahan, Justin Tuck
RE (2) - Jason Pierre-Paul, Leonard Marshall
DT (2) - Jim Burt, Erik Howard
LOLB (2) - Carl Banks, Michael Boley
ROLB (2) - Lawrence Taylor, Jesse Armstead
MLB (3) - Harry Carson, Antonio Pierce, Pepper Johnson
CB (4) - Mark Collins, Corey Webster, Jason Sehorn, Sam Madison
FS (2) - Antrel Rolle, Terry Kinard
SS (2) - Kenny Phillips, Myron Guyton

K (1) - Matt Bahr
P (1) - Sean Landeta
KR (2) - Ron Dixon, Dave Meggett
PR (1) - Dave Meggett


HC - Bill Parcells
OC - Tom Coughlin
DC - Bill Belichick

GmenFan1980
04-23-2012, 08:25 PM
Coughlin as our OC....why?

NYGRealityCheck
04-23-2012, 08:51 PM
Coughlin as our OC....why?

Cause it's Sean Payton in disguise... Bill Parcells and Tom Coughlin were special coaches in their own way...

anyway, don't forget Mike Pope for TE coach...

GiantLife615
04-23-2012, 09:01 PM
Bart Oates should be left all lists...trader...dirty 49er....Im not bitter ha

Matt C
04-23-2012, 09:06 PM
Feagles?

juice33s
04-23-2012, 09:55 PM
I'd put Phillipe sparks over Madison

BluTri10
04-23-2012, 10:04 PM
I was debating Landeta vs Feagles and Phillipi Sparks vs Sam Madison. Lanedta is on all 80s team...so I went with him...very debatable. I'd probably put Sparks over Madison though if I had to...

dayeh33
04-23-2012, 10:46 PM
Osi has to be on there somewhere

JJC7301
04-23-2012, 10:57 PM
Feagles?
Close but I go with landeta too.

JJC7301
04-23-2012, 10:58 PM
I'd put Phillipe sparks over Madison

Sparks stunk. Was reyna Thompson a CB?

NYG 5
04-23-2012, 11:01 PM
BJ AHEAD OF RODNEY HAMPTON? ARE YOU HIGH????

JJC7301
04-23-2012, 11:02 PM
Osi has to be on there somewhere
All the DEs mentioned above are are good against the run. No knock against Osi.

JJC7301
04-23-2012, 11:06 PM
I like the list except I'd take Carthon at FB. And there's probably a guard from the '80s who was better than Ron Stone, just can't think of the name right now.

fansince69
04-23-2012, 11:39 PM
Jumbo Elliot was the best left tackle we ever had I think he should be number 1...as far as the punter discussion,most of Feagles best ,prime years were not spent here with the Giants....Landettas were....Coughlin was never an OC....other than these points I agree

fansince69
04-23-2012, 11:41 PM
I'd put Phillipe sparks over Madison

Sparks stunk. Was reyna Thompson a CB?

Yes he was listed as a corner back but never really played anywhere but special teams.

BluTri10
04-24-2012, 05:01 AM
Gunners (2) - David Tyree, Reyna Thompson

nhpgiantsfan
04-24-2012, 10:40 AM
Since we just won another Super Bowl, I'd say it's a good time to sit back and think of the all Giants team from the last 25 years. Feel free to agree/disagree...Sorry to all you Lewis Tillman fans out there.... QB (2) - Eli Manning, Phil Simms RB (3) - Tiki Barber, Brandon Jacobs, Rodney Hampton FB (1) - Charles Way WR (4) - Plaxico Burress, Hakeem Nicks, Amani Toomer, Victor Cruz TE (3) - Mark Bavaro, Jeremy Shockey, Howard Cross LT (2) - Brad Benson, David Diehl LG (2) - Rich Seubert, Billy Ard C (2) - Bart Oates, Shaun O'Hara RG (2) - Chris Snee, Ron Stone RT (2) - Karl Nelson, Kareem McKenzie LE (2) - Michael Strahan, Justin Tuck RE (2) - Jason Pierre-Paul, Leonard Marshall DT (2) - Jim Burt, Erik Howard LOLB (2) - Carl Banks, Michael Boley ROLB (2) - Lawrence Taylor, Jesse Armstead MLB (3) - Harry Carson, Antonio Pierce, Pepper Johnson CB (4) - Mark Collins, Corey Webster, Jason Sehorn, Sam Madison FS (2) - Antrel Rolle, Terry Kinard SS (2) - Kenny Phillips, Myron Guyton K (1) - Matt Bahr P (1) - Sean Landeta KR (2) - Ron Dixon, Dave Meggett PR (1) - Dave Meggett HC - Bill Parcells OC - Tom Coughlin DC - Bill Belichick</P>


Carthon &gt; Way</P>


Jumbo Elliot &gt; Benson or Diehl</P>


William Roberts&gt; Seubert, 10 years 2 rings and prowbowl</P>


There must be someone that can replace Sam Madison on this list. He was here well after he was washed up.</P>


And it's hard to leave Osi off this list. If this list is truly for the past 25 years, then Osi should replace JPP for now.</P>

burier
04-24-2012, 11:16 AM
I'd put Phillipe sparks over Madison

B&RWarrior
04-24-2012, 12:09 PM
I'd put Phillipe sparks over Madison
</P>


</P>


Keith Hamilton should be on the list. Gibril Wilson &gt; Antrel Rolle, Joe Morris &gt; BJ even witht he injury. Jumbo Elliot&gt; DD. Carthon&gt; Way, Sparks&gt; Madison</P>

B&RWarrior
04-24-2012, 12:10 PM
</P>


Keith Hamilton should be on the list. Gibril Wilson &gt; Antrel Rolle, Joe Morris &gt; BJ even witht he injury. Jumbo Elliot&gt; DD. Carthon&gt; Way, Sparks&gt; Madison</P>

jax5338
04-24-2012, 04:12 PM
sam madison? is that so we can have personal foul penalties after 3rd down stops?

id take TT over sam any day.

Giants Of New Jersey
04-24-2012, 04:43 PM
chase blackburn on the kickoff team!!

JJC7301
04-24-2012, 11:03 PM
Jumbo Elliot was the best left tackle we ever had I think he should be number 1...as far as the punter discussion,most of Feagles best ,prime years were not spent here with the Giants....Landettas were....Coughlin was never an OC....other than these points I agree

You're right about Elliot -- hands down.

Rat_bastich
04-24-2012, 11:53 PM
What about Riesenberg? Raul Allegre? Ottis Anderson? Greg Jackson? Perry Williams? Everson Walls? Alot of these guys are better than the players from the modern Super Bowl teams.

BluTri10
04-24-2012, 11:56 PM
Definitely correct about Elliott. I should have put him on, no question. Riesenberg loses out to McKenzie...

Raul Allegre was great too -- I gotta admit, I'm a bit biased in selecting Matt Bahr. My brother was named after him...He was my dad's roommate when they played for the Penn State soccer team...!

TheIncredibleErk
04-25-2012, 09:30 AM
You forgot William Joseph at DT

Hahaha just kidding! But seriously, Keith Hamilton DT was a beast. He's the last DT we've had who was any kind of threat on passing downs. Dude got double digit sacks in a season more than once and averaged 6 sacks a season in 11 years

WR4Life
04-25-2012, 10:09 AM
Osi has to be on there somewhere

He's riding the bike over on the sidelines. Definitely the best at doing that in the last 25 years.

berya
04-26-2012, 08:22 AM
+1 Jumbo Elliot. Man was a great tackle for us.

Also Rodney freaking Hampton over Jacobs for me ANY DAY OF THE WEEK. Rodney did every game what Jacobs was supposed to do. All Rodney ever did was hit them hard and hit them often until he couldn't hit them no more.

As much as I love JPP I have to put Osi in there at this point.

Keith Hamilton was a beast and tough as nails has to be in there as well.

BluTri10
04-26-2012, 08:53 AM
I should have put Rodney over Jacobs, no question.


Notice how now, since we won two Super Bowls in the last 4 years...are having a harder time choosing the best players over the last 25 years...i.e. Feagles vs. Landeta and Osi vs. Pierre-Paul?

This little Super Bowl run adds a very interesting wrinkle in the historical context of this great franchise...

nhpgiantsfan
04-26-2012, 04:07 PM
What about Riesenberg? Raul Allegre? Ottis Anderson? Greg Jackson? Perry Williams? Everson Walls? Alot of these guys are better than the players from the modern Super Bowl teams.</P>


Greg Jackson was decent, but not better than Rolle or Phillips. Everson Walls was a real good CB but his good years were with the Cowboys, not with us.</P>


Collins and Webster are the best CB's we've had in the past 25 years.</P>

G-Man67
04-26-2012, 04:10 PM
Gunners (2) - David Tyree, Reyna Thompson</P>


good one</P>


i'd like to see "Little" Joe Morris on there</P>

I Bleed Blue 56
04-26-2012, 05:01 PM
No osi this list insane honestly jpp but osi should be on here. Aswell as keith hamilton the hammer. He was a solid DT

BluTri10
04-26-2012, 05:47 PM
How is this list insane?

* Osi is not better than JPP.
* Keith Hamilton's defenses never came up with big stops. He was solid DT -- but Erik Howard and Jim Burt were better -- in my humble opinion.

nhpgiantsfan
04-26-2012, 07:47 PM
How is this list insane?

* Osi is not better than JPP.
* Keith Hamilton's defenses never came up with big stops. He was solid DT -- but Erik Howard and Jim Burt were better -- in my humble opinion.
JPP is gonna be a much better player than Osi, but if this list is for the past 25 years then you have to go Osi over JPP.