PDA

View Full Version : In depth comparison of each of our 4 Super Bowl winning teams



BluTri10
05-03-2012, 07:44 PM
Quarterback
1. Phil Simms '86
2. Jeff Hostetler '90
3. Eli Manning '07
4. Eli Manning '11

MY CHOICE: Eli Manning '11

Running Backs
1. Joe Morris and Ottis Anderson '86
2. Ottis Anderson and Rodney Hampton '90
3. Brandon Jacobs and Ahmad Bradshaw '07
4. Brandon Jacobs and Ahmad Bradshaw '11

MY CHOICE: BRANDON JACOBS AND AHMAD BRADSHAW '07

Fullbacks
1. Maurice Carthon '86
2. Maurice Carthon '90
3. Madison Hedge**** '07
4. Henry Hynoski '11

MY CHOICE: MAURICE CARTHON '86

Wide Receivers
1. Bobby Johnson, Stacy Robinson, Lionel Manuel, Phil McConkey, Solomon Miller '86
2. Stephen Baker, Mark Ingram, Odessa Turner, Stacy Robinson, Lionel Manuel '90
3. Plaxico Burress, Amani Toomer, Steve Smith, David Tyree, Sinorice Moss '07
4. Hakeem Nicks, Victor Cruz, Mario Manningham, Domenik Hixon, Jerrel Jernigan '11

MY CHOICE: Hakeem Nicks, Victor Cruz, Mario Manningham, Domenik Hixon, Jerrel Jernigan

Tight Ends
1. Mark Bavaro, Zeke Mowatt '86
2. Mark Bavaro, Howard Cross, Bob Mrosko '90
3. Jeremy Shockey, Kevin Boss, Michael Matthews '07
4. Jake Ballard, Travis Beckum, Bear Pascoe '11

MY CHOICE: Mark Bavaro, Howard Cross, Bob Mrosko '90

Left Tackle
1. Brad Benson '86
2. Jumbo Elliott '90
3. Dave Diehl '07
4. Dave Diehl '11

MY CHOICE: BRAD BENSON '86

Left Guard
1. Billy Ard '86
2. William Roberts '90
3. Rich Seubert '07
4. Kevin Boothe '11

MY CHOICE: WILLIAM ROBERTS '90

Center
1. Bart Oates '86
2. Bart Oates '90
3. Shaun O'Hara '07
4. David Baas '11

MY CHOICE: BART OATES '90

Right Guard
1. Chris Godfrey '86
2. Eric Moore '90
3. Chris Snee '07
4. Chris Snee '11

MY CHOICE: CHRIS SNEE '11

Right Tackle
1. Karl Nelson '86
2. Doug Riesenberg '90
3. Kareem McKenzie '07
4. Kareem McKenzie '11

MY CHOICE: KARL NELSON '86

Right Defensive End
1. Leonard Marshall '86
2. Leonard Marshall '90
3. Osi Umenyiora '07
4. Jason Pierre-Paul '11

MY CHOICE: JASON PIERRE-PAUL '11

Left Defensive End
1. George Martin '86
2. Eric Dorsey '90
3. Michael Strahan '07
4. Justin Tuck '11

MY CHOICE: MICHAEL STRAHAN '07

Defensive Tackles
1. Jim Burt, Erik Howard, Jerome Sally '86
2. Erik Howard, Mike Fox, John Washington '90
3. Justin Tuck, Barry Cofield, Jay Alford '07
4. Linval Joseph, Rocky Bernard, Chris Canty '11

MY CHOICE: Jim Burt, Erik Howard, Jerome Sally '86

Left Outside Linebacker
1. Carl Banks '86
2. Carl Banks '90
3. Reggie Torbor '07
4. Jacquain Williams '11

MY CHOICE: CARL BANKS '86

Middle Linebacker
1. 3-4 Harry Carson, Gary Reasons '86
2. 3-4 Gary Reasons, Pepper Johnson '90
3. Antonio Pierce '07
4. Chase Blackburn '11

MY CHOICE: 3-4 Harry Carson, Gary Reasons '86


Right Outside Linebacker
1. Lawrence Taylor '86
2. Lawrence Taylor '90
3. Kawika Mitchell '07
4. Michael Boley '11

MY CHOICE: LAWRENCE TAYLOR '86

Cornerbacks
1. Perry Williams, Elvis Patterson, Mark Collins '86
2. Mark Collins, Perry Williams, Everson Walls '90
3. Corey Webster, Sam Madison, Aaron Ross '07
4. Corey Webster, Aaron Ross, Prince Amukamara '11

MY CHOICE: Mark Collins, Perry Williams, Everson Walls '90

Safeties
1. Kenny Hill, Terry Kinard '86
2. Greg Jackson, Myron Guyton '90
3. Gibril Wilson, James Butler '07
4. Kenny Phillips, Antrel Rolle '11

MY CHOICE: Kenny Phillips, Antrel Rolle '11

Kicker
1. Raul Allegre '86
2. Matt Bahr '90
3. Lawrence Tynes '07
4. Lawrence Tynes '11

MY CHOICE: MATT BAHR '90

Punter
1. Sean Landeta '86
2. Sean Landeta '90
3. Jeff Feagles '07
4. Steve Weatherford '11

MY CHOICE: SEAN LANDETA '90

Gunners
1. Phil McConkey '86
2. Reyna Thompson '90
3. David Tyree '07
4. Devin Thomas '11

MY CHOICE: REYNA THOMPSON '90

Punt Returner
1. Phil McConkey '86
2. Dave Meggett '90
3. R.W. McQuarters '07
4. Will Blackmon '11

MY CHOICE: PHIL McCONKEY '86



DEBATE, DISCUSS, CRITICIZE, CHASTISE...I'm sick at home with the flu and decided to waste an hour of my life.

Go Blue.

ralphpal
05-03-2012, 08:18 PM
Like it but my running backs would be Otis Anderson and Rodney Hampton

Roosevelt
05-03-2012, 08:35 PM
I love all the players who helped bring a trophy home to the Meadowlands, and have no desire to rank them.

After a little rough patch the '86 team dominated.

The '90 team stood tall after losing Simms, and Hoss' running ability added a whole dimension to our game.

'07 our defense knocked out a lethal Pats offense while our young QB comes up with the most improbable play. Truly unbelievable.

'11 Eli caries the team until we come together down the stretch and beat the Pats - again.

allentown PA
05-03-2012, 08:38 PM
Quarterback
1. Phil Simms '86
2. Jeff Hostetler '90
3. Eli Manning '07
4. Eli Manning '11

MY CHOICE: Eli Manning '11

Running Backs
1. Joe Morris and Ottis Anderson '86
2. Ottis Anderson and Rodney Hampton '90
3. Brandon Jacobs and Ahmad Bradshaw '07
4. Brandon Jacobs and Ahmad Bradshaw '11

MY CHOICE: BRANDON JACOBS AND AHMAD BRADSHAW '07

Fullbacks
1. Maurice Carthon '86
2. Maurice Carthon '90
3. Madison Hedge**** '07
4. Henry Hynoski '11

MY CHOICE: MAURICE CARTHON '86

Wide Receivers
1. Bobby Johnson, Stacy Robinson, Lionel Manuel, Phil McConkey, Solomon Miller '86
2. Stephen Baker, Mark Ingram, Odessa Turner, Stacy Robinson, Lionel Manuel '90
3. Plaxico Burress, Amani Toomer, Steve Smith, David Tyree, Sinorice Moss '07
4. Hakeem Nicks, Victor Cruz, Mario Manningham, Domenik Hixon, Jerrel Jernigan '11

MY CHOICE: Hakeem Nicks, Victor Cruz, Mario Manningham, Domenik Hixon, Jerrel Jernigan

Tight Ends
1. Mark Bavaro, Zeke Mowatt '86
2. Mark Bavaro, Howard Cross, Bob Mrosko '90
3. Jeremy Shockey, Kevin Boss, Michael Matthews '07
4. Jake Ballard, Travis Beckum, Bear Pascoe '11

MY CHOICE: Mark Bavaro, Howard Cross, Bob Mrosko '90

Left Tackle
1. Brad Benson '86
2. Jumbo Elliott '90
3. Dave Diehl '07
4. Dave Diehl '11

MY CHOICE: BRAD BENSON '86

Left Guard
1. Billy Ard '86
2. William Roberts '90
3. Rich Seubert '07
4. Kevin Boothe '11

MY CHOICE: WILLIAM ROBERTS '90

Center
1. Bart Oates '86
2. Bart Oates '90
3. Shaun O'Hara '07
4. David Baas '11

MY CHOICE: BART OATES '90

Right Guard
1. Chris Godfrey '86
2. Eric Moore '90
3. Chris Snee '07
4. Chris Snee '11

MY CHOICE: CHRIS SNEE '11

Right Tackle
1. Karl Nelson '86
2. Doug Riesenberg '90
3. Kareem McKenzie '07
4. Kareem McKenzie '11

MY CHOICE: KARL NELSON '86

Right Defensive End
1. Leonard Marshall '86
2. Leonard Marshall '90
3. Osi Umenyiora '07
4. Jason Pierre-Paul '11

MY CHOICE: JASON PIERRE-PAUL '11

Left Defensive End
1. George Martin '86
2. Eric Dorsey '90
3. Michael Strahan '07
4. Justin Tuck '11

MY CHOICE: MICHAEL STRAHAN '07

Defensive Tackles
1. Jim Burt, Erik Howard, Jerome Sally '86
2. Erik Howard, Mike Fox, John Washington '90
3. Justin Tuck, Barry Cofield, Jay Alford '07
4. Linval Joseph, Rocky Bernard, Chris Canty '11

MY CHOICE: Jim Burt, Erik Howard, Jerome Sally '86

Left Outside Linebacker
1. Carl Banks '86
2. Carl Banks '90
3. Reggie Torbor '07
4. Jacquain Williams '11

MY CHOICE: CARL BANKS '86

Middle Linebacker
1. 3-4 Harry Carson, Gary Reasons '86
2. 3-4 Gary Reasons, Pepper Johnson '90
3. Antonio Pierce '07
4. Chase Blackburn '11

MY CHOICE: 3-4 Harry Carson, Gary Reasons '86


Right Outside Linebacker
1. Lawrence Taylor '86
2. Lawrence Taylor '90
3. Kawika Mitchell '07
4. Michael Boley '11

MY CHOICE: LAWRENCE TAYLOR '86

Cornerbacks
1. Perry Williams, Elvis Patterson, Mark Collins '86
2. Mark Collins, Perry Williams, Everson Walls '90
3. Corey Webster, Sam Madison, Aaron Ross '07
4. Corey Webster, Aaron Ross, Prince Amukamara '11

MY CHOICE: Mark Collins, Perry Williams, Everson Walls '90

Safeties
1. Kenny Hill, Terry Kinard '86
2. Greg Jackson, Myron Guyton '90
3. Gibril Wilson, James Butler '07
4. Kenny Phillips, Antrel Rolle '11

MY CHOICE: Kenny Phillips, Antrel Rolle '11

Kicker
1. Raul Allegre '86
2. Matt Bahr '90
3. Lawrence Tynes '07
4. Lawrence Tynes '11

MY CHOICE: MATT BAHR '90

Punter
1. Sean Landeta '86
2. Sean Landeta '90
3. Jeff Feagles '07
4. Steve Weatherford '11

MY CHOICE: SEAN LANDETA '90

Gunners
1. Phil McConkey '86
2. Reyna Thompson '90
3. David Tyree '07
4. Devin Thomas '11

MY CHOICE: REYNA THOMPSON '90

Punt Returner
1. Phil McConkey '86
2. Dave Meggett '90
3. R.W. McQuarters '07
4. Will Blackmon '11

MY CHOICE: PHIL McCONKEY '86



DEBATE, DISCUSS, CRITICIZE, CHASTISE...I'm sick at home with the flu and decided to waste an hour of my life.

Go Blue.

cool thread..the only one i disagree with is id choose Mck at RT.

BluTri10
05-03-2012, 10:53 PM
Where in Allentown do you live? I'm right off Airport Rd. I think we may have talked once before...a long, long time ago.

nhpgiantsfan
05-03-2012, 11:08 PM
Quarterback 1. Phil Simms '86 2. Jeff Hostetler '90 3. Eli Manning '07 4. Eli Manning '11 MY CHOICE: Eli Manning '11 Running Backs 1. Joe Morris and Ottis Anderson '86 2. Ottis Anderson and Rodney Hampton '90 3. Brandon Jacobs and Ahmad Bradshaw '07 4. Brandon Jacobs and Ahmad Bradshaw '11 MY CHOICE: BRANDON JACOBS AND AHMAD BRADSHAW '07 Fullbacks 1. Maurice Carthon '86 2. Maurice Carthon '90 3. Madison Hedge**** '07 4. Henry Hynoski '11 MY CHOICE: MAURICE CARTHON '86 Wide Receivers 1. Bobby Johnson, Stacy Robinson, Lionel Manuel, Phil McConkey, Solomon Miller '86 2. Stephen Baker, Mark Ingram, Odessa Turner, Stacy Robinson, Lionel Manuel '90 3. Plaxico Burress, Amani Toomer, Steve Smith, David Tyree, Sinorice Moss '07 4. Hakeem Nicks, Victor Cruz, Mario Manningham, Domenik Hixon, Jerrel Jernigan '11 MY CHOICE: Hakeem Nicks, Victor Cruz, Mario Manningham, Domenik Hixon, Jerrel Jernigan Tight Ends 1. Mark Bavaro, Zeke Mowatt '86 2. Mark Bavaro, Howard Cross, Bob Mrosko '90 3. Jeremy Shockey, Kevin Boss, Michael Matthews '07 4. Jake Ballard, Travis Beckum, Bear Pascoe '11 MY CHOICE: Mark Bavaro, Howard Cross, Bob Mrosko '90 Left Tackle 1. Brad Benson '86 2. Jumbo Elliott '90 3. Dave Diehl '07 4. Dave Diehl '11 MY CHOICE: BRAD BENSON '86 Left Guard 1. Billy Ard '86 2. William Roberts '90 3. Rich Seubert '07 4. Kevin Boothe '11 MY CHOICE: WILLIAM ROBERTS '90 Center 1. Bart Oates '86 2. Bart Oates '90 3. Shaun O'Hara '07 4. David Baas '11 MY CHOICE: BART OATES '90 Right Guard 1. Chris Godfrey '86 2. Eric Moore '90 3. Chris Snee '07 4. Chris Snee '11 MY CHOICE: CHRIS SNEE '11 Right Tackle 1. Karl Nelson '86 2. Doug Riesenberg '90 3. Kareem McKenzie '07 4. Kareem McKenzie '11 MY CHOICE: KARL NELSON '86 Right Defensive End 1. Leonard Marshall '86 2. Leonard Marshall '90 3. Osi Umenyiora '07 4. Jason Pierre-Paul '11 MY CHOICE: JASON PIERRE-PAUL '11 Left Defensive End 1. George Martin '86 2. Eric Dorsey '90 3. Michael Strahan '07 4. Justin Tuck '11 MY CHOICE: MICHAEL STRAHAN '07 Defensive Tackles 1. Jim Burt, Erik Howard, Jerome Sally '86 2. Erik Howard, Mike Fox, John Washington '90 3. Justin Tuck, Barry Cofield, Jay Alford '07 4. Linval Joseph, Rocky Bernard, Chris Canty '11 MY CHOICE: Jim Burt, Erik Howard, Jerome Sally '86 Left Outside Linebacker 1. Carl Banks '86 2. Carl Banks '90 3. Reggie Torbor '07 4. Jacquain Williams '11 MY CHOICE: CARL BANKS '86 Middle Linebacker 1. 3-4 Harry Carson, Gary Reasons '86 2. 3-4 Gary Reasons, Pepper Johnson '90 3. Antonio Pierce '07 4. Chase Blackburn '11 MY CHOICE: 3-4 Harry Carson, Gary Reasons '86 Right Outside Linebacker 1. Lawrence Taylor '86 2. Lawrence Taylor '90 3. Kawika Mitchell '07 4. Michael Boley '11 MY CHOICE: LAWRENCE TAYLOR '86 Cornerbacks 1. Perry Williams, Elvis Patterson, Mark Collins '86 2. Mark Collins, Perry Williams, Everson Walls '90 3. Corey Webster, Sam Madison, Aaron Ross '07 4. Corey Webster, Aaron Ross, Prince Amukamara '11 MY CHOICE: Mark Collins, Perry Williams, Everson Walls '90 Safeties 1. Kenny Hill, Terry Kinard '86 2. Greg Jackson, Myron Guyton '90 3. Gibril Wilson, James Butler '07 4. Kenny Phillips, Antrel Rolle '11 MY CHOICE: Kenny Phillips, Antrel Rolle '11 Kicker 1. Raul Allegre '86 2. Matt Bahr '90 3. Lawrence Tynes '07 4. Lawrence Tynes '11 MY CHOICE: MATT BAHR '90 Punter 1. Sean Landeta '86 2. Sean Landeta '90 3. Jeff Feagles '07 4. Steve Weatherford '11 MY CHOICE: SEAN LANDETA '90 Gunners 1. Phil McConkey '86 2. Reyna Thompson '90 3. David Tyree '07 4. Devin Thomas '11 MY CHOICE: REYNA THOMPSON '90 Punt Returner 1. Phil McConkey '86 2. Dave Meggett '90 3. R.W. McQuarters '07 4. Will Blackmon '11 MY CHOICE: PHIL McCONKEY '86 DEBATE, DISCUSS, CRITICIZE, CHASTISE...I'm sick at home with the flu and decided to waste an hour of my life. Go Blue.</P>


Agree with most of it, but I would have to pick Jumbo Elliot '90. Guy was a beast.</P>


And, Chris Snee had a bad year in 2011. He was a shell of himself. You have to go with 2007 Snee.</P>

JimC
05-04-2012, 08:08 AM
Like it but my running backs would be Otis Anderson and Rodney Hampton

Agree here

allentown PA
05-04-2012, 09:00 PM
Where in Allentown do you live? I'm right off Airport Rd. I think we may have talked once before...a long, long time ago.

I used to live off of airport road as well..rite by the iron pigs stadium..I live in hanover township these days.

BluTri10
05-04-2012, 09:10 PM
My parents live in Hanover Township...we probably know each other...lol

allentown PA
05-04-2012, 09:12 PM
My parents live in Hanover Township...we probably know each other...lol

check ur inbox

NYG216
05-04-2012, 09:17 PM
I have to give Feagles the love at punter.

THE_New_York_Giants
05-04-2012, 10:25 PM
Quarterback 1. Phil Simms '86 2. Jeff Hostetler '90 3. Eli Manning '07 4. Eli Manning '11 MY CHOICE: Eli Manning '11 Running Backs 1. Joe Morris and Ottis Anderson '86 2. Ottis Anderson and Rodney Hampton '90 3. Brandon Jacobs and Ahmad Bradshaw '07 4. Brandon Jacobs and Ahmad Bradshaw '11 MY CHOICE: BRANDON JACOBS AND AHMAD BRADSHAW '07 Fullbacks 1. Maurice Carthon '86 2. Maurice Carthon '90 3. Madison Hedge**** '07 4. Henry Hynoski '11 MY CHOICE: MAURICE CARTHON '86 Wide Receivers 1. Bobby Johnson, Stacy Robinson, Lionel Manuel, Phil McConkey, Solomon Miller '86 2. Stephen Baker, Mark Ingram, Odessa Turner, Stacy Robinson, Lionel Manuel '90 3. Plaxico Burress, Amani Toomer, Steve Smith, David Tyree, Sinorice Moss '07 4. Hakeem Nicks, Victor Cruz, Mario Manningham, Domenik Hixon, Jerrel Jernigan '11 MY CHOICE: Hakeem Nicks, Victor Cruz, Mario Manningham, Domenik Hixon, Jerrel Jernigan Tight Ends 1. Mark Bavaro, Zeke Mowatt '86 2. Mark Bavaro, Howard Cross, Bob Mrosko '90 3. Jeremy Shockey, Kevin Boss, Michael Matthews '07 4. Jake Ballard, Travis Beckum, Bear Pascoe '11 MY CHOICE: Mark Bavaro, Howard Cross, Bob Mrosko '90 Left Tackle 1. Brad Benson '86 2. Jumbo Elliott '90 3. Dave Diehl '07 4. Dave Diehl '11 MY CHOICE: BRAD BENSON '86 Left Guard 1. Billy Ard '86 2. William Roberts '90 3. Rich Seubert '07 4. Kevin Boothe '11 MY CHOICE: WILLIAM ROBERTS '90 Center 1. Bart Oates '86 2. Bart Oates '90 3. Shaun O'Hara '07 4. David Baas '11 MY CHOICE: BART OATES '90 Right Guard 1. Chris Godfrey '86 2. Eric Moore '90 3. Chris Snee '07 4. Chris Snee '11 MY CHOICE: CHRIS SNEE '11 Right Tackle 1. Karl Nelson '86 2. Doug Riesenberg '90 3. Kareem McKenzie '07 4. Kareem McKenzie '11 MY CHOICE: KARL NELSON '86 Right Defensive End 1. Leonard Marshall '86 2. Leonard Marshall '90 3. Osi Umenyiora '07 4. Jason Pierre-Paul '11 MY CHOICE: JASON PIERRE-PAUL '11 Left Defensive End 1. George Martin '86 2. Eric Dorsey '90 3. Michael Strahan '07 4. Justin Tuck '11 MY CHOICE: MICHAEL STRAHAN '07 Defensive Tackles 1. Jim Burt, Erik Howard, Jerome Sally '86 2. Erik Howard, Mike Fox, John Washington '90 3. Justin Tuck, Barry Cofield, Jay Alford '07 4. Linval Joseph, Rocky Bernard, Chris Canty '11 MY CHOICE: Jim Burt, Erik Howard, Jerome Sally '86 Left Outside Linebacker 1. Carl Banks '86 2. Carl Banks '90 3. Reggie Torbor '07 4. Jacquain Williams '11 MY CHOICE: CARL BANKS '86 Middle Linebacker 1. 3-4 Harry Carson, Gary Reasons '86 2. 3-4 Gary Reasons, Pepper Johnson '90 3. Antonio Pierce '07 4. Chase Blackburn '11 MY CHOICE: 3-4 Harry Carson, Gary Reasons '86 Right Outside Linebacker 1. Lawrence Taylor '86 2. Lawrence Taylor '90 3. Kawika Mitchell '07 4. Michael Boley '11 MY CHOICE: LAWRENCE TAYLOR '86 Cornerbacks 1. Perry Williams, Elvis Patterson, Mark Collins '86 2. Mark Collins, Perry Williams, Everson Walls '90 3. Corey Webster, Sam Madison, Aaron Ross '07 4. Corey Webster, Aaron Ross, Prince Amukamara '11 MY CHOICE: Mark Collins, Perry Williams, Everson Walls '90 Safeties 1. Kenny Hill, Terry Kinard '86 2. Greg Jackson, Myron Guyton '90 3. Gibril Wilson, James Butler '07 4. Kenny Phillips, Antrel Rolle '11 MY CHOICE: Kenny Phillips, Antrel Rolle '11 Kicker 1. Raul Allegre '86 2. Matt Bahr '90 3. Lawrence Tynes '07 4. Lawrence Tynes '11 MY CHOICE: MATT BAHR '90 Punter 1. Sean Landeta '86 2. Sean Landeta '90 3. Jeff Feagles '07 4. Steve Weatherford '11 MY CHOICE: SEAN LANDETA '90 Gunners 1. Phil McConkey '86 2. Reyna Thompson '90 3. David Tyree '07 4. Devin Thomas '11 MY CHOICE: REYNA THOMPSON '90 Punt Returner 1. Phil McConkey '86 2. Dave Meggett '90 3. R.W. McQuarters '07 4. Will Blackmon '11 MY CHOICE: PHIL McCONKEY '86 DEBATE, DISCUSS, CRITICIZE, CHASTISE...I'm sick at home with the flu and decided to waste an hour of my life. Go Blue.</P>


Agree with most of it, but I would have to pick Jumbo Elliot '90.* Guy was a beast.</P>


And, Chris Snee* had a bad year in 2011.* He was a shell of himself.* You have to go with 2007 Snee.</P>
If this is going by performance in the Super Bowl, I take 86 Simms and OJ in 1990.

JJC7301
05-05-2012, 12:13 AM
Like it but my running backs would be Otis Anderson and Rodney Hampton
I'd say Morris/Anderson in '86.
LT: Elliot in '90.
PR: Megget in '90.

Rat_bastich
05-05-2012, 12:25 AM
I thought that was Rodney Hampton's rookie year...didn't he break his leg and not finish the year out? I don't believe he played in the Super Bowl and it was all Meggett and Anderson.

I would also go Jumbo Elliott.

I have a tough time with not including Pepper Johnson though...even though Carson is there as the other rep.

Myron Guyton and Greg Jackson too. Coupled with the rest of the defense that was on the field in 1990/91 these guys were intimidating and deadly.

Bavaro and Zeke Mowatt too.

Also, as much as I like Eli and think he is the better quarterback...Simms had the most efficient Super Bowl ever.

BluTri10
05-05-2012, 01:13 AM
I mistakenly took Benson over Elliott. I agree, Elliott should be the choice.

Rodney got hurt in the divisional game against Chicago -- so he was there for most of it. It was all Meggett and Anderson in the Super Bowl...

Myron Guyton and Greg Jackson were good...but these two guys we have now are pretty solid and are playmakers as well...They add an extra element to the position....

Howard Cross was probably the best blocking tight end this team ever had. It was a close call with the tight ends primarily because Bavaro's knees were shot and his career was basically over in '90...let's forget about his short stints with the Browns and...Eagles...although I was unfortunate enough to see him score a touchdown in person against us in Philly in 1994...Very sad.

Eli is definitely a better all around quarterback than Simms ever was. Simms had his day in the sun -- and what a day it was. Let's not punish Eli by saying how the game changed and it's now a passing game...yada yada yada. I still look at the key moments and key plays he made. Simms was getting booed out of Giants Stadium against the Broncos during the regular season game. Simms 4th and 17 play was "his play" for the '86 season. There are simply too many plays that Eli made to decipher which one was "his play" during this past year.

Just my humble opinion. Feel free to debate, discuss...This thread was done off the top of my head...spontaneously...

RagTime Blue
05-05-2012, 01:48 AM
Yea def take the earlier Snee.

And Reyna Thompson was pretty nasty, wasn't he?? Both as a gunner and on kickoff coverage.

Rat_bastich
05-05-2012, 02:56 AM
although I was unfortunate enough to see him score a touchdown in person against us in Philly in 1994...Very sad.



Was that the one that Bavaro got turned end over end and landed on his head? That might have been him in a Cleveland uniform instead. I just recall even after his stint with the Giants that he was a tough *******.

THE_New_York_Giants
05-05-2012, 03:31 AM
although I was unfortunate enough to see him score a touchdown in person against us in Philly in 1994...Very sad.



Was that the one that Bavaro got turned end over end and landed on his head? That might have been him in a Cleveland uniform instead. I just recall even after his stint with the Giants that he was a tough *******.
Had he not messed up the knee, I think he would be in the conversation for one of the greatest TE's ever

yoeddy
05-05-2012, 06:23 AM
I'd go with Meggett at punt returner...

gumby742
05-07-2012, 09:10 AM
Otis Anderson had a key run in the SB, but he was very mediocre during the regular season. Hardly chopped liver, but nothing to brag about. He was in the twilight of his career.

DragonSoul
05-07-2012, 04:51 PM
Interesting...

Quarterback
Eli Manning

MY CHOICE: Eli Manning

Running Backs
Rodney Hampton Ahmad Bradshaw


Fullbacks
Maurice Carthon


Wide Receivers
Hakeem Nicks, Victor Cruz, Plaxico Burress, Amani Toomer, Steve Smith(can switch to MM if wanted)


Tight Ends
Mark Bavaro, Howard Cross, Kevin Boss, Shockey (but he didn't play in it so boss is in his spot)


Left Tackle
Jumbo Elliott '90




Left Guard
Rich Seubert


Center
Bart Oates



Right Guard
Chris Snee '07


Right Tackle
Kareem McKenzie '07


Right Defensive End
Jason Pierre-Paul (can't go wrong with any of those options)


Left Defensive End
Michael Strahan


Defensive Tackles
Jim Burt, Erik Howard, Barry Cofield,


Left Outside Linebacker
Carl Banks


Middle Linebacker
Harry Carson, Pepper Johnson


Right Outside Linebacker
Lawrence Taylor


Cornerbacks
1. Perry Williams, Mark Collins, Corey Webster (Ross played great in our post season runs)


Safeties
Kenny Phillips, Antrel Rolle

Kicker
Matt Bahr

Punter
Sean Landeta,

Gunners
David Tyree '07

Punt Returner
Dave Meggett

THE_New_York_Giants
05-07-2012, 04:55 PM
Interesting...

Quarterback
Eli Manning

MY CHOICE: Eli Manning

Running Backs
Rodney Hampton Ahmad Bradshaw


Fullbacks
Maurice Carthon


Wide Receivers
Hakeem Nicks, Victor Cruz, Plaxico Burress, Amani Toomer, Steve Smith(can switch to MM if wanted)


Tight Ends
Mark Bavaro, Howard Cross, Kevin Boss, Shockey (but he didn't play in it so boss is in his spot)


Left Tackle
Jumbo Elliott '90




Left Guard
Rich Seubert


Center
Bart Oates



Right Guard
Chris Snee '07


Right Tackle
Kareem McKenzie '07


Right Defensive End
Jason Pierre-Paul (can't go wrong with any of those options)


Left Defensive End
Michael Strahan


Defensive Tackles
Jim Burt, Erik Howard, Barry Cofield,


Left Outside Linebacker
Carl Banks


Middle Linebacker
Harry Carson, Pepper Johnson


Right Outside Linebacker
Lawrence Taylor


Cornerbacks
1. Perry Williams, Mark Collins, Corey Webster (Ross played great in our post season runs)


Safeties
Kenny Phillips, Antrel Rolle

Kicker
Matt Bahr

Punter
Sean Landeta,

Gunners
David Tyree '07

Punt Returner
Dave Meggett

As much as I love Eli, if we are going solely based on SB performance, you'd have to be nuts not to take '86 Phil Simms. That was arguably the greatest performance by a QB in a SB