PDA

View Full Version : superbowl QB's



ralphpal
05-03-2012, 09:29 PM
Did any superbowl winners had to beat QB's as tough as we had to ?
John Elway ( i think best of all time)
Jim Kelly
Tom Brady ( Top 5 -7 )
2 QBs i think in the top 5 -7 best of all time
Jim Kelly top 25
The only one we lost to was the worst out of all them.
Pitt had tough but not as tough

miked1958
05-03-2012, 09:49 PM
Did any superbowl winners had to beat QB's as tough as we had to ?
John Elway ( i think best of all time)
Jim Kelly
Tom Brady ( Top 5 -7 )
2 QBs i think in the top 5 -7 best of all time
Jim Kelly top 25
The only one we lost to was the worst out of all them.
Pitt had tough but not as tough
I think u are right

SweetZombieJesus
05-04-2012, 07:03 AM
Good point...

49ers -- Marino, Elway, Esiason (Anderson and Humphries, meh)
Cowboys -- Kelley 2x (O'Donnel, Griese, Morton, meh)
Steelers -- Kurt Warner, Staubach 2x, Tarkenton (Hasselback, Ferragamo, meh)
Packers -- Roethelisberger, Bledsoe, Dawson, Lamonica -- agruably no all-timers but not chopped liver.
Skins -- Kelley, Elway (Woodley, meh)
Raiders -- Tarkenton (Jaworski, Theisman, meh)
Pats -- Kurt Warner (Delhomme, McNabb, meh)
Eagles -- .

Then there's SB XXXV -- Trent Dilfer. We have fared well against Kelley, Elway, and Brady, but lost to Dilfer.

NYG 5
05-04-2012, 09:10 AM
well, the giants do like to play down to their competition....