PDA

View Full Version : Rate My 53 Man Roster + Depth Chart



True 2 Blue
05-21-2012, 01:13 AM
QB
Manning
Carr

RB
Bradshaw
Wilson
Scott
Martinek

FB
Hynoski
Pascoe

WR
Nicks
Cruz
Randle
Jernigan
Hixon

TE
Bennett
Beckum
Ballard

OT: Beatty, Brewer, Locklear, Mosley
OG: Diehl, Snee, Boothe, Petrus
C: Baas

DE
JPP
Tuck
Osi
Kiwi

DT
Canty
Joseph
Rogers
Austin

OLB
Boley
Rivers
Williams

MLB
Blackburn
Herzlich
Jones

LB/LS
DeOssie

CB
Webster
Thomas
Amukamara
Hosley
Molden
Tryon

S
Phillips
Rolle
Grant
Sash
Horton

K/P
Tynes/Weatherford

giantsfan420
05-21-2012, 02:20 AM
Ive being seeing a trend of people thinking our runningback corp is going to look like the one u listed...

Its just my opinion but i see that as being 99% unlikely...bradshaw has missed parts of the last season and before...wed have absolutely no proven back if that were to happen...

For all of wares boring flaws and game, he at least is reliable to know his keys in the pass protection aspect...

How comfortable would u feel with scott, wilson, and martinek to be consistently reliable in that dept? ONE mistake and eli is, knock on wood, out for the season...

Aint no way tc goes that route, at least imo. And with martinek, why wouldnt he be the backup fb over pascoe in the highly unlikely scenario we carry two...

I see martinek being on the ps and called up if we need another fb or rb...

Beckum has a small chance of being ready reg season, ballard no chance. That 4th rd te robinson iirc will make the roster imo...pascoe will too as a te. Beckum and ballard on pup...

Jon6777
05-21-2012, 02:24 AM
Don't think Ballard will be playing this year. Tore his acl and had micro fracture surgery as well. Think we will have 6 WRs on the roster.

BlueSanta
05-21-2012, 04:07 AM
triple post

BlueSanta
05-21-2012, 04:10 AM
Dble post

BlueSanta
05-21-2012, 04:14 AM
Pascoe is a TE who makes the team every year in part because he can serve as a backup FB.

Martinek is a RB/FB who would make the team(if he does) on versatility including serving as the backup FB.

We need a backup FB behind Hynoski and that is where these 2 guys have added value. But, I do not think they both make the team. Martinek only makes the team if Pascoe does not, in my opinion.

I also think we keep at least 6 WRs.


We wont keep 3 MLBs and only 3 OLBS.

MLB is on the field for less than 50% of snaps. 3 guys is too many,

Conversely, OLBs are on the field far more , and there are 2 OLBs to 1 MLB in the starting lineup. So we would need more than 3.

You think Robinson , our 4th round pick this year, wont make the team and Beckum a guy who has never made the grade and is coming off an injury will?

Ballard will either be on the PuP for the 1st 6 weeks, or he will be out of the year. Either way, he wont be on our 53 man roster until midseason at best. At least, thats according to the articles that have been written on the subject.

giantsfan420
05-21-2012, 04:15 AM
Well to be fair, our mlbs can just as easily move outside

GMENAGAIN
05-21-2012, 09:11 AM
Robinson is making the team at TE.

river555
05-21-2012, 07:01 PM
I like the way you sneaked in Grant...i think we would all be happy to have him back.

miked1958
05-21-2012, 08:44 PM
Don't think Ballard will be playing this year. Tore his acl and had micro fracture surgery as well. Think we will have 6 WRs on the roster.Agreed

miked1958
05-21-2012, 08:45 PM
Robinson is making the team at TE.*Yep

NorwoodBlue
05-21-2012, 09:27 PM
Absolutely on Robinson.

Martinek is all speculation at this point. The fact that he's appearing on so many of these dream rosters doesn't say much for the rest of the RB group.

Locklear is a long way from a sure thing, he's getting long on the tooth, and with young McCants in camp, I think they'd keep the youngster first.

Ballard is PUP, Beckham is probably gone.

Mod_C
05-21-2012, 09:44 PM
QB
Manning
Carr

RB
Bradshaw
Wilson
Scott
Martinek

FB
Hynoski
Pascoe

WR
Nicks
Cruz
Randle
Jernigan
Hixon

TE
Bennett
Beckum
Ballard

OT: Beatty, Brewer, Locklear, Mosley
OG: Diehl, Snee, Boothe, Petrus
C: Baas

DE
JPP
Tuck
Osi
Kiwi

DT
Canty
Joseph
Rogers
Austin

OLB
Boley
Rivers
Williams

MLB
Blackburn
Herzlich
Jones

LB/LS
DeOssie

CB
Webster
Thomas
Amukamara
Hosley
Molden
Tryon

S
Phillips
Rolle
Grant
Sash
Horton

K/P
Tynes/Weatherford


Sent you a PM

nhpgiantsfan
05-21-2012, 10:14 PM
No way we have 2 rookies and a second year player as our only insurance to Bradshaw...

As much as I am not a fan, Ware has to make the team..

giantsfan420
05-22-2012, 12:43 AM
No way we have 2 rookies and a second year player as our only insurance to Bradshaw...

As much as I am not a fan, Ware has to make the team..

My thoughts exactly...aint no way tc would go that route especially when he places such importance on the rb in pass protection