PDA

View Full Version : Eli's Super Bowl Winning Drives...



Cool Papa B.
06-23-2012, 12:52 PM
Where does Eli's Super Bowl winning drives rank? Both in the pre and post Super Bowl era. ANd what was the great SB/NFL championship winning drive of all time?

Super Bowl 46 he got the ball back on his 12 yard line with 3:46 left needing a field goal to take the lead. He went 5-for-6 including one of the best passes/catches in SB history. They score a TD.

How would that rank with Montana's Super Bowl 23 winning drive. They were down by 3 with the ball on the 8 yard line with 3:10 to go. He goes 8 for 9 and throws the winning TD to Taylor.

What about Brady in Super Bowl 46. Though there was less pressure there. The game was tied and they didn't need to score then. But he did get the ball on the 17 yard line with just 1:21 left and NO timeouts. Got his team in field goal range for Vineteri.

Or what about Unitas in the 58' championship game. Or Eli again in Super Bowl 42?

Toadofsteel
06-23-2012, 01:57 PM
The XLII drive was the most important and the best executed in giants history. BJ converted a crucial 4th-and-1. The phenominal pass to Tyree that is pretty much immortalized in SB history. Eli showed there the stuff that elite QB's are made of. Although I still believe the defense had a lot more to do with that victory with their putting Brady under siege for the whole game and 5 sacks, Eli was no slouch by any means.

Cool Papa B.
06-23-2012, 03:02 PM
The XLII drive was the most important and the best executed in giants history. BJ converted a crucial 4th-and-1. The phenominal pass to Tyree that is pretty much immortalized in SB history. Eli showed there the stuff that elite QB's are made of. Although I still believe the defense had a lot more to do with that victory with their putting Brady under siege for the whole game and 5 sacks, Eli was no slouch by any means.

SB 42 probably was the toughest and most pressure packed because of the amount of time left and the fact that they needed a TD to win. You can make the arguement that in the SB 42 game winning drive there was some luck also. Eli threw 2 passes that could have been interecepted.

But in the SB 46 drive the dude was surgical. He made it look easy and he made the Patriot defense-a defense who kept him out of the end zone in the 2nd half-look like a joke. That first pass to Manningham was a like him saying "I got this!"

SweetZombieJesus
06-23-2012, 03:14 PM
They both have to be up there. Other candidates? Montana's drive against the Bengals, Big Ben's game winner after the Cardinals had taken the lead... But it's definitely elite company, and Eli may have been the only one to do it twice on that list.

Diamondring
06-23-2012, 03:16 PM
The XLII drive was the most important and the best executed in giants history. BJ converted a crucial 4th-and-1. The phenominal pass to Tyree that is pretty much immortalized in SB history. Eli showed there the stuff that elite QB's are made of. Although I still believe the defense had a lot more to do with that victory with their putting Brady under siege for the whole game and 5 sacks, Eli was no slouch by any means.Yeah the defense played a real big part but Eli's performance didn't help put the defense on the field more than they want to or real bad things could happen.

Cool Papa B.
06-25-2012, 06:48 AM
They both have to be up there.* Other candidates?* Montana's drive against the Bengals, Big Ben's game winner after the Cardinals had taken the lead...* But it's definitely elite company, and Eli may have been the only one to do it twice on that list.


That's true. I forgot about Big Ben in SB 43. Maybe because I was cheering for Kurt Warner. Down by 3 he got the ball back on the 22 yard line with 2:30 left. He ends up going 5 for 7 throwing the winning TD to Holmes with an amazing catch. All against a very tough Cardinals D.

Manning
06-25-2012, 06:56 AM
42 was by far the more excruciating to watch. One 4th down. Numerous 3rd downs (not 3rd & shorts either). I believe there was a 3rd & 10, 3rd & 5 (Tyree play), and 3rd & 11 (Smith catch to set up GW play).

46 was actually easy to watch, and provided little drama because it was so easy for us.

46 was more impressive, but 42 was downright incredible as a Giants fan.

Cool Papa B.
06-25-2012, 07:27 AM
42 was by far the more excruciating to watch. One 4th down. Numerous 3rd downs (not 3rd & shorts either). I believe there was a 3rd & 10, 3rd & 5 (Tyree play), and 3rd & 11 (Smith catch to set up GW play).

46 was actually easy to watch, and provided little drama because it was so easy for us.

46 was more impressive, but 42 was downright incredible as a Giants fan.

I counted 2 3rd down conversions- the David Tyree catch on 3rd & 5, and the Steve Smith catch on 3rd & 10. And 1 4th &short conversion by Jacobs that had me sweating like crazy.

Pop it Ahmad
06-25-2012, 10:06 AM
I think Toomer had a 3rd down catch, which set up the BJ 4th and short.

THE_New_York_Giants
06-25-2012, 10:31 AM
The Giants Superbowl XLII drive in my opinion, is the greatest drive in NFL history. Everything about that drive says legendary. It really should just go into the halls of football lore and simply be known as "The Drive".

TuckYou
06-25-2012, 11:48 AM
I will continue to say those drives are completely underrated. No one talks about those drives like the Elway or Montana drives, but they should. And Eli did it twice. People just love to hate him, even if he saved the world from non stop dribble drabble about Belichick and Brady. Could you imagine? If they won both those SBs? Id be sick every day.

What made 46 drive even more amazing was listening to how Belichick wanted to stop us, and Eli still finding a way with average players.

jimsgints
06-25-2012, 12:35 PM
I will continue to say those drives are completely underrated. No one talks about those drives like the Elway or Montana drives, but they should. And Eli did it twice. People just love to hate him, even if he saved the world from non stop dribble drabble about Belichick and Brady. Could you imagine? If they won both those SBs? Id be sick every day.

What made 46 drive even more amazing was listening to how Belichick wanted to stop us, and Eli still finding a way with average players.
It just takes time. In time, our drives will prove to the world (and the cowboy media,bspn) that our drives were the most impressive. At least we, as fans, know the truth. Still love it! I work with a pats fan and he's still in disbelief and I work with a packers fan, he thinks we stole two trophies from his team. Ha!

BigBlue1971
06-25-2012, 12:55 PM
sb 42 was more pressure packed cuz we needed the td! that one play from Eli to Tyree is imo the greatest play in sb history! only a few outside of Giants fans gave Eli a chance to win that game.</P>


sb 46 Eli and Manningham had the 1st and biggest play of the drive....or game for that matter. from there it was Eli the 4th qtr assassin doing what he does best! that was a great drive! he was expected to score and win that game by almost everyone imo!</P>

jakegibbs
06-25-2012, 04:49 PM
Where does Eli's Super Bowl winning drives rank? Both in the pre and post Super Bowl era. ANd what was the great SB/NFL championship winning drive of all time?

Super Bowl 46 he got the ball back on his 12 yard line with 3:46 left needing a field goal to take the lead. He went 5-for-6 including one of the best passes/catches in SB history. They score a TD.

How would that rank with Montana's Super Bowl 23 winning drive. They were down by 3 with the ball on the 8 yard line with 3:10 to go. He goes 8 for 9 and throws the winning TD to Taylor.

What about Brady in Super Bowl 46. Though there was less pressure there. The game was tied and they didn't need to score then. But he did get the ball on the 17 yard line with just 1:21 left and NO timeouts. Got his team in field goal range for Vineteri.

Or what about Unitas in the 58' championship game. Or Eli again in Super Bowl 42?

I loved SB 42 winning drive. I cried like an 11 year old boy in 58 after Johnny U drove um down the field.

chasjay
06-25-2012, 05:34 PM
I loved SB 42 winning drive. I cried like an 11 year old boy in 58 after Johnny U drove um down the field.

I didn't cry but I was an awfully sad 10 year old. For days, every time I closed my eyes, I saw Raymond Berry catching another pass.

NYG 5
06-25-2012, 09:46 PM
SB 42 was gut wrenching.

but in atypical Giant fashion, they were the ones who came up with miracle plays to win the game.


46 was a game where you felt they were going to win right after they ran their first play. that was a game that never should have been that close. you started to sweat after the pats too the lead, but then do or die, Eli hits Manningham and you knew it was game over. unless there was a botched snap or Tynes whiffed it, so glad that didn't come down to a field goal