If you had a choice of 4 players(2 offense-2 Defence), which current Giants would you have retire a in Blue.

[NWKEffectElement]

Excluding Eli and Tuck because they are too easy of a choice.

O-Snee and Nicks (It was hard for me not to say Boothe. He has done so much for us.)

D-Rolle and JPP

[NYG4lifeNYK]

Rolle? [:|]


Nicks, Cruz, Snee
Osi, Webster, JPP

[chizz]

Nicks cruz
osi jpp

[Bones911]

Offense: Snee, Cruz

Defense: Osi, Webster

[BlueReign]

Snee/Bradshaw, JPP/Webster

[NWKEffectElement]

Rolle? [:|]


Nicks, Cruz, Snee
Osi, Webster, JPP


Lmao!! Yea, dude Rolle. I have been a fan of his, and reconize the sacrifice that he has made for this team. From paycut, to playing out of position, giving up his body to play inside with the big boys, and changing his vocal ways to fit the Giants way.

[Diamondring]

Cruz and Nicks on offense
Webster and JPP on defense.

[slipknottin]

Nicks Wilson
JPP KP

[Jet-Blue]

Cruz, Weatherford
JPP, Osi

[Drez]

Rolle? [:|]


Nicks, Cruz, Snee
Osi, Webster, JPP


Lmao!! Yea, dude Rolle. I have been a fan of his, and reconize the sacrifice that he has made for this team. From paycut, to playing out of position, giving up his body to play inside with the big boys, and changing his vocal ways to fit the Giants way.
Rolle has never taken a paycut.

[NWKEffectElement]

Rolle? [:|]


Nicks, Cruz, Snee
Osi, Webster, JPP


Lmao!! Yea, dude Rolle. I have been a fan of his, and reconize the sacrifice that he has made for this team. From paycut, to playing out of position, giving up his body to play inside with the big boys, and changing his vocal ways to fit the Giants way.
Rolle has never taken a paycut.
Okay okay, restructured. He will mostly never see the money tho.

[Drez]

Rolle? [:|]


Nicks, Cruz, Snee
Osi, Webster, JPP


Lmao!! Yea, dude Rolle. I have been a fan of his, and reconize the sacrifice that he has made for this team. From paycut, to playing out of position, giving up his body to play inside with the big boys, and changing his vocal ways to fit the Giants way.
Rolle has never taken a paycut.
Okay okay, restructured. He will mostly never see the money tho.No. When he restructured all the money he shifted got changed into a guaranteed "signing" bonus. It made it impossible for him not to see it.

[Drez]

O- Nicks and Snee

D- JPP and C-Web

[slipknottin]

[]Okay okay, restructured. He will mostly never see the money tho.

the opposite. He restructured meaning he got more money up front.

[dave56dj]

If we are eliminating Eli and Tuck - then I would say

JPP - who will in my opinion be the most dominant defensive player in the game for the next 5 years (last year in his second year he may have had a better year then osi tuck or even the great strey has ever had - i know im gonna get sh*t for this but a defensive end who has over 86 tackles is unheard of - and never been done by any of those men - not even close. Not to mention 16.5 sacks over 10 passes tipped and a fg block to win a game - remarkable in his second year)

Nicks - will surpass amani as greatest receiver in giant history.

Wilson - It's far to early to tell but i think he is gonna be special.

diehl - I think snee will fit this category even better - but diehl gave everything he has to this team - multiple positions and almost never missed a game. Not the most talented tackle but a dependable player for sure - he may move on in his career but he will sign a one day deal and retire as a giant as will Webster snee osi deossie .

Be great to see herzlich flourish here and finish.

[midnite_nj]

My 2 would be Nicks and Wilson for offense and defense would be JPP and Phillips.

[JJC7301]

AB and Cruz
JPP and Osi

[Ahmad44rushHARD]

JPP, KP
Nicks, Wilson

[NY_Eli]

Nicks, Cruz

JPP, KP

[Diamondring]

Excluding Eli and Tuck because they are too easy of a choice.

O-Snee and Nicks (It was hard for me not to say Boothe. He has done so much for us.)

D-Rolle and JPPHey, you might as well take JPP out as well because a lot of posters picked him, I included.

[chasjay]

Based on what they've shown so far, I'd say Nicks/Snee for the O and JPP/Rolle on the D.

Based on what I hope to see from them over time, I'd go with Cruz/Wilson on offense and Kiwi/Prince defensively.

See what I did - I cheated and picked eight instead of 4!

[ShakeNBake]

D- Rolle/Corey Webster(since virtually everyone picked JPP)

O-Nicks/Snee

[MikeIsaGiant]

Offense - nicks and Cruz

Defense - JPP and Webster

[Drez]

This is pretty easy IMO.

Offense - Eli and Nicks

Defense - JPP and Tuck

Eli is an obvious
Nicks I would love here because he's been my favorite receiver in the league. Humble guy, who is pretty underrated by people

Defense - Tuck has always been an amazing giant and loves this team.

JPP - Kind of obvious there too
Eli/Tuck were barred from being chosen, as they are no brainers, lol.

[MikeIsaGiant]

This is pretty easy IMO.

Offense - Eli and Nicks

Defense - JPP and Tuck

Eli is an obvious
Nicks I would love here because he's been my favorite receiver in the league. Humble guy, who is pretty underrated by people

Defense - Tuck has always been an amazing giant and loves this team.

JPP - Kind of obvious there too
Eli/Tuck were barred from being chosen, as they are no brainers, lol.


oops good point, I didn't see that part. I'll edit my post

[GMenNY21]

Its prob been said already. But

O- Nicks & Cruz
D- JPP & C Web

[Drez]

This is pretty easy IMO.

Offense - Eli and Nicks

Defense - JPP and Tuck

Eli is an obvious
Nicks I would love here because he's been my favorite receiver in the league. Humble guy, who is pretty underrated by people

Defense - Tuck has always been an amazing giant and loves this team.

JPP - Kind of obvious there too
Eli/Tuck were barred from being chosen, as they are no brainers, lol.


oops good point, I didn't see that part. I'll edit my post
It's all good. I almost missed that myself when I first read it.