PDA

View Full Version : what happens in 3-way tie?



sachman
12-18-2011, 08:35 PM
What happens in this scenario?
1. Giants lose to NYJ then beat DAL
2. DAL loses both remaining games
3. PHL wins both remaining games.
Therefore, three way tie at 8-8. How is that broken and in this scenario, who wins the East?

miked1958
12-18-2011, 08:36 PM
What happens in this scenario?
1. Giants lose to NYJ then beat DAL
2. DAL loses both remaining games
3. PHL wins both remaining games.
Therefore, three way tie at 8-8. How is that broken and in this scenario, who wins the East?

Sad but Eagles win it based on best division record

scf424
12-18-2011, 08:36 PM
Philly

NWKEffectElement
12-18-2011, 08:37 PM
egirls get in

miked1958
12-18-2011, 08:40 PM
What happens in this scenario?
1. Giants lose to NYJ then beat DAL
2. DAL loses both remaining games
3. PHL wins both remaining games.
Therefore, three way tie at 8-8. How is that broken and in this scenario, who wins the East?

Sad but Eagles win it based on best division record

So we can no longer lose to jets and still play a winner take all game vs Dallas. We would have to scoreboard watch for the skins to upset Philly

So we really need to beat jets next week to have destiny in our hands when we playmdallas. Plus should Dallas eliminate Philly we would need to win to keep from being eliminated as well. Have to go into that last game no more then a game down.

stormblue
12-18-2011, 08:41 PM
What happens in this scenario?
1. Giants lose to NYJ then beat DAL
2. DAL loses both remaining games
3. PHL wins both remaining games.
Therefore, three way tie at 8-8. How is that broken and in this scenario, who wins the East?


the eagles

miked1958
12-18-2011, 08:44 PM
What happens in this scenario?
1. Giants lose to NYJ then beat DAL
2. DAL loses both remaining games
3. PHL wins both remaining games.
Therefore, three way tie at 8-8. How is that broken and in this scenario, who wins the East?

Sad but Eagles win it based on best division record

So we can no longer lose to jets and still play a winner take all game vs Dallas. We would have to scoreboard watch for the skins to upset Philly

So we really need to beat jets next week to have destiny in our hands when we playmdallas. Plus should Dallas eliminate Philly we would need to win to keep from being eliminated as well. Have to go into that last game no more then a game down.
So really we need Dallas to win to take out Philly. While we take out jets. Then we can deal just with Dallas and not have to worry what Philly does

miked1958
12-18-2011, 08:46 PM
What happens in this scenario?
1. Giants lose to NYJ then beat DAL
2. DAL loses both remaining games
3. PHL wins both remaining games.
Therefore, three way tie at 8-8. How is that broken and in this scenario, who wins the East?

Sad but Eagles win it based on best division record

So we can no longer lose to jets and still play a winner take all game vs Dallas. We would have to scoreboard watch for the skins to upset Philly

So we really need to beat jets next week to have destiny in our hands when we playmdallas. Plus should Dallas eliminate Philly we would need to win to keep from being eliminated as well. Have to go into that last game no more then a game down.
So really we need Dallas to win to take out Philly. While we take out jets. Then we can deal just with Dallas and not have to worry what Philly does
Don't look now but Philly all of the sudden has the ball in their court. They control there own destiny now with this win today. They beat Dallas and all they have to do is beat skins and they are in

dinz
12-18-2011, 08:47 PM
why go over all these scenarios.. this team looked beat in first half.. time for changes.. coach.. defense.. offense.. coughlin had his run here.. no WAY this team should have come out flat today,im embarassed to say im a giant fan today.

miked1958
12-18-2011, 08:49 PM
Everyone wrote off Philly and were talking about this giants Dallas winner take all possible game on jan 1 for weeks.. It looks like the giants and Dallas may be doing alot of scoreboard watching in what was supposed to be the game to decide who wins east

Overdrive92
12-18-2011, 08:49 PM
What happens in this scenario?
1. Giants lose to NYJ then beat DAL
2. DAL loses both remaining games
3. PHL wins both remaining games.
Therefore, three way tie at 8-8. How is that broken and in this scenario, who wins the East?

Sad but Eagles win it based on best division record

So we can no longer lose to jets and still play a winner take all game vs Dallas. We would have to scoreboard watch for the skins to upset Philly

So we really need to beat jets next week to have destiny in our hands when we playmdallas. Plus should Dallas eliminate Philly we would need to win to keep from being eliminated as well. Have to go into that last game no more then a game down.
So really we need Dallas to win to take out Philly. While we take out jets. Then we can deal just with Dallas and not have to worry what Philly does
Don't look now but Philly all of the sudden has the ball in their court. They control there own destiny now with this win today. They beat Dallas and all they have to do is beat skins and they are in

No. Because even if they take care of their own business, they need us to beat the Cowboys in Week 17. They don't control their own destiny.

rotundo
12-18-2011, 08:51 PM
The eagles still need help? Correct me if I'm wrong? They win out doesn't mean they get in. The Giants and Cowboys would have to go 8-8 also?

So if the Giants somehow still control their own destiny right? Win the last 2 and we still win the division? If we lose to the Jets, we'd still have a shot, but would need help. It's' all or nothing now. Pretty sad day today. I wish the rest of our games were on the road. We stink at home.

Overdrive92
12-18-2011, 08:55 PM
The eagles still need help? Correct me if I'm wrong? They win out doesn't mean they get in. The Giants and Cowboys would have to go 8-8 also?

So if the Giants somehow still control their own destiny right? Win the last 2 and we still win the division? If we lose to the Jets, we'd still have a shot, but would need help. It's' all or nothing now. Pretty sad day today. I wish the rest of our games were on the road. We stink at home.

Correct. If we win out, we win the division.

For the Eagles to win the division, they need to win out and need the Cowboys to lose out.

stormblue
12-18-2011, 08:57 PM
What happens in this scenario?
1. Giants lose to NYJ then beat DAL
2. DAL loses both remaining games
3. PHL wins both remaining games.
Therefore, three way tie at 8-8. How is that broken and in this scenario, who wins the East?

Sad but Eagles win it based on best division record

So we can no longer lose to jets and still play a winner take all game vs Dallas. We would have to scoreboard watch for the skins to upset Philly

So we really need to beat jets next week to have destiny in our hands when we playmdallas. Plus should Dallas eliminate Philly we would need to win to keep from being eliminated as well. Have to go into that last game no more then a game down.
So really we need Dallas to win to take out Philly. While we take out jets. Then we can deal just with Dallas and not have to worry what Philly does

the Dallas/Philly game does not matter anymore ;

if we lose to the jets we are eliminated.
if we lose to the cowboys we are eliminated.

if we win both , then Dallas and Philly are done. simple as that.

Redeyejedi
12-18-2011, 09:01 PM
The Giants dont win both games there done its that simple

stormblue
12-18-2011, 09:11 PM
and don't start thinkin' wild card either......
Detroit and ATL are already 9n5.