PDA

View Full Version : Rank These Prospects



titwio
02-20-2013, 04:56 PM
Trying to get a general consensus here. If these players are all on the board, rank them from 1-10 (best to least) who you feel would be the best players or fits for the Giants at 19.


(this is in random order....not my list)

Ziggy Ansah
Chance Warmack
Jonathan Banks
Alex Okafor
Sheldon Richardson
Manti Te'o
Alec Ogletree
Arthur Brown
Xavier Rhodes
Lane Johnson

Fharcyde
02-20-2013, 05:11 PM
1. Chance Warmack
2. Arthur Brown
3. Alec Ogletree
4. Sheldon Richardson
5. Ezekiel Ansah
6. Manti Te'o
7. Johnathan Banks
8. Lane Johnson
9. Alex Okafor
10. Xavier Rhodes

I doubt Warmack falls to us and I really hope LB is the pick in round one. I don't think Arthur Brown is going to be around for our second pick and fits the Giants scheme much better than Ogletree. Ogletree may be slightly faster and have more potential, but Brown is more of the thumping run stuffer that we need in my opinion. Unless Reese chooses one of these three I'll be disappointed as both linebackers will likely still be on the board.

titwio
02-20-2013, 05:21 PM
I don't think Warmack will be there either but others argue against an OG going as high as he's projected so I thought I'd add him to see how the consensus would rank him.

My list would go:

1. Chance Warmack
2. Lane Johnson
3. Ziggy Ansah
4. Alec Ogletree (depending how he tests)
5. Arthur Brown
6. Sheldon Richardson
7. Xavier Rhodes (recently overtook Banks for me)
8. Jonathan Banks
9. Alex Okafor
10. Manti Te'o

Carter.525
02-20-2013, 05:42 PM
1- Warmack
2- Richardson
3- Lane Johnson
4- Ansah
5- Rhodes
6- Banks
7- Arthur Brown
8- Okafor

I don't think either Te'o or Ogletree are in the Giants plans..

Sovereign
02-20-2013, 06:09 PM
Adjusting for positional value for the Giants
1. Sheldon Richardson
2. Ziggy Ansah
3. Jonthan Banks
4. Xavier Rhodes
5. Chance Warmack
6. Lane Johnson
7. Alex Okafor
8. Arthur Brown
9. Manti Te'o
10. Alec Ogletree

Disregarding position..

1. Chance Warmack
2. Sheldon Richardson
3. Jonthan Banks
4. Ezekial Ansah
5. Xavier Rhodes
6. Lane Johnson
7. Arthur Brown
8. Manti Te'o
9. Alec Ogletree
10. Alex Okafor

ELI_HOF_NYG
02-20-2013, 06:13 PM
1- Warmack
2- Richardson
3- Lane Johnson
4- Ansah
5- Rhodes
6- Banks
7- Arthur Brown
8- Okafor

I don't think either Te'o or Ogletree are in the Giants plans..

dont be too sure about te'o and tree, if they are both there at 19 both are by far the best available so does jerry really pass on a poasition of desperate need? I think it all hinges on the combine and the interview sessions. I could actually see it being te'o.

Carter.525
02-20-2013, 06:14 PM
dont be too sure about te'o and tree, if they are both there at 19 both are by far the best available so does jerry really pass on a poasition of desperate need? I think it all hinges on the combine and the interview sessions. I could actually see it being te'o.

I think it's a bad idea, Te'o in NY.. media wise

ELI_HOF_NYG
02-20-2013, 06:16 PM
I think it's a bad idea, Te'o in NY.. media wise

I'm not saying he is my guy but dont be surprised.

G-Men Surg.
02-20-2013, 06:24 PM
Trying to get a general consensus here. If these players are all on the board, rank them from 1-10 (best to least) who you feel would be the best players or fits for the Giants at 19.


(this is in random order....not my list)

Ziggy Ansah
Chance Warmack
Jonathan Banks
Alex Okafor
Sheldon Richardson
Manti Te'o
Alec Ogletree
Arthur Brown
Xavier Rhodes
Lane Johnson

1. Womack.
2. Ansah.
3. Lance Jhonson.
4. Richardson.
5. Te'o.
6. Ogletree.
7. Banks.
8. Rhodes.
9. Okafor.
10.Arthur Brown.

BlueSabbath
02-20-2013, 06:58 PM
1. Warmack
2. Johnson
3. Ogletree
4. Okafor (I'm obviously a lot higher on him than everyone else)
5. Richardson
6. Ansah
7. Banks
8. Brown (I think he's 2nd round guy)
9. Rhodes
10. Te'o