PDA

View Full Version : Who will/won't be back next season?



Connor
01-02-2012, 05:05 PM
Id have to assume Ross is gone, t2 is a primary resign, Kp needs to be back but who else will be gone?!

My guess,

Ross, manningham, jacobs(cut), grant

NYG4lifeNYK
01-02-2012, 05:13 PM
KP isn't a FA why did you list him?

Jacobs isn't going anywhere... he might have to take a bit of a cut though. Who would you replace Jacobs with?

Jacobs is fantastic when the line blocks


Bradshaw cannot be a full time starter in the NFL. Him & Jacobs are the perfect 1-2.



Hopefully Da'Rel Scott cracks the rotation next year a lot more.

buddy33
01-02-2012, 05:15 PM
I would not count on TT. That is the same ACL he tore before. Two tears to the same ACL is not a good thing.

gmen0820
01-02-2012, 05:19 PM
WR Mario Manningham UFA New York Giants Free Agent
WR Devin Thomas UFA New York Giants Free Agent
TE Jake Ballard UFA New York Giants Free Agent
OT Kareem McKenzie UFA New York Giants Free Agent
LB Jonathan Goff UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Michael Coe UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Brian Jackson UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Aaron Ross UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Terrell Thomas UFA New York Giants Free Agent

Here's the list for everyone.

gmen0820
01-02-2012, 05:20 PM
Jacobs is fantastic when the line blocksWhat an accomplishment.

tuck&rolle
01-02-2012, 05:27 PM
WR Mario Manningham UFA New York Giants Free Agent
WR Devin Thomas UFA New York Giants Free Agent
TE Jake Ballard UFA New York Giants Free Agent
OT Kareem McKenzie UFA New York Giants Free Agent
LB Jonathan Goff UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Michael Coe UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Brian Jackson UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Aaron Ross UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Terrell Thomas UFA New York Giants Free Agent

Here's the list for everyone.

I think we lose Manningham and Ross as we will have trouble paying up for guys that are pretty replaceable.

Goff and Thomas are tougher cases. It depends on whether they can get healthy and show the coaches that they can still play at a high level.

I'd like to find a replacement for McKenzie, but I have a gut feeling that he'll be back next year. Not the end of the world

gmen0820
01-02-2012, 05:28 PM
WR Mario Manningham UFA New York Giants Free Agent
WR Devin Thomas UFA New York Giants Free Agent
TE Jake Ballard UFA New York Giants Free Agent
OT Kareem McKenzie UFA New York Giants Free Agent
LB Jonathan Goff UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Michael Coe UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Brian Jackson UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Aaron Ross UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Terrell Thomas UFA New York Giants Free Agent

Here's the list for everyone.

I think we lose Manningham and Ross as we will have trouble paying up for guys that are pretty replaceable.

Goff and Thomas are tougher cases. It depends on whether they can get healthy and show the coaches that they can still play at a high level.

I'd like to find a replacement for McKenzie, but I have a gut feeling that he'll be back next year. Not the end of the world
At worst McKenzie provides excellent depth.

tuck&rolle
01-02-2012, 05:30 PM
WR Mario Manningham UFA New York Giants Free Agent
WR Devin Thomas UFA New York Giants Free Agent
TE Jake Ballard UFA New York Giants Free Agent
OT Kareem McKenzie UFA New York Giants Free Agent
LB Jonathan Goff UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Michael Coe UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Brian Jackson UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Aaron Ross UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Terrell Thomas UFA New York Giants Free Agent

Here's the list for everyone.

I think we lose Manningham and Ross as we will have trouble paying up for guys that are pretty replaceable.

Goff and Thomas are tougher cases. It depends on whether they can get healthy and show the coaches that they can still play at a high level.

I'd like to find a replacement for McKenzie, but I have a gut feeling that he'll be back next year. Not the end of the world
At worst McKenzie provides excellent depth.

True but it'd be a shame if we can't afford one of the other guys because we overpaid for him

NYG4lifeNYK
01-02-2012, 05:32 PM
<font color="#808080">WR Mario Manningham UFA</font> (unless he wants too much, he's very talented but struggles with route running, inconsistent hands, miscommunications)

<font color="#000000">WR Devin Thomas UFA</font>
<font color="#0000FF">TE Jake Ballard UFA
</font><font color="#000000">- Priority</font>
<font color="#000000">OT Kareem McKenzie UFA</font> (we may see him back in a reserve role for the min)
<font color="#0000FF">LB Jonathan Goff UFA - </font><font color="#0000FF"><font color="#000000">Priority</font></font>
<font color="#808080">CB Michael Coe UFA </font>- (could sign for cheap)
<font color="#000000">CB Brian Jackson UFA </font>
<font color="#000000">CB Aaron Ross UFA </font>- (really depends on status of T2, Ross isn't awful but he's not a #2)
<font color="#0000FF">CB Terrell Thomas UFA - <font color="#000000">(Priority if he's healthy.. even then still need him back)

</font>
Blue: </font><font color="#0000FF"><font color="#000000">Staying
Black: Gone
<font color="#808080">Grey:</font> Undecided
</font></font>

Bohemian
01-02-2012, 05:35 PM
I would definitely bring back: Manningham, Ballard, McKenzie, Goff, Ross and TT. The latter three would be signed because depth at their position is questionable (Mike LB and CB).

I would not like to see Devin Thomas back, unless the convinced that Hixon would not be back and healthy next year, or that D. Scott would not be able to take over on the return duties.

I have no real impressions about Brian Jackson, Michael Coe, so it would be ridiculous to say one way or another about those two. What is the overall opinion about them on this board?

Go Blue!

NYGRealityCheck
01-02-2012, 05:42 PM
Giants are probably going to see how TT recovers from his torn ACL.

Ballard earned himself another contract with the Giants I think.

McKenzie, Goff: Depends on what the Giants plan to do in FA and the draft. The O-line and LB position have been the weak point this season.

Everyone else is expendable. Manningham is going to test the FA market. It's inevitable. There's no way the Giants are going to stop that.

JesseJames
01-02-2012, 05:51 PM
Giants are probably going to see how TT recovers from his torn achillies.

Ballard earned himself another contract with the Giants I think.

McKenzie, Goff: Depends on what the Giants plan to do in FA and the draft. The O-line and LB position have been the weak point this season.

Everyone else is expendable. Manningham is going to test the FA market. It's inevitable. There's no way the Giants are going to stop that.

TT tore his ACL not his achilles...

NYGRealityCheck
01-02-2012, 05:56 PM
Giants are probably going to see how TT recovers from his torn achillies.

Ballard earned himself another contract with the Giants I think.

McKenzie, Goff: Depends on what the Giants plan to do in FA and the draft. The O-line and LB position have been the weak point this season.

Everyone else is expendable. Manningham is going to test the FA market. It's inevitable. There's no way the Giants are going to stop that.

TT tore his ACL not his achilles...

Thanks, made the correction. As you can tell, I wouldn't be good doctor. :)

Eli TO Shockey
01-02-2012, 06:01 PM
lets not forget the guys who are overpaid and will be expendable.

Chris Canty
Brandon Jacobs
Baas
David Diehl

We need cap space to sign Cruz , JPP, and NICKS to long term deals.

Also, KP will be entering into his last yr of his rookie contract.

VBGiantsFan
01-02-2012, 06:12 PM
WR Mario Manningham UFA New York Giants Free Agent
WR Devin Thomas UFA New York Giants Free Agent
TE Jake Ballard UFA New York Giants Free Agent
OT Kareem McKenzie UFA New York Giants Free Agent
LB Jonathan Goff UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Michael Coe UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Brian Jackson UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Aaron Ross UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Terrell Thomas UFA New York Giants Free Agent

Here's the list for everyone.

Manningham will be a New York Jet if we dont resign him

Eli TO Shockey
01-02-2012, 06:21 PM
WR Mario Manningham UFA New York Giants Free Agent
WR Devin Thomas UFA New York Giants Free Agent
TE Jake Ballard UFA New York Giants Free Agent
OT Kareem McKenzie UFA New York Giants Free Agent
LB Jonathan Goff UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Michael Coe UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Brian Jackson UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Aaron Ross UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Terrell Thomas UFA New York Giants Free Agent

Here's the list for everyone.

Manningham will be a New York Jet if we dont resign him

The jets have bigger worries.. like a franchise QB for one

dave56dj
01-02-2012, 06:22 PM
WR - devin thomas - done a nice job on ST and you cannot expect hixon to now come back from back to back major knee injuries - probably back.

TE - Ballard - does anyone realize in his first year as starter he has better stats then Boss ever had in any year and thats in only 14 games - with all the great TE's in the game we need him back and could still draft another.

McKenzie - If beatty is gonna be left tackle i know this doesnt sound appealing but Diehl may move to right tackle - he has actually looked a lot better at T then G. So this may mean the end of kareem - certainly one of the olines vets goes.

Goff - nice against run and was hurt so early theres a good **** he is ready to go and the giants get a good price. Back

Coe - A 4th or 5th corner at best after a devastating injury late in the year doubtful he is back.

Jackson - Looked nice as a 3/4 but expendable - maybe on a minimum contract.

Ross - Will depend on TT and prince, not a great corner but adequate - under the right circumstances for a small deal i think he'd be back but if someone wants to show him the money let him walk.

TT - Injury was the second of its kind for him which is worrisome but it came early so he shoould be close when camp starts and should get a good deal - i think like kiwi they bring him back.

MM - I dont see mario on lists but i think he is an RFA - To me mario is the odd man out - talent for sure but the 7 on the wonderlic showed up as he often reads Defenses poorly and hangs eli out to dry. Still its nice to have multi weapons - if he gets a pay day elsewhere id say goodbye.

GMAN8625
01-02-2012, 06:38 PM
I like what I saw from Coe, I think he will be back, and for cheap.

TT is gonna be gone. Someone will give him big money, probably the Redskins.

Ballard is solid, it'd be nice to keep him. Same with Goff.

Mackenzie is the man. Still playing well. I hope we sign him to like a 2-year deal.

Ross, Manningham aren't gonna be back.

jakegibbs
01-02-2012, 06:44 PM
Id have to assume Ross is gone, t2 is a primary resign, Kp needs to be back but who else will be gone?!

My guess,

Ross, manningham, jacobs(cut), grant

If they can sign Spags to contract before Philly snatches him up then Fewells out of here. If not Fewell stays another year.

BlueBlooded1979
01-02-2012, 06:58 PM
WR Mario Manningham UFA New York Giants Free Agent
WR Devin Thomas UFA New York Giants Free Agent
TE Jake Ballard UFA New York Giants Free Agent
OT Kareem McKenzie UFA New York Giants Free Agent
LB Jonathan Goff UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Michael Coe UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Brian Jackson UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Aaron Ross UFA New York Giants Free Agent
CB Terrell Thomas UFA New York Giants Free Agent

Here's the list for everyone.

Ballard is in his second year in the league. I believe that makes him an ERFA. They control his rights for two more years at very reasonable numbers.

Same with Jackson.

Guys with injuries will be allowed to test the market and JR will offer them short, cheap contract.

I think KMack is gone. He isn't the run blocker he was and has become a serious liability in pass pro.

burier
01-02-2012, 10:52 PM
Unless t2 will sign for dirt cheap he needs to keep it moving. Damanged goods.

Ross is another guy that I doubt we keep around unless he's really willing to play for cheap.

Jacobs will take a pay cut and be back.

Goff will have to be willing to sign for cheap or he's gone as well.

Manningham is lawyered up and will want too much money so he's gone.

The other no name guys might be back to early to tell.