PDA

View Full Version : NY Giants Legends



NoHuddle10
02-08-2012, 07:52 PM
I feel like this post is necessary due to the heat a lot of players on this team take from our fans. IMO the following players should forever be Giants Legends. We are never again allowed to speak poorly on anyone of the following players. Thats right, NEVER!


1. Tuck

2. Snee

3. McKenzie

4. Bradshaw

5. Jacobs

6. Osi

7. Webster

8. Ross

9. Blackburn

10. Tollefson

11. Diehl

12. Eli


A lot of the above players have received way too much heat on these boards. All 12 played a VERY BIG role in 2 Super Bowl Championships for us. 2 SB titles gives you a free pass no matter what happens in the future.


I never want to hear a bad thing about any of these guys again. True heroes of our organization. Legends who should be remembered forever.

GmenFan1980
02-08-2012, 07:54 PM
give it a week into the season and someone on this list will be getting dissed lol

bigjeep
02-08-2012, 07:56 PM
give it a week into the season and someone on this list will be getting dissed lol

That long?

Firenugget
02-08-2012, 07:57 PM
Sorry, no. LT=Legend. Carson=Legend. Gifford=Legend. Tittle=Legend. etc...

A couple of those guys you listed, maybe one day in the future. The majority of the guys you listed....Absolutely not.

calzonesays
02-08-2012, 07:59 PM
only guys maybe on that list you mentioned are Tuck and Eli

GmenFan1980
02-08-2012, 08:00 PM
give it a week into the season and someone on this list will be getting dissed lol

That long?

Should I shorten it to a day? http://boards.giants.com/emoticons/emotion-4.gif

NoHuddle10
02-08-2012, 08:01 PM
Sorry, no. LT=Legend. Carson=Legend. Gifford=Legend. Tittle=Legend. etc...

A couple of those guys you listed, maybe one day in the future. The majority of the guys you listed....Absolutely not.


I didnt say NFL legends. I said NY Giants legends.

They were all a huge part of HALF of our super bowls. They are all legends of this organization. Should be remembered that way.

I dont want to hear anything other going forward.

NoHuddle10
02-08-2012, 08:04 PM
Sorry, no. LT=Legend. Carson=Legend. Gifford=Legend. Tittle=Legend. etc...

A couple of those guys you listed, maybe one day in the future. The majority of the guys you listed....Absolutely not.


I didnt say NFL legends. I said NY Giants legends.

They were all a huge part of HALF of our super bowls. They are all legends of this organization. Should be remembered that way.

I dont want to hear anything other going forward.

I cant believe anyone is disagreeing here. Maybe its just me, but if you dedicate yourself to our fanbase and organization as much as the 12 guys above have AND are a big part of two Super Bowl Trophys (and all the joy we felt with them both), then you should forever have a free pass. Especially with your own fanbase.


If you think otherwise, then imo you are flat out pathetic.

Bing Crosby
02-08-2012, 08:12 PM
Sorry there is a good chance some of those guys aren't going to be retiring as G-Men, even if they come back to us after they hang up their helmets. I'm not going to cheer for Osi if he gets traded and nails Eli and it cost us a game in the future. Sorry.

When they are retired and come home that's one thing, but they don't get immunity for life until then.

Although hell for me personally there are somethings some of our retired legends do that just make me shake my head.

Firenugget
02-08-2012, 08:26 PM
Sorry, no. LT=Legend. Carson=Legend. Gifford=Legend. Tittle=Legend. etc...

A couple of those guys you listed, maybe one day in the future. The majority of the guys you listed....Absolutely not.
<u>

I didnt say NFL legends. I said NY Giants legends</u>.

They were all a huge part of HALF of our super bowls. They are all legends of this organization. Should be remembered that way.

I dont want to hear anything other going forward.

I understand that. And I'm telling you...no.

Ross is a NY Giants Legend?? Tolly?? Jacobs?? Diehl?? I'm sorry but not even Bradshaw. I'll give you Osi, Eli and Tuck and probably Snee. That's about it. And even THEN "Legend" is a bit much. Actually, it's alot much.

Voldamort
02-08-2012, 08:34 PM
Tuck,Eli,JPP,Nicks,Cruz everybody else will have there turn!

SweetZombieJesus
02-08-2012, 08:52 PM
I think Tuck finally turned the corner and became the leader he was supposed to be but couldn't be yet in the last 4 years.

I get that sense from the parade &amp; rally, and his actions on the field the last few weeks.

"I can only show you the door, Neo. You're the one who has to walk through it."