PDA

View Full Version : Oh great, another top 100 players for 2012



giantsfan420
02-09-2012, 12:01 AM
I saw a clip on NFL Network with the coaches discussing where Eli will end up on the top 100 players of 2012...

where does he end up?

I say top 5 he has to

giantsfan420
02-09-2012, 12:04 AM
premiers april 28th

apparently the ranking is supposed to be of the previous year ONLY which they clarified.

25 ints, I can see him being left off. But NO WAY he is not top 10 this year, NO WAY. its ONLY based on this SB season.

top 10 at least, i'd say top 5

DragonSoul
02-09-2012, 12:05 AM
I saw a clip on NFL Network with the coaches discussing where Eli will end up on the top 100 players of 2012...

where does he end up?

I say top 5 he has toProbably 100. Prefer he not be in it, rather have another trophy because they piss him off.

jaygoon
02-09-2012, 12:08 AM
If you think he is top 5 in the league, you are crazy. He is probably the 4th best qb in the league. I am in no way a Eli hater, but I'm realistic.

Don't get caught up in the moment, Eli didn't hold the patriots to 17 points in the super bowl, our defense did, thy had a lot to do with our victory.

giantsfan420
02-09-2012, 12:11 AM
nah, they asked a LB from the Bills and Baldinger when they were discussing when it'll air and where they think eli will be and Baldinger and Morrison both go "top 20" and Baldinger goes top 10 and depends how the players who played him see him...

I can honestly say top 10...but still, its confusing. They were saying Peyton could still be a player voted on, so how the hell could he make it he didn't even play?

hopefully they change the voting system bc last years was whack and im not saying it bc eli was left off, im just saying they did it completely *** backwards, like list 20 players and they only asked 15% or i forget exactly how it went but it was the # of 1rst place votes that determined ur ranking, so that means players voted for mcnabb at 1 and ****...lmfao...

at least he will crack 100, i cannot see how opposing players wouldnt have him at top 5 tho as eli single handidly beat teams a bunch of games...

giantsfan420
02-09-2012, 12:12 AM
If you think he is top 5 in the league, you are crazy. He is probably the 4th best qb in the league. I am in no way a Eli hater, but I'm realistic.

Don't get caught up in the moment, Eli didn't hold the patriots to 17 points in the super bowl, our defense did, thy had a lot to do with our victory.

it is only based on this past season. rodgers brees and brady were better i guess but eli was sb mvp had the most 4th quarter comebacks and tds, i would not be surprised at all if he got top 5 but yea ur prob right, top 10 is more likely

jhamburg
02-09-2012, 12:16 AM
Well let's see...He got left off the last "top 100" list and he was named the most overrated player in the league...They should put him in the number 1 spot on principle alone

JJC7301
02-09-2012, 12:22 AM
No way top 5. Rodgers, Brees, and even Brady will be ahead of him, and then you'll have other players like Megatron and Fitzgerald.

They'll put Eli in the top 50. I think he deserves top 10, but he won't even be close to that number.

Overdrive92
02-09-2012, 12:23 AM
Am I the only one who thinks this list is a complete joke?

It's the second biggest joke in the NFL. The first is the Pro Bowl.

giantsfan420
02-09-2012, 12:27 AM
No way top 5. Rodgers, Brees, and even Brady will be ahead of him, and then you'll have other players like Megatron and Fitzgerald.

They'll put Eli in the top 50. I think he deserves top 10, but he won't even be close to that number.

i think u guys are under estimating how players will view eli outplaying both rodgers and brady(x2 one of which was the SB)

I would expect players to put Eli ahead of those other qbs even if they are better statistically. i dunno tho we'll see...

ELIteManning
02-09-2012, 12:29 AM
His stats aren't and never will be gaudy enough to make the top tiers of this list. He has only reached the 30 TD mark once in his career. I am sorry but you cant compete with the guys throwing 35 - 50 Tds every year when that is the case. That is how our offense is and always has been therefore he will always struggle to get the recognition he really deserves.

jhamburg
02-09-2012, 12:30 AM
No way top 5. Rodgers, Brees, and even Brady will be ahead of him, and then you'll have other players like Megatron and Fitzgerald.

They'll put Eli in the top 50. I think he deserves top 10, but he won't even be close to that number.

Top 20 at least. Even Vick made the top 20 last time they did the list.

BurnerNYG
02-09-2012, 12:32 AM
The only list I care about Eli being on is the active roster list. Who cares about a top 100.

JJC7301
02-09-2012, 12:33 AM
No way top 5. Rodgers, Brees, and even Brady will be ahead of him, and then you'll have other players like Megatron and Fitzgerald.

They'll put Eli in the top 50. I think he deserves top 10, but he won't even be close to that number.

i think u guys are under estimating how players will view eli outplaying both rodgers and brady(x2 one of which was the SB)

I would expect players to put Eli ahead of those other qbs even if they are better statistically. i dunno tho we'll see...
Eli will never be voted by his peers to be above Rodgers, Brees, and Brady. Will never happen.

Based on the stupidity of last year's list, I think top 50 is the best that we could hope for on this years stupid list. I wonder if McNabb will make it on there again?

giantsfan420
02-09-2012, 12:35 AM
No way top 5. Rodgers, Brees, and even Brady will be ahead of him, and then you'll have other players like Megatron and Fitzgerald.

They'll put Eli in the top 50. I think he deserves top 10, but he won't even be close to that number.

Top 20 at least. Even Vick made the top 20 last time they did the list.

thats what i think. if it were done failry, i'd expect top 10. i doubt players care about stats as much as sports writers. they care about winning, and how a player leads a team to win.

we'll see tho should be itneresting. at least gumby will have to remove that lame as sig

giantsfan420
02-09-2012, 12:35 AM
No way top 5. Rodgers, Brees, and even Brady will be ahead of him, and then you'll have other players like Megatron and Fitzgerald.

They'll put Eli in the top 50. I think he deserves top 10, but he won't even be close to that number.

Top 20 at least. Even Vick made the top 20 last time they did the list.

thats what i think. if it were done failry, i'd expect top 10. i doubt players care about stats as much as sports writers. they care about winning, and how a player leads a team to win.

we'll see tho should be itneresting. at least gumby will have to remove that lame as sig

Sundown
02-09-2012, 12:36 AM
I hope he doesn't make it. Eli has been dissed his whole career yet he brings home rings. I hope they keep hating on him.

Sarcasman
02-09-2012, 12:36 AM
I saw a clip on NFL Network with the coaches discussing where Eli will end up on the top 100 players of 2012...

where does he end up?

I say top 5 he has to

Who cares? Top 100 players as voted by other players?

Throwing a dart would get you more meaningful results.

TrueBlue10
02-09-2012, 12:52 AM
yea, I mean <font size="5">who </font>votes for these things??

is it EVERY other player in the NFL or just a "select few" picked by NFL.com ??