PDA

View Full Version : Reese gets no love on these boards



Coach Carter
02-10-2012, 06:28 PM
The man has done it better than any Giants GM before him because he won two super bowls during the free agency era and no one, well very few, are giving him any credit.

Our roster is loaded thanks to JR.

MattMeyerBud
02-10-2012, 06:30 PM
The man has done it better than any Giants GM before him because he won two super bowls during the free agency era and no one, well very few, are giving him any credit.

Our roster is loaded thanks to JR.

amen

people want to know why we can't sign free agents and its funny they cna't see why

its because we draft so good, that when these guys rookie contracts are up they in line for pay days. Not only that but we have talent at every position group on the field, WITH depth...

Some people keep wanting to be like the Eagles, which is humiliating at this point and confusing. Why the hell would anybody want to be like them is confusing to me

miked1958
02-10-2012, 06:32 PM
The man has done it better than any Giants GM before him because he won two super bowls during the free agency era and no one, well very few, are giving him any credit.

Our roster is loaded thanks to JR.
I give Jim credit

jomo
02-10-2012, 06:34 PM
Some people will criticize anything, focusing on the moment.</P>


JRgets plenty of love hereand he may be the greatest Giants GM ever.</P>

JMFP2
02-10-2012, 06:35 PM
The man has done it better than any Giants GM before him because he won two super bowls during the free agency era and no one, well very few, are giving him any credit. Our roster is loaded thanks to JR.</P>


</P>


Just like Coughlin, Reese gets criticized or praised according to how the team is doing.</P>


I've always been a Reese fan, but that didn't prevent me from being critical about free agency.</P>


Reese deserves credit, without a doubt....but so does Coughlin, Accorsi, and Marc Ross.</P>


In fact, the Giants dodged a huge bullet with Ross didn't land the Bears job.</P>

Coach Carter
02-10-2012, 06:36 PM
Exactly, the Eagles just have big names, the Giants have big units (no pun). The Giants have the best WRs and d-line units in the league.

think about it, the Giant had a WR on IR and PUP and still a rookie could not get any burn. Tolly is our 4th defensive end and he had 5 sacks, same as Tuck.

FBomb
02-10-2012, 06:42 PM
The man has done it better than any Giants GM before him because he won two super bowls during the free agency era and no one, well very few, are giving him any credit. Our roster is loaded thanks to JR.</P>


Huh?</P>


I've seen a TON of praise for Reese on this board!!</P>

GmenFan1980
02-10-2012, 06:43 PM
to be fair, I don't cheer for Reese because I have no idea how to scout players, so usually whoever Reese drafts or Signs, I just nod my head and hope it was a good pick-up lol

JMFP2
02-10-2012, 06:44 PM
Exactly, the Eagles just have big names, the Giants have big units (no pun). The Giants have the best WRs and d-line units in the league. think about it, the Giant had a WR on IR and PUP and still a rookie could not get any burn. Tolly is our 4th defensive end and he had 5 sacks, same as Tuck.</P>


</P>


I'll say this....he's a huge upgrade over George Young.</P>


Unlike Young, I don't see Reese letting his ego get in the way of evaluating the coaching staff.</P>


The Giants make be on the verge of a dynasty....if that happens, by all means, Reese deserves a ton of credit.</P>

Coach Carter
02-10-2012, 06:50 PM
The man has done it better than any Giants GM before him because he won two super bowls during the free agency era and no one, well very few, are giving him any credit. Our roster is loaded thanks to JR.</P>


*</P>


Just like Coughlin, Reese gets criticized or praised according to how the team is doing.</P>


I've always been a Reese fan, but that didn't prevent me from being critical about free agency.</P>


Reese deserves credit, without a doubt....but so does Coughlin, Accorsi, and Marc Ross.</P>


In fact, the Giants dodged a huge bullet with Ross didn't land the Bears job.</P>

I don't know about the Accorsi thing, it isn't like none of the other two quarterbacks have been successful.

Here is why I don't like Accorsi:
1. he hurt Strahan by drafting that one eye waste Cedric Jones and letting go of Bradske
2. Trading up for Shockey when Albert Haynesworth was there
3. Drafting Ron Dayne when he didn't fit Fassell's offense
4. Drafting S. Williams when Alan Faneca was available
5. Drafting Joe Montgomery and Sean Bennett
6. He did not want Coughlin

Coach Carter
02-10-2012, 06:52 PM
The man has done it better than any Giants GM before him because he won two super bowls during the free agency era and no one, well very few, are giving him any credit. Our roster is loaded thanks to JR.</P>


Huh?</P>


I've seen a TON of praise for Reese on this board!!</P>

Man, stick to fighting with kids in the supermarket. Seriously, I have not seen much post superbowl praise for Reese. I saw lots of "Who says Eli isn't elite," and "Eli is HOFer." And even some stuff for Coughlin.

TheBookOfEli
02-10-2012, 06:53 PM
I've always loved Jerry Reese. He has built this team with so much talent.

Jerry Reese is the new Scott Pioli.

RoanokeFan
02-10-2012, 07:18 PM
The man has done it better than any Giants GM before him because he won two super bowls during the free agency era and no one, well very few, are giving him any credit.

Our roster is loaded thanks to JR.

amen

people want to know why we can't sign free agents and its funny they cna't see why

its because we draft so good, that when these guys rookie contracts are up they in line for pay days. Not only that but we have talent at every position group on the field, WITH depth...

Some people keep wanting to be like the Eagles, which is humiliating at this point and confusing. Why the hell would anybody want to be like them is confusing to me


I think the longer a fan has been a fan, the more they realize this is a "develop through the draft" organization.

RoanokeFan
02-10-2012, 07:21 PM
The man has done it better than any Giants GM before him because he won two super bowls during the free agency era and no one, well very few, are giving him any credit.

Our roster is loaded thanks to JR.

I think there are far more fans of Reese than not on here.

bLuereverie
02-10-2012, 07:32 PM
There has been plenty of love for Reese. Though there is a concern for the salary cap issues, I don't recall many people negatively linking it with Reese.