Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Things ROMO is better at then ELI

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Originally posted by FIFTY6G-MAN View Post
    You can have your Superior (non-winning) (0 superbowl) QB, I will take Eli. Nuff Said? Have your stats, I will take Rings!!
    Thanks for not reading

    Comment


    • Things Romo is better than Eli at? Mobility, improvisation/extending plays as well as accuracy.

      Things Eli is better than Romo at? Durability, commanding the offense, and rising to the occasion in big games/pressure-filled moments.

      Both guys are prolific passers, and both are great signal callers. Eli has the edge though due to playoff performance/SB wins and as arguable as that may be to the Eli naysayers, it is what separates the two.
      #80

      Comment


      • Originally posted by GiantWarfare View Post
        Things Romo is better than Eli at? Mobility, improvisation/extending plays as well as accuracy.

        Things Eli is better than Romo at? Durability, commanding the offense, and rising to the occasion in big games/pressure-filled moments.

        Both guys are prolific passers, and both are great signal callers. Eli has the edge though due to playoff performance/SB wins and as arguable as that may be to the Eli naysayers, it is what separates the two.
        I agree with this statement.

        For the posters who haven't bothered to read the first few pages of this thread or any of the numerous posts I've made on the matter, I'm not saying that Romo is better than Eli.

        Eli is the better quarterback at this point in his career, and he may always be.

        However, there are things that Romo still does better than Eli-- he's not chopped liver.

        Comment


        • Originally posted by Ntegrase96 View Post
          I agree with this statement.

          For the posters who haven't bothered to read the first few pages of this thread or any of the numerous posts I've made on the matter, I'm not saying that Romo is better than Eli.

          Eli is the better quarterback at this point in his career, and he may always be.

          However, there are things that Romo still does better than Eli-- he's not chopped liver.
          I've been guilty of clowning on Romo for his failure to get it done when it counts but I've always been in agreement w/ those who consider Romo to be a very good QB.

          Def not middle of the pack and for those who have him ranked there, that's selling him short. IMO easily top 10. Doesn't he have the 2nd highest passer rating of all time or something? He is very accurate and that is despite his gunslinger style. Not too shabby for an undrafted player.

          Dude is a baller and while I don't think he's better than Eli (I feel Eli just has a better mental edge/focus), in terms of the caliber of QB they are, both guys are great.

          Its Vick IMO who is vastly overrated.
          #80

          Comment


          • Originally posted by GiantWarfare View Post
            Its Vick IMO who is vastly overrated.
            Hey now! No reason to insult both Eli and Romo by putting Vick in the sentence.

            We're talking about QBs here.............

            Comment


            • Originally posted by Sarcasman View Post
              Hey now! No reason to insult both Eli and Romo by putting Vick in the sentence.

              We're talking about QBs here.............
              lol...duly noted!
              #80

              Comment


              • Originally posted by Ntegrase96 View Post
                I agree with this statement.

                For the posters who haven't bothered to read the first few pages of this thread or any of the numerous posts I've made on the matter, I'm not saying that Romo is better than Eli.

                Eli is the better quarterback at this point in his career, and he may always be.

                However, there are things that Romo still does better than Eli-- he's not chopped liver.
                If you are looking for acknowledgement that Tony Romo is an excellent QB then hey, you have that from me. Tony Romo is an excellent QB. I think Eli Manning is better but Tony Romo is excellent.

                Comment


                • You know whats funny? I would of bet my house that if the Giants D stopped the cowboys on that 3rd and 12 to end the game, Eli would of got the ball back and scored antoher 4th quarter touchdown and the Giants would of won the game. Oh well. We will never know now. Thank God winning a championship doesnt happen in week 1. Giants will bounce back. And Romo is still second to Eli.
                  I APPLIED TO BE THE NEW GENERAL MANAGER OF THE NEW YORK FOOTBALL GIANTS.

                  Comment


                  • slapping the referee on the *** after a touchdown.

                    Comment


                    • Originally posted by Ntegrase96 View Post
                      I really have to explain...?

                      Because you are speaking about a single game in which Romo turned the ball over more times than Eli-- a very small sample size. A much larger sample size (their respective careers) would tell us the opposite and that Eli is the QB more prone to turn the ball over.

                      But if I WERE to play by your rules and base everything on Wednesday's game, then Romo is clearly the superior QB.

                      oh I love playing the history game...ok I'll bite...Let's talk the last 5 years. How Many SB wins do you have over that time period? How many do we have? it's significant because this Romo vs Eli Era we're talking here not the SB's you won a century ago..*Heavy sarcasm intended*

                      Remember to answer the "Questions First" before throwing in whatever garbage you want to retort with..

                      Comment


                      • Originally posted by ELI_Iz_God View Post
                        oh I love playing the history game...ok I'll bite...Let's talk the last 5 years. How Many SB wins do you have over that time period? How many do we have? it's significant because this Romo vs Eli Era we're talking here not the SB's you won a century ago..*Heavy sarcasm intended*

                        Remember to answer the "Questions First" before throwing in whatever garbage you want to retort with..
                        Disregarding an argument I could go on about for hours about super bowls not being the end all be all for judging a QB, let me ask you a question. What argument exactly do you think you're in? What exactly is it that you THINK you're trying to get me to say? I feel like you haven't read through even the last page or so of this thread to actually understand what it is that I'm talking about, so I'll post a few quotes from me earlier in this thread (one of them is literally a page ago).

                        Originally posted by Ntegrase96 View Post
                        True. Don't get me wrong, there are other qbs that I'd take over romo, and I agree that Eli is a better QB at this point-- but romo is our QB and I'll defend... Bash him amongst cowboys fans, but that's different because we've all seen every snap he's taken and know the guy can play and is a top 6-8 QB. But I'll defend him when the criticisms are outrageous.

                        Originally posted by Ntegrase96 View Post
                        Rightio about the W's and superbowls. No one is disputing that.
                        Originally posted by Ntegrase96 View Post
                        I agree with this statement.

                        For the posters who haven't bothered to read the first few pages of this thread or any of the numerous posts I've made on the matter, I'm not saying that Romo is better than Eli.

                        Eli is the better quarterback at this point in his career, and he may always be.

                        However, there are things that Romo still does better than Eli-- he's not chopped liver.

                        Comment


                        • Originally posted by TheAnalyst View Post
                          You know whats funny? I would of bet my house that if the Giants D stopped the cowboys on that 3rd and 12 to end the game, Eli would of got the ball back and scored antoher 4th quarter touchdown and the Giants would of won the game. Oh well. We will never know now. Thank God winning a championship doesnt happen in week 1. Giants will bounce back. And Romo is still second to Eli.
                          So he saved it for the following week.

                          As for Romo, he is better at....

                          I APPLIED TO BE THE NEW GENERAL MANAGER OF THE NEW YORK FOOTBALL GIANTS.

                          Comment


                          • choking.

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by ELI_Iz_God View Post
                              oh I love playing the history game...ok I'll bite...Let's talk the last 5 years. How Many SB wins do you have over that time period? How many do we have? it's significant because this Romo vs Eli Era we're talking here not the SB's you won a century ago..*Heavy sarcasm intended*

                              Remember to answer the "Questions First" before throwing in whatever garbage you want to retort with..
                              Trent Dilfer has a Superbowl ring! You must think he's AWESOMMEEESSSSZZZ!!!!1!11!!!!!!!1one!

                              Riiight?

                              Comment


                              • Originally posted by HoagieBastage View Post
                                Trent Dilfer has a Superbowl ring! You must think he's AWESOMMEEESSSSZZZ!!!!1!11!!!!!!!1one!

                                Riiight?

                                Well, he's a better QB than Vick but that's really just damning him with faint praise.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X