Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

By Position, who is the best

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • By Position, who is the best



    Ok, I'm bored..... so here is something to kill some time. Byposition, who is the best player in Giants History.




    QB-




    RB-




    FB-




    WR-




    TE-




    OT-




    OG-




    C-




    DE-




    LB-




    DT-




    DG-




    S-




    CB-





  • #2
    Re: By Position, who is the best

    qb... I'll still say Simms but am not starting this argument cause Manning is slowly passing him and arguments can be made both ways....so can we please not start a Simms Eli debate...it just is not worth it.....BTW this means I actually saw them BOTH playS(if you did not see Simms...I do not care what you think you know)......I dont care about the numbers(2 different offensive styles)....I gave my opinion and I really do not care about the arguments that I have seen on these boards more times than I care to count......

    RB.... ill say Tiki just based on pure numbers....again I am not here to start arguments

    fb....Carthon

    Wr.... Toomer but Nicks has great chance of passing him

    Te...Bavaro...sorry will not even entertain a discussion on this one

    OT...Elliot...see above

    OG ..this one was tough but I'll go Snee

    C...Oates

    DE...Strahan

    DT...Im assuming we mean nt in a 3/4 I'll say erik howard

    DG/dt in a 4/3 Hamilton comes to mind but i think Rosey Greer was a dt so he would be the one but a little before my time

    LB...no brainer... although you might have to go with LT on outside and Carson for middle

    S......Spider Lockart

    CB.....Mark Collins
    "When I was 15, I could not believe how dumb my father was.....when I was 25, I could not believe how much he had learned in 10 years"

    1st to use the phrase "In Reese we trust"

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: By Position, who is the best

      Off the top of my head on the fly...don't give me crap.

      QB- Eli Manning

      RB- Tiki Barber

      FB- Maurice Carthon

      WR- Hakeem Nicks (Will be by the end of career IMO)

      TE- Mark Bavaro

      OT- John "Jumbo" Elliot

      OG- Chris Snee

      C- Shaun 'O' Hara?

      DE- Michael Strahan

      LB- L.T.

      DT- Keith Hamilton maybe (not sure about best)

      S- Mark Collins maybe?

      CB- Jason Sehorn, Sparks...not too sure.
      "You killed my family, and I don't like that kind of thing."

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: By Position, who is the best

        [quote user="titwio"]Off the top of my head on the fly...don't give me crap.

        QB- Eli Manning

        RB- Tiki Barber

        FB- Maurice Carthon

        WR- Hakeem Nicks (Will be by the end of career IMO)

        TE- Mark Bavaro

        OT- John "Jumbo" Elliot

        OG- Chris Snee

        C- Shaun 'O' Hara?

        DE- Michael Strahan

        LB- L.T.

        DT- Keith Hamilton maybe (not sure about best)

        S- Mark Collins maybe?

        CB- Jason Sehorn, Sparks...not too sure.[/quote]

        Collins was a cb not a s...other than that our lists are very close
        "When I was 15, I could not believe how dumb my father was.....when I was 25, I could not believe how much he had learned in 10 years"

        1st to use the phrase "In Reese we trust"

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: By Position, who is the best




          QB- Warner




          RB- Tiki




          FB- Comilla




          WR- Baker




          TE- Bravaro




          OT- Jumbo




          OG- rosenthal




          C- bart oats




          DE- tuck




          LB- LT




          DT- Hamilton





          S- Sparks




          CB- Sehorn





          Comment


          • #6
            Re: By Position, who is the best

            [quote user="Harooni"]



            QB- Warner





            [/quote]




            you're such a ******....[:P]

            "Measure Twice......Cut Once"
            You couldn't be more full of **** if you were break dancing in a Port-a-Potty.......Kruunch

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: By Position, who is the best

              [quote user="GameTime"][quote user="Harooni"]



              QB- Warner





              [/quote]




              you're such a ******....[:P]

              [/quote]
              wha?? Warner stat wise is the best QB to ever play for us.

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: By Position, who is the best

                [quote user="Harooni"][quote user="GameTime"][quote user="Harooni"]



                QB- Warner





                [/quote]




                you're such a ******....[:P]




                [/quote]
                wha?? Warner stat wise is the best QB to ever play for us.
                [/quote]




                while he was a Giant??? Yeah whatever....you are just being a DH....

                "Measure Twice......Cut Once"
                You couldn't be more full of **** if you were break dancing in a Port-a-Potty.......Kruunch

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: By Position, who is the best

                  [quote user="GameTime"][quote user="Harooni"][quote user="GameTime"][quote user="Harooni"]



                  QB- Warner





                  [/quote]




                  you're such a ******....[:P]




                  [/quote]
                  wha?? Warner stat wise is the best QB to ever play for us.
                  [/quote]




                  while he was a Giant???




                  [/quote]

                  Why do you bother?...you know by looking at the list he did not answer seriously...just leave it be...There were at least 3 0r 4 that I just shook my head....Baker Comilla? be serious
                  "When I was 15, I could not believe how dumb my father was.....when I was 25, I could not believe how much he had learned in 10 years"

                  1st to use the phrase "In Reese we trust"

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: By Position, who is the best

                    [quote user="fansince69"][quote user="GameTime"][quote user="Harooni"][quote user="GameTime"][quote user="Harooni"]



                    QB- Warner





                    [/quote]




                    you're such a ******....[:P]




                    [/quote]
                    wha?? Warner stat wise is the best QB to ever play for us.
                    [/quote]




                    while he was a Giant???







                    [/quote]

                    Why do you bother?...you know by looking at the list he did not answer seriously...just leave it be...There were at least 3 0r 4 that I just shook my head....Baker Comilla? be serious
                    [/quote]




                    Oh I know....its Harooni....just letting him think some one is actually serious about his "sly" posting...




                    "Measure Twice......Cut Once"
                    You couldn't be more full of **** if you were break dancing in a Port-a-Potty.......Kruunch

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: By Position, who is the best

                      [quote user="GameTime"]

                      while he was a Giant???

                      [/quote] oh you want to get technical

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: By Position, who is the best

                        CB - Webster
                        S - KP will be if he stays healthy and remains a giant.

                        I agree with the earlier post that Nicks will be the best WR in Giants history. If he isnt already.

                        I know Im in the minority, and Shockey is a major tool, but I believe he was the best TE in giants history. Which is not saying all that much either. Thats clearly a position that the giants can improve upon historically.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: By Position, who is the best

                          Based on the players I watched and followed:

                          QB - Eli, I grew up watching and respecting Simms. We can debate this on another thread.
                          RB - Tiki
                          FB - Carthon
                          WR- It's not a Toomer
                          TE - Bavaro
                          OT - Elliot
                          OG - William Roberts, although I also considered Ron Stone.
                          C - Oates
                          DE - Strahan
                          DT - Erik Howard, but my personal favorite is Jim Burt
                          LB - LT
                          S - This one is tough but I'm going to give it to Terry Kinard
                          CB - Collins

                          PR/KR - Dave Meggett
                          P - Feagles
                          K - Matt Bahr? Tynes?

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: By Position, who is the best

                            I'm surprised Gifford and Y.A. have not made the discussions yet...

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: By Position, who is the best

                              [quote user="rebelfan1966"]I'm surprised Gifford and Y.A. have not made the discussions yet...[/quote]

                              Most on the boards are too young to remember....including me and I am old...lol...I weas only including players I have seen and that is basically the Super Bowl era......

                              To Slip...I respect you as a poster but how can you rank Shocky ahead of Bavaro?.....sorry I just do not see it as even being a discussion....As much as I liked Shockey in first few seasons here...Bavaro was not human at times

                              Sorry I can not put Webster(yes I love Webster) ahead of Collins yet....and KP has a long way to go to catch spider
                              "When I was 15, I could not believe how dumb my father was.....when I was 25, I could not believe how much he had learned in 10 years"

                              1st to use the phrase "In Reese we trust"

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X