Bring Spags back!!!!!

[Old Giant]

Dear Tom,

No thanks.

John

+1

[RoanokeFan]

Not really my friend.
I've been wanting this guy back ever since he left.
Now is our opportunity.
We cannot procrastinate.

It's not going to happen

[tdawg1413]

Spags is no better than Fewell. It was the players who made him look good during the Super Bowl run. He has been awful ever since. This is not a coincidence.

[RoanokeFan]

Giants' Defensive Assistant Al Holcomb Interviews with Panthers

http://www.giants101.com/2013/01/25/...lina-panthers/

Excerpt: "The Carolina Panthers have a new General Manager in Dave Gettleman, but their pilfering of the New York Giants may have only just begun. The Charlotte Observer reports that the team met with Giants defensive assistant Al Holcomb on Thursday regarding their vacant linebackers coach position.

Holcomb, who joined the Giants in 2009 as their defensive quality control coach after interning with the New York Jets in 2007 as part of the NFL's minority internship program, was promoted to defensive assistant to Perry Fewell in 2011 and helped the team to a Super Bowl XLVI victory.

Prior to entering the NFL, Holcomb was a defensive coach for several smaller Pennsylvania college teams, including Lafayette, Kutztown University and Bloomsburg, who played for the Division II National Championship in 2000." Read more...

[Flip Empty]

Save yourself the stress, the team is committed to Fewell.

[barran21]

Save yourself the stress, the team is committed to Fewell.

Sad but true...

[BlueJayC]

So he went form DC, to HC, to DC and now assistant? Would we be looking to sign a player with that type of record? Probably not.

Yes.....when a backup or veteran in his twilight years is better than the starter the Giants would......an upgrade is an upgrade no matter where it comes from.......

(Kurt Warner can be used as an example if we're making player personnel comparisons to coaches)

[RoanokeFan]

Save yourself the stress, the team is committed to Fewell.

Can you imagine bringing Spags back after two failed adventures and we learn he isn't all that? This place would be erupting at Reese's incompetence.

[RoanokeFan]

Yes.....when a backup or veteran in his twilight years is better than the starter the Giants would......an upgrade is an upgrade no matter where it comes from.......

(Kurt Warner can be used as an example if we're making player personnel comparisons to coaches)

That's the question, is it an upgrade? For three years Spags has failed miserably.

[Diamondring]

That's the question, is it an upgrade? For three years Spags has failed miserably.

Was it his fault or the other teams he went to? A cook can't cook a delicious meal with rotten food. If a cook does cook a bad meal with fresh food then it is more his fault and did something wrong.

[TCHOF]

Not my problem if these other organizations don't know what they had.
Happens all the time in sports.
Do your research.

Research on what?

Since you're the one demanding that we hire him, it seems to me that you should have done the research as to why he was fired twice in the last 2 years. The last firing was by a very good and respected HC by the way, who fired him after only one year.

[GTGiantsFan]

That's the question, is it an upgrade? For three years Spags has failed miserably.

He hardly did miserably.

[Drez]

Spags is no better than Fewell. It was the players who made him look good during the Super Bowl run. He has been awful ever since. This is not a coincidence.

We had a great defense in '08. We just got worn down at the end of the year.

[Drez]

I think this is a fair question:

Art Stapleton @art_stapleton
Clear this up for me: some #NYG fans want Perry Fewell fired for his D giving up 6,134 yards in favor of Spags, whose D in NO gave up 7,042

Expand

• Reply
• Retweet
• Favorite
• Mor
  
  

[RoanokeFan]

He hardly did miserably.

At St. Louis he was 10 - 38 over three seasons and in NO he was 32nd.. Hardly glowing.

That's pretty bad