Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Coaching Tree?

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • nhpgiantsfan
    started a topic Coaching Tree?

    Coaching Tree?

    So since we are talking about Parcells this weekend, I was wondering how much stock everyone puts into the whole "coaching Tree" thing. I think it's overrated. I don't really think Parcells deserves credit for Coughlins success just because he coached Bill's WR's. Maybe BP just was very good at picking good coaches for his staff.

  • YATittle1962
    replied
    everyone learns from those who they work under and are mentored by

    Coughlin will be the first one to tell you how much he learned from Bill Parcells

    just as he learned from Marion Campbell who gave him his first pro position, and Forrest Gregg

    coaching staffs are a family who spend more time with each other than their actual family......in situations like that it is nearly impossible to not take something that stays with you for life

    Coughlin himself is a connoisseur of coaching history as it pertains to all sports and a firm believer in the coaching tree influence and impact
    Last edited by YATittle1962; 02-03-2013, 05:43 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • penguinfarmer
    replied
    Each coach has their own method and character, but I don't think it's a surprise that some of the best coaches evaluate and surround themselves with talent, which includes their own coaching staff as well.

    Leave a comment:


  • BigBlue1971
    replied
    actually TC would be another limb on that tree! he has only been a position coach never a coordinator!

    Belichick imo is a perfect example and model of Parcells tree! he still has Parcells former players coaching for him!

    Leave a comment:


  • brad
    replied
    I don't think BP deserves "all the credit" for TC, Belichick, or the many other coaches in his "tree"... but he does deserve credit for finding these great coaches and bringing him onto his staff. Just as a GM is judged by his ability to find talented players, a HC is judged by his ability to find talented assistants, because those assistant coaches have just as much impact on team success as the players or even HC has. It is about building a great team and clearly Parcells knew how to build a great coaching staff.

    A GM doesn't make the players he drafts great, and a HC doesn't make the personnel he hires great, and that isn't what they are judged by. They are judged by having the ability to pick out the great ones.

    Leave a comment:


  • thegreatone
    replied
    It's not overrated because you need to be able to have good positional coaches to succeed and like yo said he was good at it. Now TC might have ended up being a great coach wether or not he worked with bill but he did and we can't gauge how much influence bp had on him if any at all. So do I thin bp deserves credit for TC success,no.ndo I think he deserves credit for helping to mold a great HC, yes.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X