Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

List of Giants Free Agents Pick and Choose

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • List of Giants Free Agents Pick and Choose

    New York Giants

    Curtis Painter, QB
    Andre Brown, RB
    Peyton Hillis, RB keeper
    Louis Murphy, WR
    Hakeem Nicks, WR
    Julian Talley, WR
    Brandon Myers, TE keeper
    Bear Pascoe, TE
    David Diehl, OL
    Kevin Boothe, OL
    Justin Tuck, DE
    Linval Joseph, DT keeper
    Mike Patterson, DT keeper
    Shaun Rogers, DT
    Keith Rivers, LB keeper
    Jon Beason, LB keeper
    Trumaine McBride, CB
    Aaron Ross, CB
    Terrell Thomas, CB keeper
    Stevie Brown, S keeper
    Ryan Mundy, S
    Josh Brown, keeper

  • #2
    Curtis Painter, QB (CUT/WAIVE/CHANGE LOCKS ASAP)
    Andre Brown, RB (Keep maybe)
    Peyton Hillis, RB (Keep)
    Louis Murphy, WR (Keep maybe on 1 year deal for depth)
    Hakeem Nicks, WR (BYE)
    Julian Talley, WR (Keep for depth)
    Brandon Myers, TE (Keep maybe for 1 year deal if no better options)
    Bear Pascoe, TE (Bye)
    David Diehl, OL (Retired/Bye)
    Kevin Boothe, OL (Keep)
    Justin Tuck, DE (BYE)
    Linval Joseph, DT (Keep, but may loose)
    Mike Patterson, DT (Keep)
    Shaun Rogers, DT (Not sure)
    Keith Rivers, LB (Keep, but draft another LB)
    Jon Beason, LB (KEEP PLEASE)
    Trumaine McBride, CB (Keep, but draft another CB)
    Aaron Ross, CB (BYE. Never should have come back)
    Terrell Thomas, CB (Keep, but draft another CB)
    Stevie Brown, S (KEEP PLEASE)
    Ryan Mundy, S (Keep)
    Josh Brown, (KEEP PLEASE)
    One of these teams is not like the others

    sigpic

    Comment


    • #3
      I don't want to hijack your thread but it would be interesting to ask this...

      Who, on this list, are the players that you just can't live without? Not players that they have to keep because of the current situation (Booth, T2, AB, Rivers, Patterson) but which players are you really excited about because they could represent an important part of the future for the NY Giants?

      For me, its only 3 players from the entire list: Beason, Joseph and Stevie Brown. McBride and Mundy get honorable mention because I don't really know what they have with them yet.

      What does that say about the Giants right now?

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by PennState1 View Post
        I don't want to hijack your thread but it would be interesting to ask this...

        Who, on this list, are the players that you just can't live without? Not players that they have to keep because of the current situation (Booth, T2, AB, Rivers, Patterson) but which players are you really excited about because they could represent an important part of the future for the NY Giants?

        For me, its only 3 players from the entire list: Beason, Joseph and Stevie Brown. McBride and Mundy get honorable mention because I don't really know what they have with them yet.

        What does that say about the Giants right now?
        I agree with your assessment and it underscores that we have alot of holes to fill.
        I like to look at the positive side of this. With a large group of players like this moving into free agency, it will be easy to upgrade without breaking the bank.
        No one remembers who came in second.

        Comment


        • #5
          Curtis Painter, QB
          Andre Brown, RB (Keep)
          Peyton Hillis, RB
          Louis Murphy, WR
          Hakeem Nicks, WR (Keep)
          Julian Talley, WR
          Brandon Myers, TE
          Bear Pascoe, TE
          David Diehl, OL
          Kevin Boothe, OL
          Justin Tuck, DE
          Linval Joseph, DT (Keep)
          Mike Patterson, DT
          Shaun Rogers, DT
          Keith Rivers, LB (Keep)
          Jon Beason, LB (Keep)
          Trumaine McBride, CB (Keep)
          Aaron Ross, CB
          Terrell Thomas, CB (Keep)
          Stevie Brown, S (Keep)
          Ryan Mundy, S (Keep)
          Josh Brown, (Keep)

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by jomo View Post
            I agree with your assessment and it underscores that we have alot of holes to fill.
            I like to look at the positive side of this. With a large group of players like this moving into free agency, it will be easy to upgrade without breaking the bank.
            That's what I'm talking about, obviously we're going to need some of these guys for depth purposes. I'm more excited to see what happens in FA than the draft at this point.

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by jomo View Post
              I agree with your assessment and it underscores that we have alot of holes to fill.
              I like to look at the positive side of this. With a large group of players like this moving into free agency, it will be easy to upgrade without breaking the bank.
              That is a great way to look at it and let's hope the Giants do the extensive pruning that is necessary to begin to turn this thing around!

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by Red Dog View Post
                New York Giants

                Curtis Painter, QB
                Andre Brown, RB
                Peyton Hillis, RB keeper
                Louis Murphy, WR
                Hakeem Nicks, WR
                Julian Talley, WR
                Brandon Myers, TE keeper
                Bear Pascoe, TE
                David Diehl, OL
                Kevin Boothe, OL
                Justin Tuck, DE
                Linval Joseph, DT keeper
                Mike Patterson, DT keeper
                Shaun Rogers, DT
                Keith Rivers, LB keeper
                Jon Beason, LB keeper
                Trumaine McBride, CB
                Aaron Ross, CB
                Terrell Thomas, CB keeper
                Stevie Brown, S keeper
                Ryan Mundy, S
                Josh Brown, keeper
                Keep...

                Joseph, Beason, McBride, both Browns & TT ---- ok with everyone else going bye-bye and that includes Tuck.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Curtis Painter, QB
                  Andre Brown, RB
                  Peyton Hillis, RB
                  Louis Murphy, WR
                  Hakeem Nicks, WR
                  Julian Talley, WR
                  Brandon Myers, TE
                  Bear Pascoe, TE keep
                  David Diehl, OL
                  Kevin Boothe, OL keep
                  Justin Tuck, DE keep
                  Linval Joseph, DT keep
                  Mike Patterson, DT keep
                  Shaun Rogers, DT
                  Keith Rivers, LB keeper
                  Jon Beason, LB keeper
                  Trumaine McBride, CB keep
                  Aaron Ross, CB
                  Terrell Thomas, CB
                  Stevie Brown, S keep
                  Ryan Mundy, S keep
                  Josh Brown, keep

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Curtis Painter, QB
                    Andre Brown, RB - keep
                    Peyton Hillis, RB - keep
                    Louis Murphy, WR
                    Hakeem Nicks, WR
                    Julian Talley, WR
                    Brandon Myers, TE
                    Bear Pascoe, TE - keep
                    David Diehl, OL
                    Kevin Boothe, OL - keep
                    Justin Tuck, DE - keep
                    Linval Joseph, DT - KEEP!
                    Mike Patterson, DT - keep
                    Shaun Rogers, DT
                    Keith Rivers, LB
                    Jon Beason, LB - KEEP!
                    Trumaine McBride, CB - keep
                    Aaron Ross, CB
                    Terrell Thomas, CB - keep
                    Stevie Brown, S - keep
                    Ryan Mundy, S
                    Josh Brown,

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Curtis Painter, QB - Who cares
                      Andre Brown, RB - Keep, played well last year and won't be that expensive
                      Peyton Hillis, RB - Not a fan, cya
                      Louis Murphy, WR - Didn't do anything last year, goodbye
                      Hakeem Nicks, WR - Ineffective and too expensive, gone
                      Julian Talley, WR - Put him on practice squad or something, wouldn't care if he stayed or left
                      Brandon Myers, TE - His contract has been voided already. Wouldn't mind bringing him back as a #2 for cheap but he's not starting material
                      Bear Pascoe, TE - Keep, nice depth for TE/FB
                      David Diehl, OL - Didn't he retire? Gone
                      Kevin Boothe, OL - A serviceable, versatile offensive linemen. Keep
                      Justin Tuck, DE - Keep if the price is right but I fear it won't be. Probably leaving
                      Linval Joseph, DT - #1 priority, but he'll be very expensive. Giants should do their best to keep him, but don't totally break the bank
                      Mike Patterson, DT - Keep for cheap
                      Shaun Rogers, DT - Injured and old, cya
                      Keith Rivers, LB - Probably gone. Hasn't done much in the few games he's been healthy for
                      Jon Beason, LB - Definitely keep. Reenergized our defense last year and is a solid linebacker to boot
                      Trumaine McBride, CB - Keep. Played well above anyone's expectations last year
                      Aaron Ross, CB - Oftenly injured but played decent in the the games he played last year. He'll want to come back so bring him back if the price is right
                      Terrell Thomas, CB - He was decent last year. He'll definitely want to come back but he's not a top priority. Keep him though
                      Stevie Brown, S - Definitely keep.
                      Ryan Mundy, S - He's alright. Maybe he'll stick around for depth.
                      Josh Brown, K - Keep. Played decent last year

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by PennState1 View Post
                        I don't want to hijack your thread but it would be interesting to ask this...

                        Who, on this list, are the players that you just can't live without? Not players that they have to keep because of the current situation (Booth, T2, AB, Rivers, Patterson) but which players are you really excited about because they could represent an important part of the future for the NY Giants?

                        For me, its only 3 players from the entire list: Beason, Joseph and Stevie Brown. McBride and Mundy get honorable mention because I don't really know what they have with them yet.

                        What does that say about the Giants right now?
                        Good points on this angle. I'd add one more. Believe it or not I'd want to see Hillis back. We have a lot of questions st RB coming into this season. Hillis is a good dependable back. Strong runner with decent power and a good receiver. I think his skill set might work well with what McAdoo could be running.

                        I'd love Joseph back but we have good low cost depth there. Great if we can keep him at a reasonable cost, but not an "all cost" keep. Beason is a must keep IMO.

                        There are others we could keep. That will come down to money.
                        # 80 (For FBomb)

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          I think you are right about Hillis. I'd put him in that group of "need to re sign because of current" circumstances with T2, Booth, AB, Rivers and Patterson.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Priority signings: (in order of importance)
                            1) Jon Beason, LB
                            2) Stevie Brown, S
                            3) Trumaine McBride, CB
                            4) Mike Patterson, DT (although if Linval is re-signed this is not AS important anymore)
                            5) Kevin Boothe, OL

                            Nice to have if healthy:
                            Terrell Thomas, CB
                            Andre Brown, RB
                            Peyton Hillis, RB
                            Shaun Rogers, DT

                            Nice to have but don't break the bank for them
                            Justin Tuck, DE
                            Linval Joseph, DT
                            Hakeem Nicks, WR
                            Henry Hynoski, FB

                            Middle of the road:
                            Brandon Myers, TE
                            Aaron Ross, CB
                            Josh Brown, K
                            Bear Pascoe, TE
                            Ryan Mundy, S
                            Spencer Paysinger, LB

                            Retired:
                            David Diehl, OL
                            Brandon Jacobs, RB

                            Don't bother:
                            Louis Murphy, WR
                            Julian Talley, WR
                            Curtis Painter, QB
                            Keith Rivers, LB
                            Mark Herzlich, LB
                            Corey Toaster, CB
                            Last edited by Toadofsteel; 02-13-2014, 10:36 PM.

                            I'm Commander Shepard, and this is my favorite team in the NFL.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              ([QUOTE=Red Dog;1075251]New York Giants

                              Curtis Painter, QB(cut)(
                              Andre Brown, RB(keep
                              Peyton Hillis, RB(cut)
                              Louis Murphy, WR(keep for depth)
                              Hakeem Nicks, WR (bye)
                              Julian Talley( probably cut)
                              Brandon Myers, TE (cut)
                              Bear Pascoe, TE((keep if no better options)
                              David Diehl, OL(retired-thankyou for your service)
                              Kevin Boothe, OL (keep 1yr for depth)
                              Justin Tuck, DE(keep 1yr)
                              Linval Joseph, DT(keep)
                              Mike Patterson, DT(keep)
                              Shaun Rogers, DT(maybe keep)
                              Keith Rivers, LB(maybe keep)
                              Jon Beason, LB(keep Please)
                              Trumaine McBride, CB(keep)(
                              Aaron Ross, CB(bye)
                              Terrell Thomas, CB (keep)
                              Stevie Brown, S(keep)
                              Ryan Mundy, S(keep)
                              Josh Brown(keep),

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X