Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Will the giants resign-Manningham?Ballard?Mckenzie

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Will the giants resign-Manningham?Ballard?Mckenzie

    The list of Giants UFA's is not too bad sign or let go?

    Manningham-

    Jake Ballard

    Kareem McKenzie

    Aaron Ross

    Terrell Thomas

    Jonathon Goff

  • #2
    Re: Will the giants resign-Manningham?Ballard?Mckenzie

    I don't know about the rest, but Ross is having a decent season, and so will probably get more than he's worth somewhere else.

    And when I say "decent", I mean not COMPLETE garbage.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Will the giants resign-Manningham?Ballard?Mckenzie

      they won't resign 5 of the 6 of them so rookie free agents can step up. The Giants don't believe in sexy moves currently.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Will the giants resign-Manningham?Ballard?Mckenzie

        they won't resign 5 of the 6 of them so rookie free agents can step up. The Giants don't believe in sexy moves currently.

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Will the giants resign-Manningham?Ballard?Mckenzie

          Tough call with two of those guys coming off IR. I'd like to see TT come back. I'd like Manningham as well, but WR isn't a necessity going into next year and if they can spend money on a RB or another area of need that would probably be the better move.

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Will the giants resign-Manningham?Ballard?Mckenzie

            [quote user="RagTime Blue"]I don't know about the rest, but Ross is having a decent season, and so will probably get more than he's worth somewhere else.

            And when I say "decent", I mean not COMPLETE garbage.
            [/quote]

            Wrong, Aaron Ross is complete garbage. He has cost us games this year. He is a awful cover corner and a awful punt returner (muffed punt anyone?)

            Manningham is gone since he signed that agent to represent him, the giants won't pay him the 4 million he is going to outrageously demand as an average receiver.

            I hope they sign t2 to a one year contract to see if he has recovered from his injury.

            Ballard they will keep.

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Will the giants resign-Manningham?Ballard?Mckenzie



              [quote user="MikeSherrard"]The list of Giants UFA's is not too bad sign or let go?

              Manningham-

              Jake Ballard

              Kareem McKenzie

              Aaron Ross

              Terrell Thomas

              Jonathon Goff
              [/quote]With Goff and Thomas coming of ACL surgeries, they may get a contract cheap to see how well they recovered from the injuries. I worry for Thomas since that is his 2nd ACL surgery on the same knee.







              I think the Giants keep Ballard but look at TE somewhere in the draft and give up on the Beckum experiment.







              I think McKenzie is gone. I'm up in the air with Ross and Manningham. I'm confident though that the Giants can find a WR in the mid to later rounds in the draft, so thats not a big deal to me. I think they should address CB in the draft, especially if Thomas and Ross are not re-signed. I love Claiborne and Kirkpatrick, but they may be gone by the time the Giants draft in rd 1. I think they can go after a Minnifield or Boykin in the 2nd or 3rd rd.

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Will the giants resign-Manningham?Ballard?Mckenzie

                Barden is looking decent we will see how it goes the rest of the way which gives a better chance of Mario not coming back with Cruz emerging.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Will the giants resign-Manningham?Ballard?Mckenzie

                  Manningham - GONE

                  McKenzie - GONE

                  Ross - GONE

                  Ballard - Probably back, but I like Pascoe a lot

                  T2 - Hopefully back. He's gonna' get a cheap 'show me' contract, but I think he wants to be here in New York.

                  Goff - Hopefully back. He's not worth a lot, but maybe a 1 or 2 year contract to see if he can keep getting better

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Will the giants resign-Manningham?Ballard?Mckenzie

                    Manningham is gone i would laugh my *** off if they sign steve smith that would be hilarious. I believe the FO wont do crap but get cheap FA and sit the rookies on the bench.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Will the giants resign-Manningham?Ballard?Mckenzie

                      Manningham, I would say probably. He hasn't had a good year, and he's a great speed threat. The only way I don't see them signing him is if Steve Smith comes back from the Eagles to be the number 3.

                      Ballard - no brainer. They sign him.

                      Kareem - nope, he's old, he's done.

                      Aaron Ross - unless he greats a great deal elsewhere expect him back. He knows the defense and over all he's had a good year.

                      Terell Thomas - I would ASSUME he will be back on a 1 year deal. But you never know.

                      Goff - Who really knows. At this point i'd say maybe. If the price is right but he wasn't a world beater before he trashed his knee so I am going to guess no.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Will the giants resign-Manningham?Ballard?Mckenzie

                        [quote user="Overdrive92"]Manningham - GONE

                        McKenzie - GONE

                        Ross - GONE

                        Ballard - Probably back, but I like Pascoe a lot

                        T2 - Hopefully back. He's gonna' get a cheap 'show me' contract, but I think he wants to be here in New York.

                        Goff - Hopefully back. He's not worth a lot, but maybe a 1 or 2 year contract to see if he can keep getting better[/quote]

                        I don't see any reason to let Ross go. Sure he's not a great player by any means but he also won't command a lot of money here or anywhere else. So the only reason I could see to let him go would be us having 5 or 6 better CBs on this squad, which I highly doubt.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Will the giants resign-Manningham?Ballard?Mckenzie

                          [quote user="Overdrive92"]Manningham - GONE

                          McKenzie - GONE

                          Ross - GONE

                          Ballard - Probably back, but I like Pascoe a lot

                          T2 - Hopefully back. He's gonna' get a cheap 'show me' contract, but I think he wants to be here in New York.

                          Goff - Hopefully back. He's not worth a lot, but maybe a 1 or 2 year contract to see if he can keep getting better[/quote]

                          I agree with you on everything but Pascoe. He is simply not an NFL quality player. He will definitely not be on our roster next year and I doubt that he makes another team's roster. Look for him to be completely out of football next year.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Will the giants resign-Manningham?Ballard?Mckenzie

                            [quote user="MikeSherrard"]The list of Giants UFA's is not too bad sign or let go?

                            Manningham - With the emergence of Victor Cruz, I don't see him staying, unless he receives very limited offers. I just think we'll be significantly outbid.

                            Jake Ballard - I think he gets resigned
                            Kareem McKenzie - This may well be his last season in Blue, or football for that matter.

                            Aaron Ross - fat chance

                            Terrell Thomas - this really depends on his contract demands. I'm sure the Giants will try to get him back, but coming off surgery, someone else may make a high dollar bid, like the eagles did with SS12.

                            Jonathon Goff - I see him resigning for reasonable dollars.
                            [/quote]

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Will the giants resign-Manningham?Ballard?Mckenzie

                              [quote user="MikeSherrard"]The list of Giants UFA's is not too bad sign or let go?

                              Manningham- YES - But for a mid-range contract

                              Jake Ballard- YES - It won't be for the contract Boss got in Oakland...which was way overpaid

                              Kareem McKenzie- Quite likely NO- unless he is will to take a significant paycut

                              Aaron Ross- TBD- will need to close out this season strong for us to pursue him hard...he is older

                              Terrell Thomas- YES- it may be a 1 year deal to see how much ability he retains after rehab...I'd give him a nice one year deal

                              Jonathon Goff- YES- the reasons are very obvious this year but could also be a 1 year deal for injury reasons...I'd also pad his 1 year deal well so he stays
                              [/quote]

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X