Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Who would you trade Osi or Kiwi?

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Who would you trade Osi or Kiwi?

    http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1...this-offseason

    Found this interesting.

  • #2
    Re: Who would you trade Osi or Kiwi?

    Osi. Kiwi was a year off a serious injury and looked ineffective. Imagine him next year.

    Osi is a very talented player, and can be a team guy, I just don't trust him. I think Kiwi is better for the team and can be equally as good and provide versatility. I'd rather give him a new contract.

    Plus, Osi could probably bring more compensation.
    My body was sculpted to the proportions of Michelangelo's David.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Who would you trade Osi or Kiwi?

      osi no doubt Kiwi can play end and lb shows up for every game.
      Bill Loyal to the NYG logo

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Who would you trade Osi or Kiwi?

        I guess Osi, but I'd keep Kiwi at LB if Osi were traded (stop moving back and forth).

        But I don't want either traded. Keep Osi for the final year of his contract. He's NOT going to pull a Shockey.

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Who would you trade Osi or Kiwi?

          Does anyone remember the last time we made a trade? I remember a few like the Rosenfels trade, but I mean like a really meaningful one.

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Who would you trade Osi or Kiwi?

            [quote user="jhamburg"]Does anyone remember the last time we made a trade? I remember a few like the Rosenfels trade, but I mean like a really meaningful one.[/quote]

            The trade for Eli?

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Who would you trade Osi or Kiwi?

              [quote user="gmen0820"]Osi. Kiwi was a year off a serious injury and looked ineffective. Imagine him next year.

              Osi is a very talented player, and can be a team guy, I just don't trust him. I think Kiwi is better for the team and can be equally as good and provide versatility. I'd rather give him a new contract.

              Plus, Osi could probably bring more compensation.[/quote]

              i thought kiwi looked very effective in a bunch of games but i do believe he wasn't "all there" meaning up to his ability. next season i expect a monster year.

              i'd trade neither. both are under contract, and osi for only one more season. IF I HAD to, then osi i guess bc u could get something for him if u knew u werent able to resign him

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Who would you trade Osi or Kiwi?

                [quote user="giantsfan420"][quote user="gmen0820"]Osi. Kiwi was a year off a serious injury and looked ineffective. Imagine him next year.

                Osi is a very talented player, and can be a team guy, I just don't trust him. I think Kiwi is better for the team and can be equally as good and provide versatility. I'd rather give him a new contract.

                Plus, Osi could probably bring more compensation.[/quote]

                i thought kiwi looked very effective in a bunch of games but i do believe he wasn't "all there" meaning up to his ability. next season i expect a monster year.

                i'd trade neither. both are under contract, and osi for only one more season. IF I HAD to, then osi i guess bc u could get something for him if u knew u werent able to resign him[/quote]That's weird. I never meant to put ineffective, I meant to put effective. Don't know how that happened. I've been on Kiwi's bandwagon all year.

                My mistake.
                My body was sculpted to the proportions of Michelangelo's David.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Who would you trade Osi or Kiwi?

                  [quote user="Elaxico"]http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1057978-5-new-york-giants-who-could-be-on-the-trading-block-this-offseason

                  Found this interesting.[/quote]

                  Why trade anyone? The group just accomplished something that has never been done before. No 9-7 team has ever won the SB trophy. Let's build upon what we have now through the draft & get stronger & win 2 in a row. What's wrong with that logic? Does it have to do with CAP room?

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Who would you trade Osi or Kiwi?

                    The most likely person on that list that I can see traded is DJ Ware.

                    No one is doing the Giants any favors by actually giving up assets for Diehl/Jacobs while inheriting their contracts. That's just foolish.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Who would you trade Osi or Kiwi?

                      [quote user="gmen0820"][quote user="giantsfan420"][quote user="gmen0820"]Osi. Kiwi was a year off a serious injury and looked ineffective. Imagine him next year.

                      Osi is a very talented player, and can be a team guy, I just don't trust him. I think Kiwi is better for the team and can be equally as good and provide versatility. I'd rather give him a new contract.

                      Plus, Osi could probably bring more compensation.[/quote]

                      i thought kiwi looked very effective in a bunch of games but i do believe he wasn't "all there" meaning up to his ability. next season i expect a monster year.

                      i'd trade neither. both are under contract, and osi for only one more season. IF I HAD to, then osi i guess bc u could get something for him if u knew u werent able to resign him[/quote]That's weird. I never meant to put ineffective, I meant to put effective. Don't know how that happened. I've been on Kiwi's bandwagon all year.

                      My mistake.[/quote]

                      yeah i figured. it caught me a lil off guard bc i remember u praising kiwi when a few other posters would say to move him to DE.

                      Honestly, I'd like to see him improve upon being a LB, but if we trade osi, i could see him being moved back to DE which would be real unfair to him. he'd prob do it bc he's unselfish and an awesome team first guy, i think he laid a good foundation to build upon to becoming an excellent every down lb.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Who would you trade Osi or Kiwi?

                        I'd need a young stud LB or OL to do that.
                        No one remembers who came in second.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Who would you trade Osi or Kiwi?

                          [quote user="giantsfan420"][quote user="gmen0820"][quote user="giantsfan420"][quote user="gmen0820"]Osi. Kiwi was a year off a serious injury and looked ineffective. Imagine him next year.

                          Osi is a very talented player, and can be a team guy, I just don't trust him. I think Kiwi is better for the team and can be equally as good and provide versatility. I'd rather give him a new contract.

                          Plus, Osi could probably bring more compensation.[/quote]

                          i thought kiwi looked very effective in a bunch of games but i do believe he wasn't "all there" meaning up to his ability. next season i expect a monster year.

                          i'd trade neither. both are under contract, and osi for only one more season. IF I HAD to, then osi i guess bc u could get something for him if u knew u werent able to resign him[/quote]That's weird. I never meant to put ineffective, I meant to put effective. Don't know how that happened. I've been on Kiwi's bandwagon all year.

                          My mistake.[/quote]

                          yeah i figured. it caught me a lil off guard bc i remember u praising kiwi when a few other posters would say to move him to DE.

                          Honestly, I'd like to see him improve upon being a LB, but if we trade osi, i could see him being moved back to DE which would be real unfair to him. he'd prob do it bc he's unselfish and an awesome team first guy, i think he laid a good foundation to build upon to becoming an excellent every down lb.[/quote]Yeah I agree, he is a force vs the run and I'd like to see him 2 years in a row at LB to see how he plays. I mean, he played LB in 2010 too, but that was a short season for him, but up to that point, he was probably our best D player (granted it was like 4 games). I had a nice write up in the offseason when I did a full season notes write up thread, can't find it though.

                          Had a couple videos of him in the NASCAR alignment as well as us playing a little bit of a 50 front. I'm very high on Kiwi. When he came back at 2 years 8 mil, I was ecstatic. He's only gonna get better which is odd to say considering he's entering his 6th year.
                          My body was sculpted to the proportions of Michelangelo's David.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Who would you trade Osi or Kiwi?

                            For whatever my opinion is worth, I see Kiwi as a poor man's Terell Suggs for a 4-3 defense.

                            In terms of trade value, I'd have to think Osi would be on more teams radars than Kiwi at the moment. I could see Osi being able to transition easily to a 3-4 rush OLB if needed to or just playing RDE in a 4-3 for another team. It would have to be to a team that only needs a few pieces since he's not a young player.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Who would you trade Osi or Kiwi?

                              I would love to see both of them stay. But if one of the 2 had to be traded I would say Osi because he is older.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X