Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Kurt Warner is over-rated.

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Kurt Warner is over-rated.

    He is an indoors QB who couldn't hack it in New York.

    Be quiet Warner. Eli is BETTER than you.

  • #2
    Re: Kurt Warner is over-rated.

    [quote user="NYBlue10"]He is an indoors QB who couldn't hack it in New York.

    Be quiet Warner. Eli is BETTER than you.[/quote] I don't think there was anything wrong with what he said.
    Mood: WOOF!

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Kurt Warner is over-rated.

      [quote user="NYBlue10"]He is an indoors QB who couldn't hack it in New York.

      Be quiet Warner. Eli is BETTER than you.[/quote]

      You took out of context what he said about Eli not being a lock NOW,....the key word is now. And he's right. Eli is just now coming into himself. He had a great year, and yes 2 superbowls, not many QBs can say that. But warner meant he isn't a lock right this second. He doesn't have to win more SBs to get in, but now be consistent with is play. Meaning he can't throw another 25 ints next year. He didn't knock the kid, just made a factual statement in his opinion.
      I miss Red Hook

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Kurt Warner is over-rated.

        [quote user="Rudyy"][quote user="NYBlue10"]He is an indoors QB who couldn't hack it in New York.

        Be quiet Warner. Eli is BETTER than you.[/quote] I don't think there was anything wrong with what he said.[/quote]
        He said Eli is not consistent enough, this coming from who plain SUCKED in New York? Warner has no business criticizing Eli's consistency.

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Kurt Warner is over-rated.

          [quote user="NYBlue10"][quote user="Rudyy"][quote user="NYBlue10"]He is an indoors QB who couldn't hack it in New York.

          Be quiet Warner. Eli is BETTER than you.[/quote] I don't think there was anything wrong with what he said.[/quote]
          He said Eli is not consistent enough, this coming from who plain SUCKED in New York? Warner has no business criticizing Eli's consistency.[/quote] But it's true, Eli isn't consistent. He's not saying there is no say he'll my get into the hall of fame, but he needs to produce consistent numbers.
          Mood: WOOF!

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Kurt Warner is over-rated.

            [quote user="Rudyy"][quote user="NYBlue10"][quote user="Rudyy"][quote user="NYBlue10"]He is an indoors QB who couldn't hack it in New York.

            Be quiet Warner. Eli is BETTER than you.[/quote] I don't think there was anything wrong with what he said.[/quote]
            He said Eli is not consistent enough, this coming from who plain SUCKED in New York? Warner has no business criticizing Eli's consistency.[/quote] But it's true, Eli isn't consistent. He's not saying there is no say he'll my get into the hall of fame, but he needs to produce consistent numbers.[/quote]

            You may want to take a look at Eli's numbers season to season. He's more consistent than you think...

            or have been told???
            My 5 year old son right before the kickoff of the Super Bowl 46: Dad, are the Giants gonna win?

            Burier: Yes.

            My 5 year old son right before the kickoff of Super Bowl 46: Do you promise?

            Burier: Yes. I promise.

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Kurt Warner is over-rated.

              My only issue with what Kurt Warner had to say is...who is he to talk? The guy had 6 productive seasons in the nfl. Eli will have met or surpassed every stat warner has posted. Personally, I do not think warner even belongs in a HOF discussion himself after being productive for such a small period of time. Had he played and produced for another 4+ years then yea I get it. But by no means do I hear Kurt Warner's name and think oh man that guy was one of the best qbs to ever play the game. that is my issue with kurt saying what he said.

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Kurt Warner is over-rated.

                [quote user="Rudyy"][quote user="NYBlue10"][quote user="Rudyy"][quote user="NYBlue10"]He is an indoors QB who couldn't hack it in New York.

                Be quiet Warner. Eli is BETTER than you.[/quote] I don't think there was anything wrong with what he said.[/quote]
                He said Eli is not consistent enough, this coming from who plain SUCKED in New York? Warner has no business criticizing Eli's consistency.[/quote] But it's true, Eli isn't consistent. He's not saying there is no say he'll my get into the hall of fame, but he needs to produce consistent numbers.[/quote]
                Warner must be referring to last year's INT numbers, well was all of it Eli's fault? No, lot of those passes bounced off the receivers. Was Eli's production numbers bad? Not at all, Eli still won 10 games last season, I just don't see the consistency issue nonsense. 2 titles in 5 years seem very consistent to me.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Kurt Warner is over-rated.

                  Kurt is not over rated.

                  Kurt likes Eli, and he is still close to Coughlin.

                  What Kurt was getting at was this:

                  Most of Eli's career, he has been a good QB and has good numbers. That does not get you into the Hall of Fame. That is correct.

                  It really was not until 2011 that you could say Eli is a great QB.

                  If Eli puts together 4-5 more seasons like he did in 2011, and couple that with two titles and two SB MVPs, then he is in the conversation.

                  If Eli and the GIANTS can get to another SB, then he becomes more of a sure thing. If the GIANTS win another SB, and Eli plays well in it, then he is a lock.

                  Bottom Line: Eli is now a top-5 QB. If he stays one throughout the rest of his prime, then he gets to Canton someday.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Kurt Warner is over-rated.

                    [quote user="Tommy_Ribs"]Kurt is not over rated.

                    Kurt likes Eli, and he is still close to Coughlin.

                    What Kurt was getting at was this:

                    Most of Eli's career, he has been a good QB and has good numbers.* That does not get you into the Hall of Fame.* That is correct.

                    It really was not until 2011 that you could say Eli is a great QB.

                    If Eli puts together 4-5 more seasons like he did in 2011, and couple that with two titles and two SB MVPs, then he is in the conversation.

                    If Eli and the GIANTS can get to another SB, then he becomes more of a sure thing.* If the GIANTS win another SB, and Eli plays well in it, then he is a lock.

                    Bottom Line: Eli is now a top-5 QB.* If he stays one throughout the rest of his prime, then he gets to Canton someday.
                    [/quote]
                    I disagree, Warner is TOTALLY OVER-RATED. He is indoors-only QB. If Eli doesn't belong in HOF right now, Warner is even farther out.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Kurt Warner is over-rated.

                      Hey Kurt.... Do you want to talk about consistency? Lets look at your mid career.

                      2002...... 0-6 record, 1431 passing yards, 3 TDs, 11 INTs, 67 QB rating
                      2003...... 0-1 record, 365 passing yards, 1 TD, 1 INT, 72 QB rating
                      2004...... 5-4 record, 2054 passing yards, 6 TDs, 4 INTs, 86 QB rating
                      2005...... 2-5 record, 2713 passing yards, 11 TDs, 9 INTs, 85 QB rating
                      2006...... 1-4 record, 1377 passing yards, 6 TDs, 5 INTs......

                      The list goes on and on. Is that the consistency of a hall of fame QB?


                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Kurt Warner is over-rated.

                        [quote user="Tommy_Ribs"]Kurt is not over rated.

                        Kurt likes Eli, and he is still close to Coughlin.

                        What Kurt was getting at was this:

                        Most of Eli's career, he has been a good QB and has good numbers.* That does not get you into the Hall of Fame.* That is correct.

                        It really was not until 2011 that you could say Eli is a great QB.

                        If Eli puts together 4-5 more seasons like he did in 2011, and couple that with two titles and two SB MVPs, then he is in the conversation.

                        If Eli and the GIANTS can get to another SB, then he becomes more of a sure thing.* If the GIANTS win another SB, and Eli plays well in it, then he is a lock.

                        Bottom Line: Eli is now a top-5 QB.* If he stays one throughout the rest of his prime, then he gets to Canton someday.
                        [/quote] this.
                        Mood: WOOF!

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Kurt Warner is over-rated.

                          [quote user="NYBlue10"][quote user="Tommy_Ribs"]Kurt is not over rated.

                          Kurt likes Eli, and he is still close to Coughlin.

                          What Kurt was getting at was this:

                          Most of Eli's career, he has been a good QB and has good numbers. That does not get you into the Hall of Fame. That is correct.

                          It really was not until 2011 that you could say Eli is a great QB.

                          If Eli puts together 4-5 more seasons like he did in 2011, and couple that with two titles and two SB MVPs, then he is in the conversation.

                          If Eli and the GIANTS can get to another SB, then he becomes more of a sure thing. If the GIANTS win another SB, and Eli plays well in it, then he is a lock.

                          Bottom Line: Eli is now a top-5 QB. If he stays one throughout the rest of his prime, then he gets to Canton someday.
                          [/quote]
                          I disagree, Warner is TOTALLY OVER-RATED. He is indoors-only QB. If Eli doesn't belong in HOF right now, Warner is even farther out.[/quote]

                          Kurt Warner is as brilliant a passer that has ever played in this league, and the ONLY reason he didn't have an even better career is because that lunatic Mike Martz almost killed him.

                          The St Louis Rams did things on Offense that the rest of the league can only do now, 13 years later with the specific help of Rules Changes,

                          Think what you want, but Warner was a great QB.

                          Eli is a great QB now, and is my guy, but that doesn't diminish what Kurt did.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Kurt Warner is over-rated.

                            I tend to think Kurt intentionally forgot to mention all of Eli's other attributes.... he was too busy blasting him over the inconsistency. There is more to Eli's body of work than his two SBMVPS.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Kurt Warner is over-rated.

                              And Warner can cut it out with this whole "Im just stating the facts" Routine.

                              This clown has done 100 interviews since the Superbowl about how Eli shouldn't be in the HOF.

                              overrated and soft. Needed to have the best player in the league at a skill position to even get close to busting a grape.

                              My 5 year old son right before the kickoff of the Super Bowl 46: Dad, are the Giants gonna win?

                              Burier: Yes.

                              My 5 year old son right before the kickoff of Super Bowl 46: Do you promise?

                              Burier: Yes. I promise.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X