New York Giants Message Boards

Tuffy44:

There is a difference between good and Elite , I can name you 15 Qb's that are around as good as Eli and some that are better. Of course it is a matter of perception so I cant tell you not to call him elite, just as you can't force myself and others to call him Elite. I do know he has improved year to year.

I'd like to see that list. There is subjective and then there is evident, I don't see that many QBs in the discussion, especially after this year.

---

Follow me: twitter.com/BSchujasNYG

gmen0820:

Tuffy44:

There is a difference between good and Elite , I can name you 15 Qb's that are around as good as Eli and some that are better. Of course it is a matter of perception so I cant tell you not to call him elite, just as you can't force myself and others to call him Elite. I do know he has improved year to year.

I'd like to see that list. There is subjective and then there is evident, I don't see that many QBs in the discussion, especially after this year.

One year doesnt make for a career ,it is the body of work.

---

Tuffy44:

There is a difference between good and Elite , I can name you 15 Qb's that are around as good as Eli and some that are better. Of course it is a matter of perception so I cant tell you not to call him elite, just as you can't force myself and others to call him Elite. I do know he has improved year to year.

Actually, you can't.

All you can do is give your opinion about 15 QBs whom you feel are around as good as Eli.

I have no desire to attempt to force you to call him elite, nor to call him that myself...why would I? I think the whole elite thing is a crock of crap created by morons in the media.

Tuffy44:

gmen0820:

Tuffy44:

There is a difference between good and Elite , I can name you 15 Qb's that are around as good as Eli and some that are better. Of course it is a matter of perception so I cant tell you not to call him elite, just as you can't force myself and others to call him Elite. I do know he has improved year to year.

I'd like to see that list. There is subjective and then there is evident, I don't see that many QBs in the discussion, especially after this year.

One year doesnt make for a career ,it is the body of work.

Let the backpedaling begin!

You see what you get for trying to engage him with logic, 820?

Sarcasman:

Tuffy44:

There is a difference between good and Elite , I can name you 15 Qb's that are around as good as Eli and some that are better. Of course it is a matter of perception so I cant tell you not to call him elite, just as you can't force myself and others to call him Elite. I do know he has improved year to year.

Actually, you can't.

All you can do is give your opinion about 15 QBs whom you feel are around as good as Eli.

I have no desire to attempt to force you to call him elite, nor to call him that myself...why would I? I think the whole elite thing is a crock of crap created by morons in the media.

Well you are sane some here feel they need to force feed it, how many eli is elite threads do you see and how many eli is not elite threads? i see 3 eli is elite threads in the first page alone. I feel as if i am being forced to agree he is the best QB in the NFL.

---

Sarcasman:

Tuffy44:

gmen0820:

Tuffy44:

There is a difference between good and Elite , I can name you 15 Qb's that are around as good as Eli and some that are better. Of course it is a matter of perception so I cant tell you not to call him elite, just as you can't force myself and others to call him Elite. I do know he has improved year to year.

I'd like to see that list. There is subjective and then there is evident, I don't see that many QBs in the discussion, especially after this year.

One year doesnt make for a career ,it is the body of work.

Let the backpedaling begin!

You see what you get for trying to engage him with logic, 820?

Oh well

---

Follow me: twitter.com/BSchujasNYG

Tuffy44:

Sarcasman:

Tuffy44:

There is a difference between good and Elite , I can name you 15 Qb's that are around as good as Eli and some that are better. Of course it is a matter of perception so I cant tell you not to call him elite, just as you can't force myself and others to call him Elite. I do know he has improved year to year.

Actually, you can't. All you can do is give your opinion about 15 QBs whom you feel are around as good as Eli. I have no desire to attempt to force you to call him elite, nor to call him that myself...why would I? I think the whole elite thing is a crock of crap created by morons in the media.

Well you are sane some here feel they need to force feed it, how many eli is elite threads do you see and how many eli is not elite threads? i see 3 eli is elite threads in the first page alone. I feel as if i am being forced to agree he is the best QB in the NFL.

and why do let other people's opinions bother you??

How do you get force fed by a message board???

 

---

Measure twice......cut once.

Tuffy44:

Sarcasman:

Tuffy44:

There is a difference between good and Elite , I can name you 15 Qb's that are around as good as Eli and some that are better. Of course it is a matter of perception so I cant tell you not to call him elite, just as you can't force myself and others to call him Elite. I do know he has improved year to year.

Actually, you can't.

All you can do is give your opinion about 15 QBs whom you feel are around as good as Eli.

I have no desire to attempt to force you to call him elite, nor to call him that myself...why would I? I think the whole elite thing is a crock of crap created by morons in the media.

Well you are sane some here feel they need to force feed it, how many eli is elite threads do you see and how many eli is not elite threads? i see 3 eli is elite threads in the first page alone. I feel as if i am being forced to agree he is the best QB in the NFL.

Hardly... But you are just a fool if you dont think he is at least top 6 currently.


Ok ok... Maybe not a fool, but definitely not someone I want picking the QB on my team.

Lets just say, not very good at watching a football game in the eyes of a talent evaluator..

Tuffy44:

Sarcasman:

Tuffy44:

There is a difference between good and Elite , I can name you 15 Qb's that are around as good as Eli and some that are better. Of course it is a matter of perception so I cant tell you not to call him elite, just as you can't force myself and others to call him Elite. I do know he has improved year to year.

Actually, you can't.

All you can do is give your opinion about 15 QBs whom you feel are around as good as Eli.

I have no desire to attempt to force you to call him elite, nor to call him that myself...why would I? I think the whole elite thing is a crock of crap created by morons in the media.

Well you are sane some here feel they need to force feed it, how many eli is elite threads do you see and how many eli is not elite threads? i see 3 eli is elite threads in the first page alone. I feel as if i am being forced to agree he is the best QB in the NFL.

Are you always this easily led by peer pressure?

Do you like movies about gladiators?

GameTime:

Tuffy44:

Sarcasman:

Tuffy44:

There is a difference between good and Elite , I can name you 15 Qb's that are around as good as Eli and some that are better. Of course it is a matter of perception so I cant tell you not to call him elite, just as you can't force myself and others to call him Elite. I do know he has improved year to year.

Actually, you can't. All you can do is give your opinion about 15 QBs whom you feel are around as good as Eli. I have no desire to attempt to force you to call him elite, nor to call him that myself...why would I? I think the whole elite thing is a crock of crap created by morons in the media.

Well you are sane some here feel they need to force feed it, how many eli is elite threads do you see and how many eli is not elite threads? i see 3 eli is elite threads in the first page alone. I feel as if i am being forced to agree he is the best QB in the NFL.

and why do let other people's opinions bother you??

How do you get force fed by a message board???

 

3 threads GameTime...

3 THREADS GAMETIME!!!!

3!

---

Follow me: twitter.com/BSchujasNYG

Sarcasman:

Tuffy44:

gmen0820:

Tuffy44:

There is a difference between good and Elite , I can name you 15 Qb's that are around as good as Eli and some that are better. Of course it is a matter of perception so I cant tell you not to call him elite, just as you can't force myself and others to call him Elite. I do know he has improved year to year.

I'd like to see that list. There is subjective and then there is evident, I don't see that many QBs in the discussion, especially after this year.

One year doesnt make for a career ,it is the body of work.

Let the backpedaling begin!

You see what you get for trying to engage him with logic, 820?

So we judge a QB by his best year not his career? that seems very odd.

---

Tuffy44:

Sarcasman:

Tuffy44:

gmen0820:

Tuffy44:

There is a difference between good and Elite , I can name you 15 Qb's that are around as good as Eli and some that are better. Of course it is a matter of perception so I cant tell you not to call him elite, just as you can't force myself and others to call him Elite. I do know he has improved year to year.

I'd like to see that list. There is subjective and then there is evident, I don't see that many QBs in the discussion, especially after this year.

One year doesnt make for a career ,it is the body of work.

Let the backpedaling begin!

You see what you get for trying to engage him with logic, 820?

So we judge a QB by his best year not his career? that seems very odd.

How many years would you like to discuss?

10? 8?

Unless you are talking about retired players it's a moving target and kind of a stupid metric. But feel free to have at it.

By the way, if you're don't easily succumb to peer pressure then forget I asked about the gladiator stuff...

Sarcasman:

Tuffy44:

Sarcasman:

Tuffy44:

gmen0820:

Tuffy44:

There is a difference between good and Elite , I can name you 15 Qb's that are around as good as Eli and some that are better. Of course it is a matter of perception so I cant tell you not to call him elite, just as you can't force myself and others to call him Elite. I do know he has improved year to year.

I'd like to see that list. There is subjective and then there is evident, I don't see that many QBs in the discussion, especially after this year.

One year doesnt make for a career ,it is the body of work.

Let the backpedaling begin!

You see what you get for trying to engage him with logic, 820?

So we judge a QB by his best year not his career? that seems very odd.

How many years would you like to discuss?

10? 8?

Unless you are talking about retired players it's a moving target and kind of a stupid metric. But feel free to have at it.

By the way, if you're don't easily succumb to peer pressure then forget I asked about the gladiator stuff...

I'm sorry I live on planet earth. you?

---

Eli is akwardly the best in my eyes. My point is... out of the top three QBs this year A Rogers, D Brees, and evenT Brady I haven't seen the gutsy moves to keep the play alive with Eli's success while under such duress. The pass to Cruz down field was earily reminiscent of the Tyree pass. Not sure the others can make that throw with the defenders draped on them with Eli's consistency. Nothing against the other great ones of this era, but you have to give Eli his due credit and place him right in the mix amongst the other for his toughness.

The guy straight out balls with a poker face!

Go Blue!!!

---

"You can't tell which way the train went by just looking at the tracks"

Tuffy44:

Sarcasman:

Tuffy44:

Sarcasman:

Tuffy44:

gmen0820:

Tuffy44:

There is a difference between good and Elite , I can name you 15 Qb's that are around as good as Eli and some that are better. Of course it is a matter of perception so I cant tell you not to call him elite, just as you can't force myself and others to call him Elite. I do know he has improved year to year.

I'd like to see that list. There is subjective and then there is evident, I don't see that many QBs in the discussion, especially after this year.

One year doesnt make for a career ,it is the body of work.

Let the backpedaling begin!

You see what you get for trying to engage him with logic, 820?

So we judge a QB by his best year not his career? that seems very odd.

How many years would you like to discuss?

10? 8?

Unless you are talking about retired players it's a moving target and kind of a stupid metric. But feel free to have at it.

By the way, if you're don't easily succumb to peer pressure then forget I asked about the gladiator stuff...

I'm sorry I live on planet earth. you?

Look kid, I don't explain the jokes; ya either get 'em or you don't. Do you have any smart friends you could ask?

Interestingly you didn't answer the question about the number of years.