or how about you don't click on the thread and read it.Quote:
Originally Posted by ryan12
Its relevent topic of should we of left a player go or not. Its a GIANTS football topic...
So happy im not a mod anymore so i don't have to coddle the people who e-cry.
Its just like if you hear a song on the radio you don't like - instead of complaining about it - turn the station
-
11-20-2012, 05:40 PMMattMeyerBud
-
11-20-2012, 06:49 PMalentown paplus 45Quote:
Originally Posted by ashleymarie
-
11-20-2012, 07:07 PMnycsportzfanbingo..Quote:
Originally Posted by MattMeyerBud
-
11-20-2012, 08:53 PMAntwuan
Not really.
Manningham wanted a big role and the Giants couldn't afford him. Plus by the Giants not re-signing him saved more $$$ for the Giants, -
11-20-2012, 09:18 PMbearbryant
Yeh, we'll lose the NFC East w/o him!! Right!! This isn't on my top 5 questions I'd ask TC if I'd have lunch with him! Not even in the top 20!
But OK I'll bite. Since I don't understand their philosophy or reasoning, I can't say whether it was DUNB but I do know something else: If Eli and his entourage don't get it together in these last 6 games, I doubt if this will be one of the questions posed frequently to tommy boy while we're watching; not taking part in the playoffs. There are bigger fish to fry!Go Giants! -
11-21-2012, 08:37 AMryan12it was a joke Matt hence why i said haha. im glad your not a mod anymore either. to think i congratualted you on your up coming marriage and you say im "e-crying" not cool broQuote:
Originally Posted by MattMeyerBud
-
11-21-2012, 08:43 AMDwinsballgames
It wasn't dumb, it was just business. He was a UFA who chose to go elsewhere for more $ and a promised larger role. It's not like we cut him or traded him. Under those circumstances maybe you could have said it was dumb. He's a good player, but I don't think his not being here has any real bearing on our season so far.
-
11-21-2012, 09:37 AMBParcells777
We should have tried to keep him. He was a high draft choice and made some spectacular plays.........he was great in the red zone
SFO is now LOADED with WRs........maybe they would be willing to trade him back in the off season.
Why do we mess with Championship teams.........I do not recall Pittsburg or GB in their heydays changing anything as they repeated yr after yr -
11-21-2012, 09:40 AMGameTimeyeah...and the NFL and the CAP are the same as it was back then. Not having MM has 0 to do witht he Giants performance the last 4 weeks...Quote:
Originally Posted by BParcells777
Jakk....once again you make no sense.... -
11-21-2012, 09:55 AMTheAnalyst
Manningham was the #3 here, and still would be today. Nicks and Cruz are the 2 WRs the Giants are focused on resigning. Manham was here for 4 years. He did what he needed to do and helped get us a ring. We just drafted Rueben Randle, who the Giants actually considered drafting in the first round. He is the future #3 guy as long as Nicks and Cruz stay. You can't keep everyone.
So the answer to this thread's question, is ABSOLUTELY 100% NO!