GILBRIDE COST US THE GAME

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by YATittle1962

do you honestly believe thats how it goes down?

if you actually believe that this is what happens I weep for humanity

---

LMAO

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BuffyBlueII

KG is probably one of the worst OCs in NFL. We win in spite of him.

---

+1

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by YATittle1962

do you honestly believe thats how it goes down?

if you actually believe that this is what happens I weep for humanity

---

Obviously I know he doesn't design plays like that. It's the execution of those plays that hurt us time to time. It's the execution of the design I'm attacking really, not the actual design.

Wouldn't you as an OC want to design plays that can be executed fairly well, especially under stressful situations like 2 minute drills? That's my point

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BigBlue wins

Obviously I know he doesn't design plays like that. It's the execution of those plays that hurt us time to time. It's the execution of the design I'm attacking really, not the actual design.

Wouldn't you as an OC want to design plays that can be executed fairly well, especially under stressful situations like 2 minute drills? That's my point

---

so when the plays are executed correctly and successful its the players and when the they are not its the plays or design??
Its been said the Giants O is a bit complex.....ok great. Its still not brain surgery. Obviously it works and works well.
Dont know about you but it seems the Giants offense runs the best when it is under extreme stress!! Have you watched any games since 07????

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by YATittle1962

do you honestly believe thats how it goes down?

if you actually believe that this is what happens I weep for humanity

---

ha ha . . . . I feel your pain YA!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GameTime

so when the plays are executed correctly and successful its the players and when the they are not its the plays or design??
Its been said the Giants O is a bit complex.....ok great. Its still not brain surgery. Obviously it works and works well.
Dont know about you but it seems the Giants offense runs the best when it is under extreme stress!! Have you watched any games since 07????

---

Yes of course I have! I'm talking about the bad games because I'm criticizing Gilbride's scheme to be a bit too complex at times.

He's certainly good but there's a few guys I'd rank over him. Sean Payton, Josh McDaniels (crappy HC, awesome OC) Mike McCoy from Denver (anyone who gets to the playoffs with Tebow as a starting QB gets huge props lol), Maybe Chip Kelly too...These are just my personal preferences.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BigBlue wins

Yes of course I have! I'm talking about the bad games because I'm criticizing Gilbride's scheme to be a bit too complex at times.

---

Like I said so when its bad games its Gilbrides fault??? Not saying the guy doesnt make mistakes but bad games are way more then play designs. If his plays were so complicated and off the wall he wouldn't have a job let alone be succesfull and have 2 SBs with the Giants...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheEnigma

He's certainly good but there's a few guys I'd rank over him. Sean Payton, Josh McDaniels (crappy HC, awesome OC) Mike McCoy from Denver (anyone who gets to the playoffs with Tebow as a starting QB gets huge props lol), Maybe Chip Kelly too...These are just my personal preferences.

---

2 SBs for KG and the Giants say different....

Oh great now we have a OC who thinks he's Rex Ryan