Ok ok ok ..... after all these arguments about resigning players, who would you keep?

Nicks everyday and twice on Sunday..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GiantLegend

Nicks without hesitaiton. He had a bad injury year this past year, but he is without question a #1 receiver. I made a thread before about that, I watched last years playoffs and Super Bowl recently. Nicks was the difference maker. He is awesome.

To me Cruz is a replaceable slot receiver with some speed who drops some passes. I don't think it would be hard to replace that. I realize this is an unpopular opinion with most Giants fans.

---

This is what I was thinking. Eli has so much faith in Nicks. Who did Eli throw the hail mary pass to? Nicks because he knew with Nicks height no one else would get it but Nicks or Nicks would knock it away. Nicks is a baller. I pray he can stay healthy.

Nicks is a top 5 reciever in the NFL hands down if he's playing 100%

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by gmen0820

We should just tender Cruz, and if someone really wants him, lets take their first and if no one wants him, it's guaranteed 2.8 million.

---

Yes. The team that gets him will have to give up the picks AND pay him, which teams will be very reluctant to do (see Mike Wallace).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ashleymarie

This is what I was thinking. Eli has so much faith in Nicks. Who did Eli throw the hail mary pass to? Nicks because he knew with Nicks height no one else would get it but Nicks or Nicks would knock it away. Nicks is a baller. I pray he can stay healthy.

---

Nicks isnt that tall. Im about 6 1 and I was taller then him

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TCHOF

Yes. The team that gets him will have to give up the picks AND pay him, which teams will be very reluctant to do (see Mike Wallace).

---

Cruz is better, but I see your point.

If Cruz is really looking to get 8-10 Mil a year, I would have to go with Nicks. There are too many other needs on the team to put that much into one player when they already have Nicks, Randle and Hixon.Don't take me wrong, I like Cruz and would love to see him back, but not at the expense of having to go cheap on other positions.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kruunch

Cruz.

He doesn't get hurt.

---

Except for that hammy that put him on IR his rookie season.

deciding who is better between these two, in my opinion, is if you factor their injury history into the decision. Based on talent alone I say Nicks is better but since Nicks gets hurt more I can see how people think Cruz is the one you want to keep.