Bring Spags back!!!!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RoanokeFan

He had three seasons at St.Louis to change the trend. 10 wins in three years is dismal.

---

Granted, the team was a hot mess before he took the job, but he still should have been able to do better.

I, however, do not take his HC results too much in consideration when evaluating him as a DC. There's plenty of guys that are good coordinators yet poor head coaches.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Diamondring

Even good coaches make mistakes.

---

And if Spags had replaced Coughlin, as many here wished, and we went 10 - 38 in three years, we'd be cheering?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RoanokeFan

Can you imagine bringing Spags back after two failed adventures and we learn he isn't all that? This place would be erupting at Reese's incompetence.

---

I just don't get it. Anytime something goes wrong, fans look to the past. Passing game stalling? Bring back Manningham. Running game stalling? Bring back Jacobs.
The team doesn't share the same philosophy.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Drez

Granted, the team was a hot mess before he took the job, but he still should have been able to do better.

I, however, do not take his HC results too much in consideration when evaluating him as a DC. There's plenty of guys that are good coordinators yet poor head coaches.

---

Good point, so his next job was DC at NEW ORLEANS where they ranked 32nd. An established DC, not a noob.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RoanokeFan

He had three seasons at St.Louis to change the trend. 10 wins in three years is dismal.

---

Sometimes it takes longer than 3 years. We will see how well Fisher will do with coaching the Rams.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Flip Empty

I just don't get it. Anytime something goes wrong, fans look to the past. Passing game stalling? Bring back Manningham. Running game stalling? Bring back Jacobs.
The team doesn't share the same philosophy.

---

True enough, we are a fickle bunch. We won a Super Bowl with Spags and we won a Super Bowl with Fewell. Fewell's still here.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RoanokeFan

I'm starting to think the players made the coach

---

I'd say it's both.

Obviously you must have talent, but you also need good coaching. Athleticism, size, vision, brains, and heart vary from player to player and it's up to the coach to get the most out of the each player and meld them into a team.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Diamondring

Sometimes it takes longer than 3 years. We will see how well Fisher will do with coaching the Rams.

---

He sucks as a HC, under Spags they won 3 division games in 3 years, under Fisher they went 4-1-1..

RF you aren't grasping he had far worse players at St. Louis than the Giants, and far worse players in NO than the Giants have. Are you really comparing the players of the Rams to the Giants? Come on now... relax, nobody's going to take your Fewell away lol :).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Diamondring

Sometimes it takes longer than 3 years. We will see how well Fisher will do with coaching the Rams.

---

TC took the Jaguars from scratch and went to the AFC Championship game in year 2. THAT is a good coach.