give the giants a grade
with only 1 pick left, what do you all think of this draft for the giants overall.
this was by no means a sexy or flashy draft for us, but we got a few players that will contribute and hopefully will develop in time.
the pick that really intrigues me is cooper taylor, im excited to see this kid in action. I think he could play a great S/LB hybrid and be great against most TEs. this is my favorite pick of the draft.
the nassib pick, i understand we needed to start to mold a replacement for Eli and he was good value in the 4th but if we still have at the minimum assuming no injuries 6 years left with eli we could have waited another year or two to find value at the QB position and still give him enough time to develop. especially if we were giving up a 6th round pick in a draft where alot of quality players were dropping and a fourth round where numerous quality players were still available. Happy with nassib but could be happier.
overall i think it was a succesful draft, infuriating at times but now that its practically over i look back and nod and think just well done.
Giants have drafted one player who ran better than a 4.95 40.
I know they wanted to get big bodies, but Id give it a C at best.
If Pugh starts,
Hawkins > Canty
Nassib > Carr,
Moore = Osi - or shows potential
Taylor makes team.
would be real nice clark, real nice
not to mention the age differences.
Originally Posted by winstonsalem
Anywhere from E- to A+ depending on who plays where and if they can play at all!
wish we addressed LBs though
good thing 40's dont equal good football players.
Originally Posted by slipknottin
You act like we drafted skill positions which require top end speed. Taylor ran a 4.5 and moore ran a 4.9, which is one of the reasons why he slipped. Had he ran a 4.6 he would have easily gone in the 2nd.
Grade - B
Upgrades all over the field. even at backup QB. :)