Greatest QB ever

Automatic Otto Graham.

Nobody better than automatic Otto

[link]http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-game-highlights/09000d5d8074c956/Top-Ten-Records-Never-Be-Broken-Otto-Graham-s-10-Straight-Title-Games[/link]

Beast

1.Joe Montana
2.Terry Bradshaw
3.Tom Brady
4.John Elway
5.Otto Graham

Super Bowl or not, Marino was the most gifted and talented QB to ever play the position for me. Shame he never had a Super Bowl caliber team around him.

1. Marino
2. Montana
3. Unitas
4. Graham
5. Brady/Peyton

[quote user="Voldamort"]1.Joe Montana
2.Terry Bradshaw
3.Tom Brady
4.John Elway
5.Otto Graham[/quote]
talk to some old timers that were alive during Otto's day. They'll all say he was the greatest.

[quote user="Voldamort"]1.Joe Montana
2.Terry Bradshaw
3.Tom Brady
4.John Elway
5.Otto Graham[/quote]

Terry Bradshaw at #2? No Marino?

[quote user="EazyEManning"][quote user="Voldamort"]1.Joe Montana
2.Terry Bradshaw
3.Tom Brady
4.John Elway
5.Otto Graham[/quote]

Terry Bradshaw at #2? No Marino?
[/quote]
Wow, for guys here who say winning games makes you elite, you would think automatic Otto would be the most elite. He won 82% of his games.

[quote user="THE_New_York_Giants"][quote user="Voldamort"]1.Joe Montana
2.Terry Bradshaw
3.Tom Brady
4.John Elway
5.Otto Graham[/quote]
talk to some old timers that were alive during Otto's day. They'll all say he was the greatest.[/quote]

Talk to most veteran players now and they will probably say Montana or Bradshaw, it is all relative and nobody is wrong but we all only have so much experience to judge from. From what I seen from him he was a league above everyone else at the time but does that mean he tops my list, no he doesn't, but he is up there I'd probably go

Manning
Montana
Bradshaw
Elway
Graham

LOL you're using winning percentage as your argument? He was an All Time great don't get me wrong, but he played only 10 years and 12 games a year. I would hope he has a higher winning percentage than the QB's who played 16 games a year for 15-20 years.