Search:

Knowing HOW to play the positions but being ABLE to amounts to 2 very different things!! Diehl isn't able to play any position adequately.

Uh, actually he can't play ANY of the oline positions anymore. Just because he knows HOW to play them sure doesn't mean he's got the ability anymore. Being a good guy and teammate just isn't...

Then he's doing a great job!

GOT to be the funniest, and yet most accurate reply EVER!!! Most Giant fans have NO idea why Diehl is still on our roster. Vet minimum is too much to pay him.

The Giants have given up more than 6,000 yards in a season only twice in history. Guess which 2 years? Yep, 2011 and 2012.

You likely know that most are referring to the very weak AFC East and that the Pats usually win 5 or 6 of those games every year.

A man with a plan!!! Build a strong Oline again and see if Eli looks like a better QB. We all know he's not very elusive, but he does get rid of the ball without taking sacks. Sadly you are so...

The "whole dome thing" is surely not overrated for piling up stats. Be honest - wouldn't a QB want to play in 75 degrees with no cold, wind, or rain issues?

Looks a little "too sweet" to me, especially that hair!

"New ideas and thinking"? From the Giants? NOOOOWAYYYY that's happening! Eli runs a great no huddle offense (see just before the half in the Saints game), but how often do we run that? Almost...

In 2011 our receivers actually created separation and Eli made nice intermediate throws. This year, with Nicks being hurt and Cruz getting A LOT more attention, we didn't create that separation and...

SO, maybe YOU are "still waiting for the breakout season" when most of us know that we saw it in 2011. Almost 5k yards and mostly heroic efforts. You did say that he carried the team last year to...

"Thoughts" would include you expressing yourself in intelligent sentences with appropriate spelling, grammar, and punctuation!

I agree with everything you said EXCEPT that "we were taken out of field goal range". From memory the attempt was a little more than 50 yards. Plenty of NFL kickers don't consider that out of their...

I've been making these points for a LONG time. Our offensive schemes are stale. Our receivers rarely get separation at all. OC needs to change and NOW.

100% right. Our play calling is SO stale. Good defensive coaches absolutely know our plays and game plan for us extremely well. Coaches have to be changed from time to time, and it's time!!!

Kinda like we didn't need a franchise QB to win SB 46 when we had, statistically, the WORST running game in the league? Perhaps your definition of "succeed" is different than others. We want to WIN...

Ok, come on now, don't compare Eli's one TD pass to Ben's one TD pass in their SB victories. Pretty sure Ben had the lowest QBR by far of any Super Bowl winning QB when he won his first one.

Well, if outrunning SEC defenses is your definition of slow, then he's REALLY slow!!! This is a crazy thread though, because there aren't many 6'1" QB's in pro football. He is, however, VERY fast.

Actually, I hate to agree with you, but you probably got it about right. HOWEVER, is he only 6th in clutch situations in the playoffs? Likely higher than that!

Awesome analysis and right on the money. This is the NFL, QB's who run should pay a price. Against us they get rewarded. Seeing Osi crash down inside on every fake hand off is amazing - remember...

+1000000000

Exactly right. When the other team stops the run well - guess what? You don't continually try to run. And if they don't defend the pass well - you throw the ball more. UNBELIEVABLE game planning...

Yeah, you're right, but there's a reason for that. Trying to run the ball too much when that's the other team's strength is pure Giants "hard-headedness" from the coaching staff. When the other...

Well, if our defense would MAN UP and get themselves off the field with a few 3 and outs, then they wouldn't be exhausted would they? Sometimes the Giants go 3 and out, but we don't seem to expect...