Search:

Type: Posts; User: simmstolt

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.03 seconds.

  1. Replies
    35
    Views
    1,128

    Coughing knows about as much about player...

    Coughing knows about as much about player management as Coughlin...
  2. Replies
    66
    Views
    1,808

    The first 11 games of 2008 is the best I have...

    The first 11 games of 2008 is the best I have ever seen a Giants team play.
  3. Replies
    24
    Views
    518

    The 2007 and 2011 teams were underachieving, so...

    The 2007 and 2011 teams were underachieving, so many were upset. They both magically turned it around, 2 of the unlikeliest runs in NFL history. Expecting that a 3rd time with an aging qb, a rookie...
  4. 6 of those guys have battled injuries and the...

    6 of those guys have battled injuries and the other three are young. Nicks was a great pick but didn't last long. I still wish we had taken Iupati over JPP, especially at this point (yeah, I know,...
  5. Yup, but this is TC...Herzlich for the...

    Yup, but this is TC...Herzlich for the win...err...loss.
  6. I am basing it on 6+ years of performances,...

    I am basing it on 6+ years of performances, especially the last 3 years, excepting a couple months thanks to a hot QB.
  7. Replies
    72
    Views
    2,424

    I'm all for a pessimistic bent on the current...

    I'm all for a pessimistic bent on the current state of the Giants but Cruz gets a pass. The dude wasn't even drafted yet has been better than any pick JR has made. He got injured and may be close...
  8. Replies
    191
    Views
    2,968

    Right, and you are arguing consistently that they...

    Right, and you are arguing consistently that they will be better this year despite that with a rookie LT, Pugh moving, without the only good vet on the dline, and with a decimated safety core that...
  9. Replies
    191
    Views
    2,968

    Who got shut out against the Eagles in the...

    Who got shut out against the Eagles in the critical game of the season? As I said, there are far worse problems than Eli but rebuilding around an aging qb and the oldest coach in the league plus a...
  10. Replies
    72
    Views
    2,424

    Much rather see a healthy VC for next season than...

    Much rather see a healthy VC for next season than rush him back. I am more than ok with him sitting, that was a devastating injury. Fans should have zero expectations of him contributing much this...
  11. Replies
    191
    Views
    2,968

    Carry over to another 6-10 season? Losing 7...

    Carry over to another 6-10 season? Losing 7 games in a row including getting shut out against Philly? What are you talking about? There are far worse problems than Eli but, again, what...
  12. Replies
    191
    Views
    2,968

    Your thread on Parker for starters...

    Your thread on Parker for starters...
  13. Replies
    191
    Views
    2,968

    Being a bit presumptive about this year, you are...

    Being a bit presumptive about this year, you are correct.
  14. Replies
    191
    Views
    2,968

    You mean like the rah rah crowd who talk about...

    You mean like the rah rah crowd who talk about SB's and refuse to look at last season? 6-10 and no playoffs 4 years in a row works for you?
  15. Replies
    191
    Views
    2,968

    So being pathologically positive with zero...

    So being pathologically positive with zero evidence backing it is the correct move? Got it...
  16. Replies
    70
    Views
    1,682

    Good post. I love what Eli has done overall and,...

    Good post. I love what Eli has done overall and, while I think it is a bad idea to tie up money in him long term, comparing him to RGIII is ridiculous.

    II just think that Eli requires too much...
  17. Replies
    191
    Views
    2,968

    If the offense comes together I see a ceiling of...

    If the offense comes together I see a ceiling of 8-8. I think 9-7 and playoffs is wishful thinking, excepting Dallas and Philly and having major injuries. Expecting much from Cruz, JPP or Beatty is...
  18. Yup, surprised he has been out there at all...

    Yup, surprised he has been out there at all really. I wouldn't expect much from VC this year, next year we'll see how much this affects him long-term.
  19. Replies
    135
    Views
    1,438

    Diehl was a great Giant during his prime but was...

    Diehl was a great Giant during his prime but was a victim of organizational "loyalty" and a GM and HC's inability to recognize fundamental decline in the most important part of winning on the field,...
  20. When did you become a fan? You seem extremely...

    When did you become a fan? You seem extremely optimistic...
  21. Replies
    90
    Views
    2,480

    +1, sounds like we started watching around the...

    +1, sounds like we started watching around the same time and this is exactly how I feel.
  22. Replies
    51
    Views
    1,278

    The problem with this logic is the oft pointed to...

    The problem with this logic is the oft pointed to argument "none of those guys did anything after they left the Giants" says more as to their lack of quality to begin with than the FO doing the right...
  23. Since the 70's here

    Since the 70's here
  24. Poll: TP - It doesn't have shoulders to shrug.

    TP - It doesn't have shoulders to shrug.
  25. Coughlin has never shown the fortitude to play...

    Coughlin has never shown the fortitude to play the most deserving player, Giant loyalty to vets far beyond a fault.
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4