Search:

Type: Posts; User: MaekloTau

Search: Search took 0.00 seconds.

  1. Replies
    22
    Views
    952

    haha

    haha
  2. I disagree. If I recall, Kerry Collins was just...

    I disagree. If I recall, Kerry Collins was just piling up the points at the end of that season. I'm not saying its probable but it was possible we could have beaten TB. They did not have a very good...
  3. I agree with this statement except for where you...

    I agree with this statement except for where you say "4 hands must reach the ball at the same time." Why can it be 3 hands? Are catches solely made with one hand not considered catches?
  4. Catch: the full act of catching the ball meaning...

    Catch: the full act of catching the ball meaning from the moment you gain control (see below for definition) to when you get 2 feet in and go to the ground etc. THIS IS NOT AN INSTANTANEOUS MOMENT.
    ...
  5. Yes but this is not the issue of concern. The...

    Yes but this is not the issue of concern. The only issue of concern is who gained "control" of the football first. The completer act of catching the ball and obtaining control of the ball are two...
  6. I think the part of the rule we need to focus on...

    I think the part of the rule we need to focus on is as follows "It is not a simultaneous catch if a player gains control first and an opponent subsequently gains joint control." By the time the ball...
  7. We are trying to discuss this like civilized...

    We are trying to discuss this like civilized people, please express your viewpoint in football terms without insulting.
  8. Although Jennings clearly had possession of the...

    Although Jennings clearly had possession of the ball in 2 hands, wasn't Tate holding the ball in his left palm all the way to the ground as well? Does this not constitute a simultaneous catch?
  9. Were the refs right on the Greenbay Seattle Catch?.. Please Clarify

    Aside from the blatant OPI, I still donít see how this is such an obvious interception according to the rule of the simultaneous catch. From what I see, they both touched the ball at virtually the...
Results 1 to 9 of 9