Search:

Type: Posts; User: Bigbluefan4

Page 1 of 9 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. Replies
    62
    Views
    2,092

    Opinions are what makes this fun. Hard to tell...

    Opinions are what makes this fun. Hard to tell where he would have went had the giants not taken him.....would have to know all the other draft boards to label him a reach.
  2. Replies
    62
    Views
    2,092

    Thank you

    Thank you
  3. I think that is very fair about Romo. I believe...

    I think that is very fair about Romo. I believe he was ranked pretty high on the list of QB 4th quarter comebacks. And you are right about supporting cast. Was it Clayton that dropped that ball in...
  4. It does seem unfair to leave Eli off the list,...

    It does seem unfair to leave Eli off the list, especially when the article itself included a list of most 4th quarter comebacks and Eli was 3rd on the list. I think Eli does hold the single season...
  5. I have a lot of love for both BP and TC. Aren't...

    I have a lot of love for both BP and TC. Aren't their records similar in terms of their time with the giants?
  6. Yes, you have a good point. I just considered the...

    Yes, you have a good point. I just considered the SBs.
  7. 2-0 head to head should count for something. As...

    2-0 head to head should count for something. As for Spags, I'm not trying to take anything alway form the job he did, but TC approves the game plan, and Spags wasn't around for the second time around
  8. TCs resume is HOF quality. Those 3 have a ways to...

    TCs resume is HOF quality. Those 3 have a ways to go.
  9. True. I do think the head to head wins should get...

    True. I do think the head to head wins should get TC closer to BB than his number 5 spot
  10. Top 5 is great, no question. It is just hard for...

    Top 5 is great, no question. It is just hard for me to put a guy with 0 SB wins ahead of a guy with 2.
  11. I Agree as well. Their resumes' are not as...

    I Agree as well. Their resumes' are not as accomplished as TC. Maybe combined.
  12. 100%. As far as luck goes (mentioned in another...

    100%. As far as luck goes (mentioned in another post), every SB winner had some bounce or call go their way.
  13. I recall cris collinsworth contrasting the giants...

    I recall cris collinsworth contrasting the giants downfield approach against how p manning takes the underneath stuff and takes his shots when presented. I Eli is not Peyton, but SB 46 seemed to have...
  14. As far as style of play goes, do you think an...

    As far as style of play goes, do you think an offense based on west coast principles might help?
  15. I like Rich Gannon too. I disagree with some of...

    I like Rich Gannon too. I disagree with some of his thoughts as well. Maybe someone should ask him if anyone thought he would throw 5 INTs in a SB at that point in his career.
  16. [QUOTE=Morehead State;1182723]Think back on...

    [QUOTE=Morehead State;1182723]Think back on Giants teams of the past.
    What Giants QB has had better WR's than Eli Manning?[/

    Definitely a fair point. I was really intending to say much more going...
  17. I agree with you that at times it is certainly...

    I agree with you that at times it is certainly his fault. I don't think baseball would always be the best comparison because at the plate it's hitter vs pitcher. There is no one one for a qb. There...
  18. I agree with your thoughts on the OC's...

    I agree with your thoughts on the OC's responsibility to scheme around the talent on the team. As for the underneath stuff, Eli did a nice job is SB 46. I want to say he was around 75%
  19. Replies
    35
    Views
    1,492

    Fact

    Fact
  20. Very true. I understand part of being a fan is...

    Very true. I understand part of being a fan is second guessing the team's decisions, but it does seem we forget the folks making these decisions are the best at what they do, and they invest millions...
  21. Replies
    51
    Views
    2,115

    [QUOTE=moosedrool;1168498]Nothing wrong with...

    [QUOTE=moosedrool;1168498]Nothing wrong with being optimistic, but there are too many question marks on the OL and at TE, plus the learning curve of a new offense. I think scary potential is a...
  22. Replies
    51
    Views
    2,530

    That is very fair

    That is very fair
  23. Replies
    51
    Views
    2,530

    Now now, be fair....how long was he a pro under...

    Now now, be fair....how long was he a pro under huffnagle? Not too many qbs nail it right out of the gate
  24. Replies
    29
    Views
    1,631

    Well said

    Well said
  25. Replies
    104
    Views
    2,253

    Awesome. And that clip does prove my recollection...

    Awesome. And that clip does prove my recollection wrong
Results 1 to 25 of 204
Page 1 of 9 1 2 3 4