Search:

To me that just seems like too many safeties and not enough capable cbs.....not saying I am right...just saying To me it doesn't make sense

Exactly....sounds a lot like a MLB that is no longer here

Agreed

I am not questioning his value....I am just not sure giving up young talent is worth it....I still see it as... if we sign him we lose either taylor or hill....I think Sash is gone anyway....possible...

I understand what you are saying about hill....but if 3 cbs get hurt .....not unheard of on this team....do you want Hill playing cb?

Possible.... but Hill is a safety not a cornerback and with that roster you have 6 safety's or 5 if taylor is LB...and 4 cbs....Honestly not sure that works....I just do not see room for woodson...

Would have to be someone that is a 3 down player....my impression is Connor is not.....Honestly with all the substitutions for different downs and distance...3 down players are getting few on the...

Yupp....forgot about him...so I ask again ...where does he fit?

Not a bum...Has been well respected ,true Giant...but as I said ....everyone(even you and I)gets old

Boothe is signed to a 1 yr deal and Snee is getting to the end...This line is going to have some changes in next few years....collect good young athletes and may the better man win

RF it was a joke to your statement....I love what he has done for the giants....I just think his time is up

Snee doesn't enter into this at all? I seriously doubt he loses his spot yet.....My guess would be Beatty-Boothe-bass-Snee-Pugh

getting torched?

The biggest concern of this thread seems to be money....just out of curiosity ...how do you guys see us fitting him on the roster?.....Currently consists of Rolle,Brown,Hill,Taylor and...

was thinking same thing...but I have always been a JJ supporter and still feel that Gilbride just needs to be more creative in using him.....needs to find ways to get him in space

will you please stop using logic...you confuse everyone

I almost think haters root against certain players ...just so they can come here and say ...I told you so....blah blah blah

I do not think you are much different than most people on this board......We all think we know more than the front office....lol

LOL you are right we could have the "which came first ? the chicken or the egg "debate...bottom line is it would be nice to get the play off sooner........I just see it as a lot less of Eli's fault...

wow this one will kill all the" Eli is perfect supporters".......Just my opinion but most of the time Getting the play off quicker is more a function of quickly he gets the play from the sideline as...

I believe Ernie Acorsi said that and now Reese just follows that philosophy.....I think it was right after he drafted Kiwi

Are you saying you wouldn't trade the Mara?Tisch combo for say, Jerry Jones?

This sounds quite accurate to me

Even when he does make a tackle ...he is usually dragged 5 yds .......Everyone gets enamored with the few big plays he makes and over looks all the common plays he should make that he doesn't

down 10-9