Average WR Manningham

[ibbill]

Okay I will say it he's just and average WR. #3 at best.

Who ever takes his place will play as well or better with Nicks Cruz and Eli throwing. Nyg will not miss a beat without him.There I said it and now lets here it.

[G-Men Surg.]

He was a playmaker in Michigan and he ended being another one at the pro level. Period .

[TheEnigma]

Of course he looks average here. We're spoiled with Nicks and Cruz.

[ibbill]

Not saying he was not good but avg at best. Will see how well he does in TB and if I am wrong will come back and apologize on bended knee.Will say I was WRONG

[jakegibbs]

[quote user="ibbill"]Okay I will say it he's just and average WR. #3 at best.

Who ever takes his place will play as well or better with Nicks Cruz and Eli throwing. Nyg will not miss a beat without him.There I said it and now lets here it.[/quote]

If Hixon can come back & be the player he was 3 years ago then they have a chance of not missing a beat I would think anyway. That's a big if though.

[NY_Eli]

Year Team Games Rec Yards Y/R TDs
2009 Giants 14 57 822 14.7 5
2010 Giants 16 60 944 15.7 9
2011 Giants 12 39 523 13.4 4


These are not AVERAGE STATS

[ibbill]

[quote user="NY_Eli"]Year Team Games Rec Yards Y/R TDs
2009 Giants 14 57 822 14.7 5
2010 Giants 16 60 944 15.7 9
2011 Giants 12 39 523 13.4 4


These are not AVERAGE STATS[/quote]

2009 he was 42 on the rec list

2010 41 st

2011 99th

What would you say is average.

[miked1958]

[quote user="ibbill"]Okay I will say it he's just and average WR. #3 at best.

Who ever takes his place will play as well or better with Nicks Cruz and Eli throwing. Nyg will not miss a beat without him.There I said it and now lets here it.[/quote]
I agree. I think Thomas, barden or JJ could step right in and give us the exact same or better production...

[miked1958]

[quote user="jakegibbs"][quote user="ibbill"]Okay I will say it he's just and average WR. #3 at best.

Who ever takes his place will play as well or better with Nicks Cruz and Eli throwing. Nyg will not miss a beat without him.There I said it and now lets here it.[/quote]

If Hixon can come back & be the player he was 3 years ago then they have a chance of not missing a beat I would think anyway. That's a big if though.[/quote]
Sad to say this but with his injury issues I don't think he makes it out of camp this season without being Cut

[gianttuffguy]

He was part of our big 3 now we gotta move on i say bring in a decent vet (ocho cinco) to push jj,barden plus draft one in the 2nd or 3rd round we will be fine but we nees wr depth bad god forbid nicks or cruz miss a few gms