Who do you take?

[Morehead State]

[quote user="slipknottin"][quote user="Morehead State"] I don't think the "we don't have enough DT's on the roster" philosophy will compel them to draft a DT in round one, unless its truly the BPA.[/quote] I dont think they will reach to fill the position, but I do think its a position of need.[/quote]</P>


I agree that its a position of need. I still think that the running game is probably the largest need we have.</P>


By that I mean a RB or O lineman.</P>


And I think Wilson and Martin are good values at 32. (especially Wilson IMO)</P>

[Shockeyitus]

[quote user="Morehead State"]

[quote user="slipknottin"][quote user="Morehead State"] I don't think the "we don't have enough DT's on the roster" philosophy will compel them to draft a DT in round one, unless its truly the BPA.[/quote] I dont think they will reach to fill the position, but I do think its a position of need.[/quote]</P>


I agree that its a position of need.* I still think that the running game is probably the largest need we have.</P>


By that I mean a RB or O lineman.</P>


And I think Wilson and Martin are good values at 32.* (especially Wilson IMO)</P>[/quote]

Im not sold on Wilson. He seems like more of an athlete with good gene's, rather than a future star at running back. Obviously, Richardson is the prize of the class, but in regards to football talent I think Wilson is fifth on my list.

Richardson - Best back since AP
Miller - Incredible vision, patient and speed.
Martin - catches, blocks, decent speed.
James - deadly receiving threat, could be shifty between the tackles
Wilson - Speed....??

[BlueBlooded1979]

[quote user="Spizi"]If Devon Still, Nick Perry, and Coby Fleener are all still available at 32 who do you take and why?[/quote]

To actually answer your question I would take Devon Still. The knock on him in inconsistent tape. I believe that the Giant DL group would push him to maximize his talents. The seem to have the right mix of knowing how to work and keeping it loose. If a guy comes in there and doesn't play to his potential it simply won't fly in that room.

Nothing wrong with Perry either but I think over the next 3 years Still would see more snaps. With Osi and Kiwi both becoming UFAs after this season Perry isn't a bad play at all.