hindsight draft 2012

[lawl]

Now that we know who would have went where. What picks would you want the giants to have made

[hugehomer]

The same ones they made.

[Kruunch]

Adrien Robinson was the only pick that really had me scratching my head. I would have picked up George Iloka (instead of Janzen Jackson as a UDFA and grabbed Robinson as a UDFA instead).

Otherwise the whole draft, value wise was a home run by and large.

Now to see if they actually get that value out of them.

[critters]

RD1: Courtney Upshaw (can't believe he made it out of the first round)
RD2: Sanu (I'm fine with RR, but he's gonna have to do more than he did in college.. didn't have much of a qb though)
RD3: Massie or Lamar Miller
RD4: Dequan Menzie
RD4: Senio Kelemete or Vick Ballard
RD6: McCants or Cam Johnson
RD7: Kuhn

[juice33s]

[quote user="Kruunch"]Adrien Robinson was the only pick that really had me scratching my head. I would have picked up George Iloka (instead of Janzen Jackson as a UDFA and<font size="4"> grabbed Robinson as a UDFA instead)</font>.

Otherwise the whole draft, value wise was a home run by and large.

Now to see if they actually get that value out of them.[/quote]
Lol, u have so little faith in the Giants management that you think they picked an UDFA in the 4th round?.....after his pro day I heard a number of NFL people calling him a mid round pick

[nevada11]

[quote user="juice33s"][quote user="Kruunch"]Adrien Robinson was the only pick that really had me scratching my head. I would have picked up George Iloka (instead of Janzen Jackson as a UDFA and<font size="4"> grabbed Robinson as a UDFA instead)</font>.

Otherwise the whole draft, value wise was a home run by and large.

Now to see if they actually get that value out of them.[/quote]
Lol, u have so little faith in the Giants management that you think they picked an UDFA in the 4th round?.....after his pro day I heard a number of NFL people calling him a mid round pick
[/quote]

Where did you "hear" this

Just because the giants had a high grade on him doesnt mean the rest of the NFL did. Anything other than such is pure speculation. He could have easily gone 7th round just as easily he could have gone 3rd round

[nevada11]

If I had to redo the draft:

1- Brian Quick
2- Dwayne Allen
3- Bobbie Massie
4 - Jared Crick (t/ up)
7 - DaJohn Harris

[michaelkhan3]

I would have gone

1 Glenn
2 Randle
3 Lamar Miller

and keep the rest about the same maybe get a CB somewhere

[Neverend]

Honestly I'd keep things the same but instead draft Juron crier with their 6th. And perhaps cam johnson with their 7th

[gmen0820]

1. Coby Fleener

2. Trumaine Johnson

3. Cyrus Gray or Lamar Miller

4a. Greg Childs or George Iloka

4b. Marvin Jones or George Iloka

6. Nate Potter

7. Andrew Datko