Ha! Obviously Matt Light is gonna go for his homeboy Brady.
Eli might now have the stats or whatever for other categories, but he is definitely Mr. Clutch. Brady wasn't the one that won those Supberbowls, history will show it was their clutch kicker Vinateiri. After he left he went on to win another ring while the Patriots have yet to win anything.
Eli pretty much won those games for the Giants (although I guess Bradshaw's squat and pop wasn't Eli's doing, but he definitely set them up.) A-Vin hit some serious kicks in order for them to win.
It's definitely not just one player, but you're kidding yourself if you don't think Eli is the most clutch quarterback in the league right now. Maybe Brady in his prime was, or even slightly before his prime, but he's not anymore. I think hitting his prime might've made Brady complacent.