Eli 5th on Jaws QB Countdown

[FeaglesPuntsEaglesRunts]

No surprise here, wouldn't expect former-Eagle and notorious Giants hater Jaws to give Eli the credit he deserves.

I guess he picked him as a top 5... behind 2 guys he beat in the playoffs, a guy who leads a team he swept last year and a guy that hasn't played in a year and a half. Eli has more rings than 3 of those guys, and more SB MVPs as well.

Should at least be above Peyton, considering we have no idea if Peyton is still the QB he was.

[MattMeyerBud]

[quote user="FeaglesPuntsEaglesRunts"]No surprise here, wouldn't expect former-Eagle and notorious Giants hater Jaws to give Eli the credit he deserves.

I guess he picked him as a top 5... behind 2 guys he beat in the playoffs, a guy who leads a team he swept last year and a guy that hasn't played in a year and a half. Eli has more rings than 3 of those guys, and more SB MVPs as well.

Should at least be above Peyton, considering we have no idea if Peyton is still the QB he was.
[/quote]</P>


</P>


hard to discredit Breez, Brady, Peyton, or Rodgers</P>


</P>


I think it was a fair ranking as of right now</P>

[thomsoad]

I got no issues with 5th. Until the INTS come down thats a pretty fair assessment. Its not like he is below Romo, Flacco, or Big Ben

[FeaglesPuntsEaglesRunts]

[quote user="MattMeyerBud"]

[quote user="FeaglesPuntsEaglesRunts"]No surprise here, wouldn't expect former-Eagle and notorious Giants hater Jaws to give Eli the credit he deserves.

I guess he picked him as a top 5... behind 2 guys he beat in the playoffs, a guy who leads a team he swept last year and a guy that hasn't played in a year and a half. Eli has more rings than 3 of those guys, and more SB MVPs as well.

Should at least be above Peyton, considering we have no idea if Peyton is still the QB he was.
[/quote]</p>


</p>


hard to discredit Breez, Brady, Peyton, or Rodgers</p>


</p>


I think it was a fair ranking as of right now</p>[/quote]

Honestly my biggest gripe is the fact that Peyton Manning, who had more neck surgeries than snaps last year is ahead of the reigning Superbowl MVP.

Based on that, I'm surprised Andrew Luck and RGIII didn't make the list; they played just as many games as Peyton did.

[burier]

lol.

Eli should be moved up 4 spots.

But watch my smoke. Week 6

[b_ELI_eve]

[quote user="FeaglesPuntsEaglesRunts"][quote user="MattMeyerBud"]

[quote user="FeaglesPuntsEaglesRunts"]No surprise here, wouldn't expect former-Eagle and notorious Giants hater Jaws to give Eli the credit he deserves.

I guess he picked him as a top 5... behind 2 guys he beat in the playoffs, a guy who leads a team he swept last year and a guy that hasn't played in a year and a half. Eli has more rings than 3 of those guys, and more SB MVPs as well.

Should at least be above Peyton, considering we have no idea if Peyton is still the QB he was.
[/quote]</p>


*</p>


hard to discredit Breez, Brady, Peyton, or Rodgers</p>


*</p>


I think it was a fair ranking as of right now</p>[/quote]

Honestly my biggest gripe is the fact that Peyton Manning, who had more neck surgeries than snaps last year is ahead of the reigning Superbowl MVP.

Based on that, I'm surprised Andrew Luck and RGIII didn't make the list; they played just as many games as Peyton did.
[/quote]

Stop being so sour. Eli at #5 is just fine. Gives him more of a reason to go out this season and show the "experts" how wrong they are.

[greenca190]

[quote user="FeaglesPuntsEaglesRunts"]No surprise here, wouldn't expect former-Eagle and notorious Giants hater Jaws to give Eli the credit he deserves.

I guess he picked him as a top 5... behind 2 guys he beat in the playoffs, a guy who leads a team he swept last year and a guy that hasn't played in a year and a half. Eli has more rings than 3 of those guys, and more SB MVPs as well.

Should at least be above Peyton, considering we have no idea if Peyton is still the QB he was.
[/quote]

A notorious Giant hater putting their quarterback at fifth best in the league?

If the guy let his opinions of teams influence his job, Eli wouldn't be placed fifth on his list.

Jaws is one of the easier analysts on ESPN to listen to.

[BigBlue1971]

[quote user="FeaglesPuntsEaglesRunts"]No surprise here, wouldn't expect former-Eagle and notorious Giants hater Jaws to give Eli the credit he deserves.

I guess he picked him as a top 5... behind 2 guys he beat in the playoffs, a guy who leads a team he swept last year and a guy that hasn't played in a year and a half. Eli has more rings than 3 of those guys, and more SB MVPs as well.

Should at least be above Peyton, considering we have no idea if Peyton is still the QB he was.
[/quote]</P>


</P>


i think Eli should be ahead of Peyton at this point! hard to jump ahead of Brees, Rodgers and Brady although he did play better down the stretch than any of those guys.</P>


id rate Eli a solid 4th in the league now!</P>

[GMENAGAIN]

[quote user="MattMeyerBud"]


[quote user="FeaglesPuntsEaglesRunts"]No surprise here, wouldn't expect former-Eagle and notorious Giants hater Jaws to give Eli the credit he deserves.

I guess he picked him as a top 5... behind 2 guys he beat in the playoffs, a guy who leads a team he swept last year and a guy that hasn't played in a year and a half. Eli has more rings than 3 of those guys, and more SB MVPs as well.

Should at least be above Peyton, considering we have no idea if Peyton is still the QB he was.
[/quote]</P>


</P>


hard to discredit Breez, Brady, Peyton, or Rodgers</P>


</P>


I think it was a fair ranking as of right now</P>


[/quote]</P>


Totally agree.</P>


Ha ha . . . . look at the Eli picture that PFT has on its article about Eli being number 5 on Jaws' list . . . .</P>


http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com...e-quarterback/</P>

[gumby742]

I think that's fair.