1.QB Eli= Mike Vick (Mike Vick is the better runner but is that what a QB is all about no) Eli more clutch better passing read defenses better the edge goes to Eli
2.WR= Maclin ,Jackson, Avant,=Cruz ,Nicks, Randle ( he will be the starter and 3rd wr) IMHO the Giants have the better receivers they are more physical are willing to go across the middle and Cruz and Nicks are just as homerun threats as maclin and jackson also better blockers
3.RB= you have the egde but the postion is not as valued as it once was and with Jacobs leaving your losing leadership but you get an speedy athletic pass catching RB with Wilson and the combination of Bradshaw's power I don't know if it is really an advantage for your team anymore.
4.TE= Brent Celic is good not great and Martellus Bennet has a lot to prove this year he is also a big target for a better passing QB in the redzone something Eli desperately needed you know how many more TD'S were left by the giants cause they didn't have a big tall strong fast TE and Randle at 6'3 also gives him that.
5.Secondary yours is consider better but with the loss of samuels I think it got worse and our secondary has T2 back so we'll have to see
6. O-line yours is better
7.D-line ours is definitely better and anyone who say's different is dead wrong we got more depth with Osi and that with Tuck,JPP, Canty. I'll take that line overs anyone's.
8.LB= When Boley went down our defense was all over now with him healthy and JW coming on and kiwi I think that is a formidable LB core so where is the clear cut advantage that your E-girls have I don't see one. I'm personally more worried about the Cow****s more then your E-girls cause Mike Vick I think is very overrated and will be exposed again this year
WR... a rookie is'nt going to help you mush in the beginning and Nicks had a broken Foot... NOT easy to come back from... after that you've got Cruz... He Better step it up because with Nicks recovering and a rookie... HE is gonna be #1 for a bit and I don't think he can handle that YET.
RB... well all i can say is you've got that right... but wilson is known to have fumblitis... which MAY or may NOT be a problem this year
TE... Celek put up darn good numbers for a guy with a bad hip and a sports hernia all last year... he's healthy now... BIG edge to us.
Secondary... Samuel was a liability in press coverage, DRC and Nnamdi are FAR better than he was... and since they are gonna use more Press Man this year... It was a good trade.
O line.... you're right.
D Line.... I think you're underestimating our D Line... 46 sacks last year and all but 5 from the front 4... we also have depth... I think that is about even.
LB... Ryans makes a difference, Rolle is in His second Year, Cheney Becomes a backup, Matthews is a spot guy who will get better, Kendricks LOOKS like a beast... but he's still a rookie so I don't really count on him... all In all... We have an advantage at RB,WR, Secondary, and TE... THAT's Significant.
Mean people suck... Nice People swallow.