I just wanted to get some opinions on two great Giants qb's. I know this topic is difficult to make comparisonsí, but letís have some fun anyways.
I think it's safe to say Phil Simms is the bar that is set as to who the best qb this franchise has ever seen. I know we have had some great qb's play for us. Ex. YA Tittle, Charlie Conerly, Fran Tarkenton, I would even put Kerry Collins in the conversation. He may not have been great, but he gave us some real good years.
It's up to debate where Eli Manning is right now, 2 super bowl rings and still at the prime of his career.
Here are the first 8 seasons of Simms and Manningís career.
Simms: 19,815 yds. 121 td's.
Manning: 27,579 yds. 185 td's
*We have to put into the equation Simms being hurt a lot in the beginning of his career*
*And the league has changed since Simms was playing*
So I ask my fellow fans, where do you rank Eli with Simms?
I know Eli's career is not done by a long shot, but would like to hear some opinions on these two all-time greats.