Just curious what you guys think about CARR?

[NJBLUE]

I don't know much about him, but dude sure can run. Also, he seemed comfortable out there. What do you guys think about him?

[rainierjef]

above average serviceable back up. could of been good if the texans had an O-line to begin with, but he knew what he was getting into with an expansion team.

[GameTime]

As fast as he is and even the fact that he was a #1 pick and starter in the league for years he STILL holds on to the ball way too long many times. He needs to throw the ****er or run past the LOS......

[greenca190]

we should try him at running back. or h-back. that stands for white running back, right?

[Syverce]

He never got over his time in Texas. He still hears footsteps on almost every play. He is a reliable backup though. Doesn't have the hilarity factor that J-Load had, but I'm still glad to have him.

[moo]

One of the best backups in the league.

[krygny]

He's no Tim Tebow.

Thank goodness for that.

[RagTime Blue]

He'll do for now, but I'd like to Giants to investigate the future of that position. That is, find someone who has potential to be more than a backup.

With Carr at starting QB, I think the Giants would go 5-11.

[Moke]

Good back-up QB for sure. I feel comfortable with him back there.

[gmen46]

He'll do for now, but I'd like to Giants to investigate the future of that position. That is, find someone who has potential to be more than a backup.

With Carr at starting QB, I think the Giants would go 5-11.

"Someone who has potential to be more than a backup"? What does that mean? A starting QB to be a back up to Eli?

Good luck finding a QB of starting quality to accept sitting on the bench--and accepting a back-up's pay, because the Giants are not going to pay starter salary for a back-up--for the next 6-7 years.

And if circumstances dictated Carr being our starter for an entire season, we'd have far greater concerns than having Carr being our starter for an entire season.