Who do you guys feel is the most underrated Giants player and overrated Giants player?
Underrated, Id say Corey Webster. He still has never made the probowl, yet for the past 4 or 5 years has been a top CB in the league in my opinion. QBs normally pick on our other CB like Ross or T2 or Prince. Its a shame he doesnt get the recognition he deserves, but the Giants FO knows exactly what they have in #23. A very reliable, durable, top flight CB.
Overrated, tough to do as a fan, but Id stickl with the CB position and say Terrell Thomas. Tough to do now with the injuries he has had the past few years, but even in his "breakout" year I felt like he was way overrated. He got twice as many plays his way because of CWeb being on the other side, which led to his high tackle count and most INTs on the team. I remember a few of those INTs were actually deflected by someone else and landed in his lap. I always felt like he had no deep ball skills. He got abused a bunch by WRs being more physical then him and going over the top.