Quote Originally Posted by Riverboat76 View Post
What does that prove exactly? The Giants WRs have never been strong, this is the best they have had. So Nicks might be the best Giant WR ever. That's like saying Josh Freeman might be the best Bucs QB ever. A statement that may sound impressive but then you look to see who you are comparing him too and its much less impressive.
Even comparing him to any other receiver in the league he is a top ten talent. Simply compare him to receivers in his own draft class and there might be one (Mike Wallace) that you'd want more than him. Jeremy Maclin, Michael Crabtree, Darius Heyward-Bey, Kenny Britt, Percy Harvin, Mike Wallace.


There's no date on this article, but it's obviously a year or so old. By now the debate would be Mike Wallace vs. Hakeem Nicks. And I can't really listen to John Clayton because I think he'd an idiot. Almost everyone in the media is biased against the Giants and will do anything to point out the negatives to any side of a story.