I like that the 49er fans give Eli some props!
Those saying he would have to make adjustments to their offense - don't you think they wouldn't be running that offense if they had a better quarterback? Their offense doesn't truly rely around a QB, whereas if they had Eli or a higher caliber QB it would. Props to Alex Smith though, he's improved tremendously and hasn't had it easy with different coaches pretty much every year.
I didn't believe the increased productivity to the defense would offset the offensive productivity decrease to that move..
Niner fan here. Why is this even a question? No one in the league would.
No. Ask the question at 730 means, this might be the worst question in the history of ****ing sports. Would you rather have a game manager who in big games looks for the grass to be open before his wide outs, or a two time Super Bowl MVP who is on pace to be the leagues most valuable player? If you can't find absurdity in that submission, then holy ****.
Alex Smith would trade Alex Smith for Eli Manning.
Giants fan since the early 80s