Eli Manning isn't even in his prime yet.

[Paul Newman]

Right now he's in his composite. He's not in his prime quite yet. To really prove himself even a half decent quarterback, he needs to win the next 6 Super Bowls all in a row. Until he does that, he'll remain no better than a Cleveland Browns QB back up.

[repeatchamps]

Right now he's in his composite. He's not in his prime quite yet. To really prove himself even a half decent quarterback, he needs to win the next 6 Super Bowls all in a row. Until he does that, he'll remain no better than a Cleveland Browns QB back up.

Fixed.

[ashleymarie]

You are correct. Eli is a bust so far.

[MustWarnOthers]

I'm thinking if we go for Philip Rivers, we can probably trade off Eli, Nicks, Cruz and maybe an extra 1st round pick to sweeten the deal. Remember the saying from "Talladega Nights"? "If you ain't first, you're last".

If you haven't won 6 straight titles back to back, you haven't won any.

Let's get this team rebuilt.

[Giants5699]

We need to trade Eli to the Eagles for a bag of footballs

[Riverboat76]

Loved you in HUD.

[rainierjef]

Trade Eli for Geno smith

[Paul Newman]

I'm thinking if we go for Philip Rivers, we can probably trade off Eli, Nicks, Cruz and maybe an extra 1st round pick to sweeten the deal. Remember the saying from "Talladega Nights"? "If you ain't first, you're last".

If you haven't won 6 straight titles back to back, you haven't won any.

Let's get this team rebuilt.

Finally, someone as intelligent as I.

[Astorian]

Right now he's in his composite.

I have no idea what you mean by 'composite' in this context. Can you help me out?

[Rudyy]

Actually, in order for Eli to be elite, he needs to have exactly 60 touchdowns and -12 interceptions, with about 6000 yards and a QB rating of 500%. Anything less than that proves he benefits from great receivers, and a great defense. Man I wish we had Tebow