You CANNOT choose Eli, because it would be too easy.
I would have to say either Bradshaw or Cruz, but it is a hard choice. JPP might be another consideration.
Ill be clear tho, you cannot pick Eli. You cannot pick Eli's parents for giving birth to him. Nor can you pick Ernie Accorsi for drafting him or the Chargers for trading him to us. Anything related to Eli is off limmits.