The one throw vs the Redskins has masked his foul play. When Eli is on, his ceiling is right next to Peyton, Rodgers and Brady. But when he is bad, his basement is much lower than those other guys. The Giants have been lucky, very easily could have lost to both the Redskins and Cowboys and truly got dominated by the Steelers. And how awful has he been on 3rd down? Also I believe he's trying to get Victor Cruz killed.