Quote Originally Posted by Morehead State View Post
The case is very much open and always will be.

Comparing players from different eras with one stat is complete folly.
Let it go, dude. I had to accept that Drew Brees was a better QB than Archie Manning...you can do this. It was inevitable. Phil Simms will always be a great, respectable guy and QB...someone all fans can look-up to and remember fondly...but from this day on he will walk in Eli's shadow.