Phil Simms: "No, Eli Is Not One Of The Elites....."

[Harooni]

This from Pro Football Today's power ranking after week 10 games:

11. Giants: Eli Manning doesn’t have a tired arm; his arm is in a coma.

lol

[Rusty192]

I don't watch enough AFC games to actually have a real opinion. My brother though, who is a Bills fan, tells me that he drools over Tom Brady.

I've finally figured it out. Phil Simms is Morehead. And it took me this long to realize it...

[Morehead State]

NOBODY ever said Eli was the best in the league.......not even his mother.

You obviously haven't been reading this MB since SB 46.

[RoanokeFan]

Is Simms an elite analyst? Discuss.

Seriously?

[RoanokeFan]

You obviously haven't been reading this MB since SB 46.

+1

[Rusty192]

Phil Simms is one of my personal favorite former players. Someone responded that he also wasn't elite, and I agree with that. But Phil Simms was something to watch in that day and he played when beating up the QB was encouraged.

I don't think the fact that it's Phil Simms saying it makes it any worse or less/more valid than any other talking head.

yeah he's just trying to make an honest living........by stirring up ***.

[RoanokeFan]

5 pages so far. 15 more to go

[TheEnigma]

Seriously?

Poking fun at the elite labels RF. I got Mike Mayock as my #1 and I'm just not sure where to place Simms. He has his moment where he fanboys over certain players but he can be pretty objective at other times. I question his consistency.

[GameTime]

Simms is a great Giant and beloved by 99% of Giants fans and he was far from Elite.
Eli is a better overall QB (IMO) and gets less love overall. So what and who cares. Eli and his crew have two SBs. Good enough for me.....

[RoanokeFan]

yeah he's just trying to make an honest living........by stirring up ***.

That's what they do, they get paid to do it. We make that possible.